Admirals vs Octa
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
Admirals and Octa both offer MetaTrader and their own platforms to retail forex traders, but they differ sharply in regulation and range. Admirals is a European broker with FCA and CySEC entities, raw and spread-only accounts, thousands of share CFDs, real stocks and copy trading. Octa is a low-deposit broker built for international traders, with a published average spread, swap-free accounts, free deposits and withdrawals, fast e-wallet and crypto payouts and round-the-clock chat, but its main international entity is lightly regulated. Pick Admirals for strong regulation and a broad market range. Pick Octa for a simple, swap-free forex account with a low deposit, if you accept weaker oversight.
- Minimum deposit
- USD 100
- USD 25
- Max leverage
- 1:1000 (FSA)
- 1:1000 (MISA)
- EUR/USD average spread
- 0.6 pips (Trade.MT5 / Trade.MT4)
- 0.9 pips (OctaTrader)
- Regulators
- CySEC, FCA, FSA
- MISA, CySEC, FSCA, FSC
- Platforms
- MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform
- Proprietary platform, MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5
- Funding methods
- 12
- 10
- Trustpilot
- 4.2 / 5
- 3.7 / 5
- Founded
- 2001
- 2011
- Headquarters
- Tallinn, Estonia
- Mwali, Comoros
Safety and regulation
Winner: Admirals. Admirals serves UK clients under FCA license 595450 with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000, and EU clients under CySEC license 201/13 with up to EUR 20,000 (ICF); insurance up to EUR 100,000. International clients go to Admirals SC in the Seychelles.
Octa's EU entity, Octa Markets Cyprus, holds CySEC license 372/18 with compensation up to EUR 20,000. Most international clients, however, sign with Octa Markets LTD, registered with the Mwali authority (T2023320), a tier-4 regulator in our regulator tiers that does little supervision. Octa also has entities in South Africa and Mauritius, at leverage up to 1:1000.
Both state negative balance protection on every entity. Admirals wins clearly: it has an FCA license, and even its offshore entity sits with a better-supervised regulator than Octa's. Admirals is privately owned: Admirals Group AS is controlled by founder Alexander Tsikhilov, and the group's bonds are listed on Nasdaq Tallinn, so it publishes audited financial statements. Octa is a private company and is not publicly traded. It traded as OctaFX until its rebrand.
Costs
Winner: Octa on holding and non-trading fees; no winner on spreads. Octa publishes an average EUR/USD spread of 0.9 pips on all its accounts, so one standard lot costs 9 USD round trip, with no commission. Admirals publishes only a minimum on its Trade account, from 0.5 pips, so the spread-only offers cannot be ranked.
Admirals offers what Octa lacks: a raw Zero account at up to 6 USD per round turn. Active traders may find that cheaper than Octa's spread, but Admirals does not publish a raw spread to prove it.
Holding costs favor Octa, whose accounts are swap-free. Non-trading fees also favor Octa: it charges None for withdrawals and None for inactivity. Admirals limits free withdrawals. One free withdrawal per calendar month per method; after that EUR 1 (or currency equivalent) by bank transfer, or 1% (minimum 1 unit) by card, Skrill or Brite. Its inactivity fee is EUR 10 per month after 24 months without trades, only if the balance is above zero and it charges a conversion fee of 0.5% on instruments or charges in a currency other than the account base currency; 1% on transfers between accounts in different currencies. See Admirals fees and Octa fees.
Accounts
Winner: Admirals for choice; Octa for simplicity. Octa's minimum is 25 USD, against 100 USD at Admirals. Octa's three accounts differ only by platform and share the same pricing. Admirals offers spread-only, raw and Invest accounts, the last for real stocks from 1 USD.
Platforms
Winner: Admirals. Both offer MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 and their own platforms, and both list copy trading and allow scalping. Admirals adds VPS hosting and active trader rebates, and names its copy service, Admirals Copy Trading. Octa adds guaranteed stops, which Admirals does not state. Octa does not offer VPS.
Funding
Winner: Octa. At Octa, Skrill and Neteller withdrawals take 1-3 hours, and Bitcoin, Ethereum and Tether 1-3 hours to approve, up to 30 minutes to transfer, all free. Admirals pays out by bank, card, Skrill and instant bank transfer Same business day if requested before 18:00 EET, with only the first withdrawal per method each month free. Octa does not publish card or bank withdrawal times.
Markets
Winner: Admirals. Admirals offers about 8,702 instruments, including 80 forex pairs, about 3,350 share CFDs and 300 ETFs, plus real stocks. Octa offers about 260, including 52 forex pairs, 10 indices and 27 crypto CFDs.
Research and support
Winner: tie. Both publish news, an economic calendar, daily analysis and webinars, and both offer courses. Admirals adds Trading Central. Octa answers 24/7 by chat and email; Admirals adds phone support but publishes no hours. Admirals scores 4.2 on Trustpilot from 2,166 reviews and Octa 3.7 from 9,986.
Why the Mwali entity matters
Octa's international entity is registered in Mwali, an island authority in the Comoros that sits in the lowest regulator tier. Registration there involves little ongoing supervision, no capital rules comparable to Europe's and no compensation scheme. In practice, an international Octa client relies on Octa's own policies, such as negative balance protection and segregated funds, rather than on a regulator. Traders in the EU are placed with Octa's CySEC entity instead, which is a very different proposition. Check which entity your account is with before you deposit.
Swap-free by default
Octa's accounts carry no swaps, which makes them attractive to traders who hold positions for days and to those who need Islamic accounts. Admirals offers swap-free accounts too, but its standard accounts charge overnight financing. For a swing trader, that can outweigh a small difference in spread. Scalpers and day traders who close before the daily rollover pay no swaps anyway, so for them the spread and commission are the costs to compare. The swap calculator shows what overnight financing costs for a given position.
Which should you choose?
- UK and EU traders: Admirals, or Octa's CySEC entity in the EU.
- Traders who want thousands of markets and real stocks: Admirals.
- Swing traders who hold positions for days: Octa, for swap-free accounts.
- Active traders who want raw pricing: Admirals.
- Traders who withdraw by e-wallet or crypto: Octa.
Most retail CFD accounts lose money. Read the full Admirals review and Octa review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Is Admirals safer than Octa?
For most traders, yes. Admirals serves UK and EU clients through FCA and CySEC entities and its offshore arm is in the Seychelles. Octa has a CySEC entity for Europe, but its main international entity is registered in Mwali, which gives very little oversight.
Which is cheaper?
Octa publishes an average EUR/USD spread for its accounts, giving a clear cost per lot. Admirals publishes only minimum spreads, so the two spread-only offers cannot be ranked. Admirals offers a raw account with commission; Octa does not.
Does Octa charge swaps?
Octa's accounts are swap-free. Admirals charges normal swaps but offers swap-free accounts on request.
Which has more markets?
Admirals, by a very wide margin, including real stocks. Octa focuses on forex, metals, indices and crypto.
Which has better support?
Octa answers around the clock by live chat and email. Admirals offers live chat, email and phone but does not publish hours.