AJ Bell vs XTB
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
AJ Bell and XTB both offer UK investors a Stocks and Shares ISA under FCA regulation, but they price and position themselves differently. AJ Bell is a traditional UK platform with flat dealing fees, funds and bonds, a full set of ISAs and pensions, and top review scores. XTB is a Warsaw-listed broker that charges no commission on shares and ETFs up to a monthly turnover limit, pays interest on cash and offers fractional shares, but has no pension, no funds and a CFD business on the side. Pick XTB for low-cost share and ETF investing in an ISA. Pick AJ Bell for a SIPP, funds or a Lifetime ISA.
- Minimum deposit
- GBP 25
- GBP 0
- Max leverage
- —
- 1:500 (CFDs) (FSC Belize)
- Regulators
- FCA
- FCA, KNF, CySEC, FSC Belize
- Platforms
- AJ Bell website, AJ Bell mobile app
- XTB web platform, XTB mobile app
- Funding methods
- 2
- 4
- Trustpilot
- 4.9 / 5
- 3.8 / 5
- Founded
- 1995
- 2004
- Headquarters
- Salford, United Kingdom
- Warsaw, Poland
Safety and regulation
Tie for UK clients. AJ Bell Securities Limited holds FCA reference 155593, and XTB Limited holds 522157. Both carry FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000. Both parents are listed. AJ Bell is listed on the London Stock Exchange (LSE: AJB) and is a FTSE 250 constituent. XTB has been listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange since 2016.
XTB also runs entities in Poland under the KNF, in Cyprus under CySEC and in Belize, where CFD leverage reaches 1:500 (CFDs) and negative balance protection is not offered. UK clients are not placed there, but international clients may be. AJ Bell offers no leveraged products at all.
Costs
Winner: XTB. XTB's pricing is 0% commission up to EUR 100,000 monthly turnover; 0.2% (minimum GBP 10) above that. AJ Bell's is GBP 5 per online deal (GBP 3.50 with 10 or more share deals in the previous month); 0.5% stamp duty on UK share purchases and GBP 1.50 PTM levy on deals over GBP 10,000. For a typical retail investor, XTB's turnover limit is far above what they trade in a month, so they pay no commission.
FX is closer. XTB charges 0.5% on currency conversion. AJ Bell charges 0.75% on the first GBP 10,000, 0.50% on the next GBP 10,000 and 0.25% above GBP 20,000 per deal; 0.5% on converting dividends and corporate action payments. XTB is cheaper on smaller deals; on a very large overseas deal AJ Bell's lower top band can come out cheaper.
Holding costs favor XTB, which charges nothing on most portfolios. None up to EUR 250,000 held; above that 0.02% a year, minimum GBP 10. AJ Bell charges a yearly account fee. Shares account charge 0.25% a year, capped at GBP 3.50 a month in the Dealing account (ISA and SIPP caps differ); funds 0.25% on the first GBP 250,000, 0.10% on the next GBP 250,000, nil above GBP 500,000.
XTB's one extra charge is for inactivity: EUR 10 a month after 12 months without trading, if no deposit was made in the last 90 days. AJ Bell charges none. A long-term investor who buys once and never trades again should note it.
Accounts
Winner: AJ Bell. AJ Bell offers Stocks and Shares ISA, Lifetime ISA, Junior ISA, SIPP, Junior SIPP. XTB offers Stocks and Shares ISA, Cash ISA. AJ Bell covers pensions and children's accounts; XTB adds a Cash ISA.
XTB has no minimum (0 GBP); AJ Bell asks for 25 GBP. Interest favors XTB, which pays on uninvested cash in three currencies. 4% AER (variable) on GBP, 2.3% on EUR and 3.45% on USD uninvested funds in a general investment account. AJ Bell tiers its rate by account. Tiered by account since 1 February 2026: Dealing account 0.75% AER on the first GBP 2,000 and nothing above; Stocks and shares, Lifetime and Junior ISA 1.75%; SIPP 2.05% up to GBP 100,000 and 2.40% above; SIPP in drawdown 2.65% and 3.15%. Paid quarterly. XTB also holds accounts in GBP, EUR, USD, while AJ Bell holds GBP only.
Platforms and features
Winner: XTB. Both run a web platform and app, and both support recurring investing. XTB adds fractional shares and a demo account. AJ Bell adds dividend reinvestment, which XTB does not state. App Store ratings are equal: 4.7 for XTB and 4.7 for AJ Bell.
Funding
Winner: XTB. XTB takes cards, bank transfers, PayPal and Skrill, though Skrill deposits cost 2% for UK clients. Bank withdrawals arrive Same business day if requested before 1 pm, otherwise next business day, and card withdrawals take Up to 3 business days. AJ Bell takes bank transfers and Direct Debit and publishes no withdrawal time. Neither charges to withdraw.
Markets
Split. XTB offers about 6,900 stocks and 2,300 ETFs from 14 markets, but no bonds, funds or spot crypto for UK investors. AJ Bell lists 24 exchanges and adds funds, investment trusts and bonds. XTB's CFDs cover many more markets, but those are leveraged derivatives, not investments you own.
Research and support
Winner: AJ Bell on reviews; XTB on hours. XTB answers by live chat, email and phone, 24 hours a day, Monday to Friday. AJ Bell answers by the same three channels, Monday to Friday 8am to 7pm, Saturday 10am to 2pm (UK time). On Trustpilot, AJ Bell scores 4.9 from 18,053 reviews and XTB 3.8 from 3,107.
XTB's CFD account is a separate product
XTB is best known as a CFD and forex broker, and the same app hosts both its investing account and its CFD account. The investing account buys real shares and ETFs that you own, inside an ISA if you choose. The CFD account lets you trade price movements with leverage, which can magnify losses as well as gains. New investors should check which account an order goes through before they place it. AJ Bell has no CFD business, so there is no risk of opening the wrong type of position by mistake.
Which should you choose?
- Share and ETF investors in an ISA: XTB, for zero commission and no custody fee on most portfolios.
- Pension savers: AJ Bell; XTB has no SIPP.
- Fund investors: AJ Bell.
- Investors who leave cash uninvested: XTB, for interest on GBP, EUR and USD cash.
- Investors who rarely log in: AJ Bell, which has no inactivity fee.
Most retail CFD accounts lose money; use XTB's investing account if you want to own shares. Read the full AJ Bell review and XTB review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Is XTB cheaper than AJ Bell?
For most share and ETF investors, yes. XTB charges no commission up to a generous monthly turnover limit and no custody fee on most portfolios. AJ Bell charges a flat fee per online deal and a capped account charge.
Does XTB offer a SIPP?
No. XTB offers a Stocks and Shares ISA and a Cash ISA. AJ Bell offers a SIPP, Junior SIPP, Lifetime ISA, Junior ISA and Stocks and Shares ISA.
Does XTB charge an inactivity fee?
Yes, after a long period with no trades and no recent deposit. AJ Bell has no inactivity fee.
Is XTB safe for UK investors?
UK clients sign with XTB Limited, which is FCA authorized with FSCS cover, and XTB's parent is listed in Warsaw. XTB also offers leveraged CFDs, which are high risk and separate from its investing account.
Which has better support?
Both offer phone, email and live chat. XTB answers around the clock on weekdays; AJ Bell has UK business hours plus Saturday mornings and higher review scores.