Skip to content
Menu

Trading 212 vs XTB

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Safety and regulation
  2. Costs
  3. Accounts
  4. Platforms and features
  5. Funding
  6. Markets
  7. Research and support
  8. Where the cost difference shows up
  9. Two brokers with CFD roots
  10. Which should you choose?

Trading 212 and XTB are closely matched zero-commission brokers for UK and European investors. Both offer fractional shares, a Stocks and Shares ISA and a Cash ISA, interest on cash, a demo account, and a CFD account alongside investing. Trading 212 is cheaper on currency conversion, adds a SIPP, automated Pies and an API, and has no inactivity fee. XTB adds phone support, publishes its share and ETF lists, is listed on a stock exchange, and pays interest in pounds, euros and dollars. Pick Trading 212 for the lowest overall cost and a pension. Pick XTB if you want phone support or a listed parent company. For many UK investors the deciding factor will be how much of the portfolio sits in US shares.

Minimum deposit
GBP 1
GBP 0
Max leverage
1:30 (CFD account) (FCA)
1:500 (CFDs) (FSC Belize)
Regulators
FCA, CySEC, BaFin, ASIC
FCA, KNF, CySEC, FSC Belize
Platforms
Trading 212 mobile app, Trading 212 web platform
XTB web platform, XTB mobile app
Funding methods
7
4
Trustpilot
4.6 / 5
3.8 / 5
Founded
2004
2004
Headquarters
London, United Kingdom
Warsaw, Poland

Safety and regulation

Tie. Both serve UK clients through FCA companies with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000: Trading 212 under 609146 and XTB under 522157. Both hold CySEC licenses; Trading 212 adds BaFin and ASIC, and XTB adds Poland's KNF.

XTB has been listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange since 2016. The listing brings published accounts. Trading 212 is privately held and controlled by co-founders Ivan Ashminov and Borislav Nedialkov. XTB runs a Belize entity with CFD leverage up to 1:500 (CFDs) for some international clients, while all Trading 212 entities are tier-1 regulated. The listing and the offshore entity balance out.

Costs

Winner: Trading 212. Trading 212's pricing: Commission-free. US regulatory fees apply on sales (SEC and FINRA fees). XTB charges 0% commission up to EUR 100,000 monthly turnover; 0.2% (minimum GBP 10) above that. For a typical investor, both cost nothing to deal; very large traders pay commission only at XTB.

FX is the main difference. Trading 212 charges 0.15%. XTB charges 0.5%. On US shares, XTB's conversion cost is several times Trading 212's.

Trading 212 has no custody fee, while XTB charges only on large holdings. None up to EUR 250,000 held; above that 0.02% a year, minimum GBP 10. XTB also charges for inactivity. EUR 10 a month after 12 months without trading, if no deposit was made in the last 90 days. Trading 212 does not.

Deposits at Trading 212: Bank transfer and instant bank transfer free. Card, Apple Pay and Google Pay free until GBP/EUR 2,000 has been deposited in total, then 0.7%. At XTB: Free; payment providers may charge their own fees.

Accounts

Winner: Trading 212. Trading 212 offers Stocks and Shares ISA, Cash ISA, SIPP. XTB offers Stocks and Shares ISA, Cash ISA. The SIPP is the difference.

Interest: Trading 212 pays 3.6% on GBP, 3.3% on USD and 2.4% on EUR uninvested cash, paid daily with no minimum balance (opt-in); interest is paid in 10 currencies. XTB pays 4% AER (variable) on GBP, 2.3% on EUR and 3.45% on USD uninvested funds in a general investment account. Compare the rate for the currency you hold. Trading 212 supports GBP, USD, EUR, CHF, DKK, NOK, PLN, SEK, CZK, RON, HUF, CAD, AUD; XTB supports GBP, EUR, USD. Minimum deposits are 1 GBP and 0 GBP.

Platforms and features

Winner: Trading 212. Both run a web platform and app with fractional shares, recurring investing and a demo account. Trading 212 adds Pies, dividend reinvestment, extended hours and an API. App Store ratings are 4.7 for Trading 212 and 4.7 for XTB; on Google Play, 4.7 against 4.6.

Funding

Tie. Trading 212 takes bank transfers, instant bank transfers, cards, Apple Pay, Google Pay, iDEAL and BLIK, and pays out to cards in About 1 business day. XTB takes cards, bank transfers, PayPal and Skrill, and pays out by bank Same business day if requested before 1 pm, otherwise next business day. XTB's bank payout is faster; Trading 212 has more deposit methods.

Markets

Winner: XTB. XTB publishes about 6,900 stocks and 2,300 ETFs from 14 markets. Trading 212 offers shares, ETFs, bonds and crypto but publishes no counts, so its range cannot be measured on the same basis. Neither offers options, futures or funds to UK investors.

Research and support

Split. XTB answers by live chat, email and phone, 24 hours a day, Monday to Friday. Trading 212 offers in-app support 24 hours a day, 7 days a week; no phone line. Trustpilot favors Trading 212, rated 4.6 from 108,110 reviews, against 3.8 from 3,107.

Where the cost difference shows up

For a UK investor buying UK shares and UK-listed ETFs in pounds, the two cost almost exactly the same: no commission, no custody fee and stamp duty on UK share purchases at both. The gap opens on anything priced in another currency. Every US share purchase is converted from pounds to dollars, and every sale back again, so the conversion fee is paid twice on a round trip. XTB's higher rate applies to the full value each time. Holding a dollar balance at either broker reduces the number of conversions, since both support USD accounts, but most investors fund in pounds and convert on each trade.

The other difference is the quiet account. A regular investor will never meet XTB's inactivity rule, but an investor who buys once and leaves the account alone for more than a year might, and Trading 212 charges nothing in that case.

Two brokers with CFD roots

Both apps offer an investing account and a separate CFD account. The investing account buys real shares and ETFs that you own, inside an ISA if you choose; the CFD account trades with leverage of 1:30 (CFD account) at Trading 212 and 1:30 (CFDs) at XTB for UK retail clients. Most retail CFD accounts lose money. Whichever you choose, check that each order goes through the investing or ISA account if your aim is to build a long-term portfolio.

Which should you choose?

  • US share investors: Trading 212, for its lower FX fee.
  • Pension savers: Trading 212, which offers a SIPP.
  • Investors who want phone support: XTB.
  • Investors who build automatic portfolios: Trading 212, with Pies.
  • Investors who want a listed parent company: XTB.

Read the full Trading 212 review and XTB review, or see all broker comparisons. The value of investments can fall as well as rise.

Frequently asked questions

Is Trading 212 or XTB cheaper?

Both charge no commission for normal retail volumes. Trading 212's FX fee is lower than XTB's, and it has no inactivity fee. XTB charges a commission above a high monthly turnover and an inactivity fee after a long idle period.

Which offers a SIPP?

Trading 212. Both offer a Stocks and Shares ISA and a Cash ISA, but only Trading 212 adds a SIPP.

Which pays more interest on cash?

Both pay interest on uninvested cash in several currencies. The rates differ by currency and change often, so compare the current rate for the currency you hold.

Which has phone support?

XTB, around the clock on weekdays, along with live chat and email. Trading 212 offers live chat and email at any hour but no phone line.

Are both safe?

Both serve UK clients through FCA-regulated companies with FSCS cover and hold other European licenses. XTB is listed in Warsaw; Trading 212 is privately held. Both also offer CFDs, which are high risk.