Skip to content
Menu

Admirals vs XM

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Safety and regulation
  2. Costs
  3. Accounts
  4. Platforms
  5. Funding
  6. Markets
  7. Research and support
  8. Inactivity: the fee that catches people out
  9. Real stocks at both
  10. Which should you choose?

Admirals and XM are both long-established MetaTrader brokers with European roots, but they lean in different directions. Admirals is built around its FCA and CySEC entities, with one of the longest share CFD lists among forex brokers, real stocks from a very small deposit, copy trading and active trader rebates. XM is a global broker with a token minimum deposit, many regional entities, instant e-wallet withdrawals, XM's own app and support around the clock, but no UK entity and an inactivity fee after a few months. Pick Admirals if you live in the UK or want a wide multi-asset range. Pick XM for a very small start and fast e-wallet payouts.

XM
4.6 / 5
Visit
Minimum deposit
USD 100
USD 5
Max leverage
1:1000 (FSA)
1:1000 (FSC Belize)
EUR/USD average spread
0.6 pips (Trade.MT5 / Trade.MT4)
1.6 pips (Standard)
Regulators
CySEC, FCA, FSA
CySEC, FSC Belize, FSC, FSA, BVI FSC, FSCA, DFSA, UAE CMA, CMA
Platforms
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform
Funding methods
12
9
Trustpilot
4.2 / 5
Not shown
Founded
2001
2009
Headquarters
Tallinn, Estonia
Limassol, Cyprus

Safety and regulation

Winner: Admirals. Admirals serves UK clients through Admiral Markets UK Ltd under FCA license 595450, with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000, and EU clients through CySEC license 201/13, with up to EUR 20,000 (ICF); insurance up to EUR 100,000. Its Seychelles entity allows leverage up to 1:1000.

XM serves EU clients through Trading Point of Financial Instruments under CySEC license 120/10, with investor compensation up to EUR 20,000, and Middle East clients through a DFSA entity. International clients sign with XM Global in Belize (8557558), at leverage up to 1:1000. XM also has entities in Mauritius, the Seychelles, the BVI, South Africa, the UAE and Kenya, but none in the UK.

Both state negative balance protection on their main entities. Admirals wins for its FCA entity. Admirals is privately owned. Admirals Group AS is controlled by its founder, Alexander Tsikhilov; the group's bonds are listed on Nasdaq Tallinn and it publishes audited financial statements. XM is privately owned by Trading Point Group; XM is a trading name of Trading Point Holdings Ltd. The group is controlled by co-founder Costas Cleanthous.

Costs

No winner on spreads; Admirals on non-trading fees. Neither publishes an average EUR/USD spread. Admirals' Trade account lists spreads from 0.5 pips; XM's Standard from 1.6 and Ultra Low from 0.8. On raw accounts, Admirals' Zero charges up to 6 USD per round turn, and XM's Zero 7 USD.

Inactivity fees differ a lot. XM charges USD 10 per month after 90 days without trading, deposits or withdrawals. Admirals charges EUR 10 per month after 24 months without trades, only if the balance is above zero. A trader who pauses for a few months pays at XM long before Admirals.

On withdrawals, XM charges None; XM covers payment fees, except bank wires under USD 200. Admirals charges: One free withdrawal per calendar month per method; after that EUR 1 (or currency equivalent) by bank transfer, or 1% (minimum 1 unit) by card, Skrill or Brite. Admirals also discloses a conversion fee of 0.5% on instruments or charges in a currency other than the account base currency; 1% on transfers between accounts in different currencies. XM does not publish one. See Admirals fees and XM fees.

Accounts

Winner: XM for small starts; Admirals for investors. XM's minimum is 5 USD on Standard, Ultra Low and Zero. Admirals' trading accounts need 100 USD. For real stocks, Admirals' Invest.MT5 starts at 1 USD, while XM's Shares account needs 10,000 USD. Both offer swap-free accounts.

Platforms

Tie. Both offer MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 and their own platforms, and both allow algorithmic trading and VPS hosting. XM adds TradingView integration; Admirals does not state it. Admirals offers copy trading through Admirals Copy Trading and active trader rebates. XM offers copy trading too, but it does not name the providers. Admirals allows scalping; XM does not publish its scalping policy.

Funding

Winner: XM for e-wallets; Admirals for bank and card speed. At XM, Skrill, Neteller and Google Pay withdrawals are Instant, crypto Instant to 24 hours, and cards and bank transfers 2-5 business days. It also supports M-Pesa. Admirals pays out by bank, card, Skrill and instant bank transfer Same business day if requested before 18:00 EET, with the first withdrawal per method each month free.

Markets

Winner: Admirals. Admirals offers about 8,702 instruments, including 80 forex pairs, 43 indices, about 3,350 share CFDs, 300 ETFs and 28 crypto CFDs. XM offers about 1,400, including 21 indices and about 1,200 share CFDs. Both offer real stocks.

Research and support

Winner: XM for support; tie on research. Both publish news, an economic calendar, daily analysis, webinars and Trading Central, and both offer courses. XM answers 24/7; Admirals does not publish its hours. Admirals scores 4.2 on Trustpilot from 2,166 reviews; XM's score is not published, so reviews cannot be compared.

Inactivity: the fee that catches people out

XM's inactivity fee starts after a short break from trading, which matters to traders who deposit, try a few trades and then step away. Admirals waits far longer before charging, and only when the account holds money. If you might leave an account idle, withdraw the balance or close the account, because both brokers take the fee from your balance. Check the exact conditions in each broker's fee schedule before you go quiet.

Real stocks at both

Unusually for forex brokers, both offer accounts for real, unleveraged shares. Admirals' Invest account is open to small investors and sits on MetaTrader 5, so you can hold shares and trade CFDs in the same platform. XM's Shares account is aimed at larger investors, given its minimum. For a small investor who wants a few real shares beside a forex account, Admirals is the practical choice. Remember that real shares are not leveraged, so their risk is the price of the share itself, not the amplified risk of a CFD.

Which should you choose?

  • UK traders: Admirals, since XM has no FCA entity.
  • Traders starting with a very small deposit: XM.
  • Multi-asset traders and small stock investors: Admirals.
  • Traders who may pause for months: Admirals, whose inactivity fee starts much later.
  • Traders who want e-wallet payouts the same day: XM.

Most retail CFD accounts lose money. Read the full Admirals review and XM review, or see all broker comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better regulated, Admirals or XM?

For UK traders, Admirals, because it has an FCA entity and XM does not. In the EU both use CySEC entities with investor compensation. Outside Europe, both place many clients with offshore entities.

Which is cheaper?

Neither publishes an average EUR/USD spread, so spread-only costs cannot be ranked. Both offer raw accounts with similar commissions. XM charges an inactivity fee much sooner than Admirals.

What is the minimum deposit?

XM's minimum is a token amount on most accounts. Admirals asks for more on its trading accounts but very little on its Invest account for real stocks.

Do both offer real stocks?

Yes. Admirals offers an Invest account for real stocks and ETFs, and XM offers a separate Shares account with a high minimum.

Which has better support?

XM answers around the clock. Admirals offers live chat, email and phone but does not publish its support hours.