Skip to content
Menu

How We Review and Score Brokers, Prop Firms and Trading Services

By Chad Smith · Updated

On this page
  1. What we have not done
  2. Where our facts come from
  3. The verification rule
  4. One record, used everywhere
  5. The five pillar scores
  6. How pillar scores are calculated
  7. Other provider types
  8. Featured placement and scores
  9. Keeping data current
  10. Our reviews are independent
  11. Risk disclaimer
  12. Related pages

Our mission is to make information about brokers and trading available around the world in the simplest form possible. Every review on this site is built from the same process: we collect facts from the company's own documents and regulator registers, check anything else against independent sources, store the result in one place, and calculate scores from it with fixed weights. This page explains each step, including what we have not done.

What we have not done

We have not opened live accounts with the providers we review. We have not deposited money, timed withdrawals, tested customer support response times or traded through the platforms ourselves.

Our reviews describe what each company states and what regulators record. If we add our own tests in future, each review will say which parts were tested, when and how.

Where our facts come from

We use three kinds of source, in this order.

  1. The company's own documents. Its website, fee schedules, product disclosure statements, terms and conditions, order execution policy, key information documents and help center.
  2. Regulator registers. For each regulated company, we look up the legal entity on the regulator's register and record the license number as the company prints it, with a link to the register. Our regulators pages list each register.
  3. Consistent public information. For anything the company does not publish, we use figures that appear consistently in public information, such as press coverage and app store listings.

We note where each figure came from and the date we read it. Changes are logged with a date and a short note.

The verification rule

A figure goes onto a page only if it meets one of these conditions:

  • It is stated on the company's own site, in its legal documents or on a regulator register.
  • At least two independent reputable sources give the same value.

We remove a value if only one secondary source gives it and nothing repeats it, if it was derived, estimated or assumed, if it was recalled rather than read, or if most sources contradict it. Where sources conflict, we keep the value most of them give, preferring the most recent. Removed values and the reason for removing them are recorded in the change log.

When a value is missing, we leave it empty and write around it. A review will say "the broker does not publish its conversion fee" rather than guess.

One record, used everywhere

Each provider has one database record. Every figure you see on a review, a comparison, a best-of list or a country page is pulled from that record, not typed by hand. When a figure changes, we change it once and every page updates. This also means a figure cannot say one thing on a review and another on a comparison.

Records start with the status "draft". A record is marked "verified" only after a person on our team has checked it against the sources. Each page shows when its data was last checked.

The five pillar scores

Forex and CFD brokers, stock brokers and prop firms are scored on five pillars. Each pillar score runs from 1.0 to 5.0, rounded to one decimal place. The overall score is a weighted average of the five, with the same weights for every scored provider:

PillarWeight
Costs30%
Safety30%
Platforms15%
Accounts15%
Support10%

Costs and safety carry the most weight because they affect every trader on every trade: what you pay, and whether your money is protected. Platforms and accounts matter a lot to some traders and less to others. Support matters, but it is the pillar we can measure least well without our own tests, so it carries the least weight.

If we change the weights, we will update this page, note the date and recalculate every score at once.

How pillar scores are calculated

Scores are calculated by a script from the data in each record, never typed by hand. Each pillar starts from a base value and gains or loses points for specific facts in the record. No pillar can go below 1.0 or above 5.0. Only providers that are currently operating are scored.

Missing data does not earn points. If a provider does not publish a figure, the related part of the score is not credited, and the pillar stays at its base value. That gives companies a reason to publish more, and it means a score reflects what a reader can check.

Safety (brokers)

  • The starting point is the strongest regulator among the broker's legal entities: 4.0 for a tier-1 regulator, 3.2 for tier 2, 2.4 for tier 3 and 1.8 for tier 4 or an unlisted regulator. A broker with no regulated entity scores 1.5.
  • Plus 0.4 for three or more tier-1 licenses, or 0.2 for two.
  • Plus 0.2 if a tier-1 or tier-2 entity offers negative balance protection.
  • Plus 0.2 if any entity is covered by a compensation scheme.
  • Plus 0.2 if the company has operated for 15 years or more.
  • Minus 0.4 for each recorded incident, such as a regulator enforcement action.

Regulator tiers are listed on our regulators pages.

Support (all scored types)

  • The base is 2.0.
  • Plus 0.35 for each support channel, counting up to four.
  • Plus 1.0 for support around the clock, seven days a week, or 0.6 for 24-hour support on weekdays.
  • Plus 0.6 for support in 10 or more languages, or 0.3 for four or more.

Platforms (forex brokers and prop firms)

  • The base depends on how many widely used third-party platforms are offered: MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader, TradingView, NinjaTrader, Tradovate, DXtrade, Match-Trader, TradeLocker and Rithmic. None scores 2.8, one 3.4, two 3.9, three 4.4 and four or more 4.7.
  • Plus 0.2 for the provider's own platform.
  • For forex brokers, plus 0.2 if the average app store rating is 4.5 or higher, or minus 0.3 if it is below 3.5.

Forex and CFD brokers: costs and accounts

Costs are based on the lowest all-in cost, in US dollars, of trading one standard lot of EUR/USD, including spread and commission, across the broker's accounts:

All-in cost per lotCosts score
USD 6.50 or less5.0
USD 8 or less4.6
USD 10 or less4.2
USD 12 or less3.7
USD 15 or less3.2
More than USD 152.6
Not published2.5

A broker with no inactivity fee gets 0.2 more.

Accounts start at 2.4, then:

  • plus 1.0 for a minimum deposit of USD 100 or less, or 0.5 for USD 250 or less,
  • plus 0.4 for an Islamic (swap-free) account, 0.3 for a demo account and 0.3 for copy trading,
  • plus 0.3 for two or more account types, and
  • plus 0.3 for five or more base currencies.

Stock brokers: costs, platforms and accounts

Costs start at 3.0, then:

  • plus 1.0 for commission-free US stock trading,
  • plus 0.6 for a currency conversion fee of 0.25% or less, plus 0.2 for 0.5% or less, or minus 0.4 for a higher fee,
  • plus 0.3 for no custody fee, and
  • plus 0.2 for no inactivity fee.

Platforms start at 3.0, then:

  • plus 0.8 if the average app store rating is 4.5 or higher, or 0.4 if it is 4.0 or higher, and
  • plus 0.2 each for extended-hours trading, recurring investing, an API and paper trading.

Accounts start at 2.4, then:

  • plus 0.3 each for fractional shares, options, bonds, funds and ETFs,
  • plus 0.4 for tax-advantaged accounts,
  • plus 0.4 for interest on uninvested cash, and
  • plus 0.3 for a minimum deposit of 10 or less.

Safety and support use the same rules as for forex brokers.

Prop firms: costs, safety and accounts

Costs are based on the cheapest one-step or two-step challenge for a USD 100,000 account:

Challenge priceCosts score
USD 300 or less5.0
USD 450 or less4.5
USD 550 or less4.0
USD 700 or less3.5
More than USD 7003.0
Not published2.5

Safety for a prop firm is about track record and reputation, because prop firms are generally not regulated. It starts at 2.0, then:

  • plus 1.2 if the firm has operated for eight years or more, 0.8 for four years or more, or 0.3 for less,
  • plus 1.2 for a Trustpilot score of 4.5 or higher, 0.8 for 4.0 or higher, or 0.3 for a lower score,
  • plus 0.4 for 10,000 or more Trustpilot reviews, and
  • plus 0.3 if the firm publishes the total it has paid out to traders.

Accounts start at 2.4, then:

  • plus 0.3 for each challenge program, counting up to five,
  • plus 0.6 for a maximum profit split of 90% or more, or 0.3 for a lower published split, and
  • plus 0.3 for a scaling plan.

Platforms and support use the same rules as above.

Other provider types

Binary options platforms, signal and copy trading services and broker affiliate programs do not get pillar scores at present. Their reviews cover the same areas, such as regulation and regional bans, payouts, pricing and refunds, and commission terms, but describe them rather than score them.

Scores are only compared within the same type. A prop firm's score cannot be compared with a broker's.

Pepperstone is our featured partner. It is pinned first in forex lists and marked as featured. That placement is commercial, and it is explained on how we make money. Its pillar scores come from the same data, script and weights as every other broker. Its weaknesses are written as plainly as anyone else's.

Keeping data current

Figures that move often, such as spreads, promotions, Trustpilot scores and prop firm discounts, are rechecked more often than company facts such as founding year or headquarters. Each record carries a last-checked date and a change log. If a company closes or stops taking new clients, we mark it as such and keep the page for reference.

If you find an error, please tell us through the contact page. We check every report against the sources and log any correction.

Our reviews are independent

Our reviews and scores do not depend on any payment we may receive from providers. Providers can report factual errors, like anyone else, but they do not see reviews before publication and cannot change their scores.

Risk disclaimer

Trading carries a high level of risk. Margin-based forex trading, off-exchange derivatives such as CFDs, and cryptocurrencies expose you to risks that include leverage, the creditworthiness of the provider, limited regulatory protection and market volatility, which can sharply affect the price or liquidity of a currency or instrument. Do not assume that any method, technique or indicator described on this site will be profitable or will not lead to losses. Read our full risk disclaimer.

Frequently asked questions

Do you open real accounts with the brokers you review?

No. We have not opened live accounts, timed withdrawals or tested customer support ourselves. Our reviews are built from each company's own documents, regulator registers and figures that independent sources agree on, and we say so on every review.

How is the overall score calculated?

Brokers and prop firms get five pillar scores from 1 to 5, for costs, safety, platforms, accounts and support. The overall score is a weighted average, with costs and safety at 30% each, platforms and accounts at 15% each and support at 10%.

Does Pepperstone get a higher score because it is your partner?

No. Pepperstone is pinned first in forex lists as our featured partner, and that placement is disclosed. Its scores are calculated by the same method and weights as every other broker.

How often is the data updated?

Every figure carries the date it was last checked, and changes are logged. Figures that move often, such as spreads and promotions, are rechecked more frequently than company facts such as the founding year.

What happens when sources disagree?

We keep the figure most independent sources give, preferring the most recent. If only one secondary source gives a value and nothing repeats it, we leave it out.