Admirals vs Vantage
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
Admirals and Vantage are both FCA-regulated MetaTrader brokers with offshore entities for international clients, raw accounts and copy trading. Admirals is a European broker with a CySEC entity, one of the longest share CFD lists among forex brokers, real stocks from a very small deposit and active trader rebates. Vantage is an Australian-founded broker with an ASIC license, TradingView, a Pro ECN account with a reduced commission, spread betting in the UK and same-day card and e-wallet withdrawals. Pick Admirals for market range and real stocks. Pick Vantage for TradingView, Australian regulation or lower commissions on large balances. Both offer demo and Islamic accounts.
- Minimum deposit
- USD 100
- USD 50
- Max leverage
- 1:1000 (FSA)
- 1:30 (ASIC)
- EUR/USD average spread
- 0.6 pips (Trade.MT5 / Trade.MT4)
- 1.4 pips (Standard STP)
- Regulators
- CySEC, FCA, FSA
- FSC, VFSC, FSCA, ASIC, FCA, CIMA
- Platforms
- MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform
- MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, Proprietary platform
- Funding methods
- 12
- 16
- Trustpilot
- 4.2 / 5
- 4.4 / 5
- Founded
- 2001
- 2009
- Headquarters
- Tallinn, Estonia
- Sydney, Australia
Safety and regulation
Winner: tie. Both serve UK clients under the FCA with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000: Admirals under 595450 and Vantage under FRN 590299. Admirals adds CySEC license 201/13 for EU clients, with up to EUR 20,000 (ICF); insurance up to EUR 100,000. Vantage adds ASIC license AFSL 428901 for Australians.
Offshore, Admirals uses one Seychelles entity, with leverage up to 1:1000. Vantage uses several: Vanuatu (700271), the Cayman Islands (1383491), Mauritius and South Africa. Both state negative balance protection on every entity.
The two are evenly matched; your country decides which one's home license applies. Admirals is privately owned: Admirals Group AS is controlled by founder Alexander Tsikhilov, and the group's bonds are listed on Nasdaq Tallinn, so it publishes audited financial statements. Vantage is a private company and is not publicly traded.
Costs
No winner on spreads; Vantage for large raw-account balances. Neither publishes an average EUR/USD spread. Spread-only accounts list minimums of 0.5 pips at Admirals and 1.4 at Vantage, which do not show typical costs.
On raw accounts, Admirals' Zero charges up to 6 USD per round turn, and Vantage's Raw ECN 6 USD. Vantage's Pro ECN cuts the commission to 3 for a minimum balance of 10,000 USD. Admirals offers volume rebates instead.
Non-trading fees: Vantage charges None, except USD 20 for bank wire withdrawals; Neteller and Skrill charge their own fees. Admirals charges: One free withdrawal per calendar month per method; after that EUR 1 (or currency equivalent) by bank transfer, or 1% (minimum 1 unit) by card, Skrill or Brite. Vantage has no inactivity fee; Admirals charges EUR 10 per month after 24 months without trades, only if the balance is above zero. Admirals discloses a conversion fee of 0.5% on instruments or charges in a currency other than the account base currency; 1% on transfers between accounts in different currencies. Vantage does not publish one. See Admirals fees and Vantage fees.
Accounts
Winner: Vantage for traders; Admirals for investors. Vantage's minimum is 50 USD on Standard STP, Raw ECN and Cent, against 100 USD at Admirals. Vantage adds a cent account and spread betting in the UK. Admirals' Invest.MT5 account buys real stocks and ETFs from 1 USD. Both offer swap-free accounts.
Platforms
Winner: Vantage. Vantage offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, Proprietary platform, including TradingView. Admirals offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform. Both offer copy trading, through Admirals Copy Trading and Vantage Copy Trading, plus VPS hosting, and both allow scalping. Admirals adds active trader rebates.
Funding
Winner: Vantage, narrowly. At Vantage, cards, Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal, Skrill, Neteller and many regional methods are paid Up to 24 hours, and bank wires 3-7 business days for USD 20. Admirals pays bank, card, Skrill and instant bank transfers Same business day if requested before 18:00 EET, faster for bank transfers, but only the first withdrawal per method each month is free. Vantage's list of methods is much longer.
Markets
Winner: Admirals. Admirals offers about 8,702 instruments, including 80 forex pairs, 43 indices, about 3,350 share CFDs and 300 ETFs, plus real stocks. Vantage offers about 1,000, including 33 indices, about 800 share CFDs and 57 ETFs.
Research and support
Winner: Vantage. Both publish news, an economic calendar, daily analysis, webinars and Trading Central, and both offer courses. Vantage offers Live chat 24/7; phone 24/5; Admirals does not publish its hours. Trustpilot scores are 4.4 for Vantage from 16,133 reviews and 4.2 for Admirals from 2,166.
Spread betting and real stocks
These two brokers each add one product that UK traders often want. Vantage lists spread betting, which lets UK clients bet on price moves in pounds per point; under current UK rules, spread betting profits are generally free of capital gains tax, though tax depends on your circumstances. Admirals offers real stocks through its Invest account, which are owned outright rather than traded with leverage. A UK trader who wants tax-efficient short-term trading may lean toward Vantage; one who wants to build a long-term share portfolio beside a CFD account may lean toward Admirals.
Large traders
Vantage's Pro ECN account is aimed at traders with large balances who trade often, cutting the commission in return for a high minimum. Admirals rewards volume through active trader rebates rather than a separate account. Which pays more depends on your volume and balance, so ask both for their rebate terms before you commit a large sum.
Which entity you join
Both brokers place clients by country of residence. A UK resident joins the FCA entity at either broker, with the retail leverage cap of 1:30 on major pairs, negative balance protection and FSCS cover. An EU resident joins Admirals' CySEC entity; Vantage has no EU entity. An Australian joins Vantage's ASIC entity; Admirals has no Australian entity. Everyone else is placed offshore, where leverage is higher and protections are thinner. Your account agreement names the company you join, and that company's regulator is the one that matters if something goes wrong.
Which should you choose?
- EU traders: Admirals, through its CySEC entity.
- Australian traders: Vantage, through its ASIC entity.
- TradingView users: Vantage.
- Multi-asset traders and stock investors: Admirals.
- High-volume traders with large balances: Vantage's Pro ECN or Admirals' rebates; compare both.
Most retail CFD accounts lose money. Read the full Admirals review and Vantage review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better regulated, Admirals or Vantage?
Both have FCA entities for UK clients. Admirals adds CySEC for the EU, while Vantage adds ASIC for Australia. Offshore, Admirals uses the Seychelles and Vantage uses several entities, including Vanuatu and the Cayman Islands.
Which is cheaper?
Neither publishes an average EUR/USD spread. On raw accounts, the two charge a similar standard commission, and Vantage's Pro ECN account cuts it for large balances. Vantage charges a fee on bank wire withdrawals; Admirals charges after the first free withdrawal each month.
Does Admirals offer TradingView?
It does not state TradingView integration. Vantage offers TradingView alongside MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 and its own app.
Which has more markets?
Admirals, by a wide margin, with thousands of share CFDs and real stocks. Vantage lists around a thousand instruments.
Do both offer spread betting?
Vantage lists spread betting for UK clients. Admirals does not state it.