AvaTrade vs BlackBull Markets
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
AvaTrade and BlackBull Markets are both popular with international traders, but they work very differently. AvaTrade is a market maker with licenses in many countries, a commission-free Standard account with a published average spread, three copy trading services and high Trustpilot scores. BlackBull is a New Zealand ECN broker with no minimum deposit, a raw ECN Prime account with a lower published cost, cTrader and TradingView, a very large market list including real shares and support around the clock. Pick AvaTrade for regulation in your own country and simple copy trading. Pick BlackBull for raw pricing, platform choice and market range. Both offer demo accounts and Islamic accounts, so you can test either before funding a live account.
- Minimum deposit
- USD 100
- USD 0
- Max leverage
- 1:400 (BVI FSC)
- 1:500 (FMA)
- EUR/USD average spread
- 0.93 pips (Standard (retail))
- 1.1 pips (ECN Standard)
- Regulators
- CBI, CySEC, ASIC, BVI FSC, JFSA, FSCA, FSRA, CMA, ISA
- FMA, FSA
- Platforms
- MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform
- MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader, TradingView, Proprietary platform
- Funding methods
- 6
- 16
- Trustpilot
- 4.8 / 5
- 4.7 / 5
- Founded
- 2006
- 2014
- Headquarters
- Dublin, Ireland
- Auckland, New Zealand
Safety and regulation
Winner: AvaTrade. AvaTrade serves EU clients under the Central Bank of Ireland (C53877) and holds CySEC license 347/17, ASIC license 406684, a Japanese FSA license and licenses in South Africa, Abu Dhabi, Kenya and Israel. Its international entity is in the BVI, at up to 1:400. It offers negative balance protection on its main entities.
BlackBull's main license is from New Zealand's FMA (FSP403326), a tier-1 regulator, with a Seychelles entity (SD045) at up to 1:500. It does not state negative balance protection or a compensation scheme.
AvaTrade is privately owned. It uses a Market maker model. BlackBull runs an ECN / no dealing desk model. BlackBull Markets is privately owned. Co-founders Michael Walker and Selwyn Loekman each hold roughly 30%, LMAX Group bought 20% in June 2024, and a private equity fund managed by Milford Asset Management holds a minority stake.
Costs
Winner: BlackBull. One standard lot of EUR/USD, opened and closed:
- BlackBull ECN Prime: 7.6 USD, from an average spread of 0.16 pips and 6 USD commission
- AvaTrade Standard: 9.3 USD, from an average spread of 0.93 pips
BlackBull's commission-free ECN Standard account has no published average, so it cannot be ranked against AvaTrade's Standard. AvaTrade has no raw account.
Non-trading fees cut both ways. BlackBull charges Flat USD 5 per withdrawal on withdrawals; AvaTrade charges None. AvaTrade charges 50 units of the account currency per quarter after 3 months without activity, plus a 100-unit administration fee after 12 months. BlackBull's inactivity fee: None. Live accounts may be closed after one year of inactivity. See AvaTrade fees and BlackBull fees.
Accounts
Winner: BlackBull. BlackBull has no minimum deposit (0 USD) and three accounts from commission-free to Prime+. AvaTrade asks for 100 USD and offers Standard and Professional, the latter with spreads from 0.6 pips for clients who qualify. Both offer Islamic accounts.
Platforms
Winner: BlackBull. BlackBull offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader, TradingView, Proprietary platform, including cTrader and TradingView, with VPS hosting and an API. AvaTrade offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform. Both offer copy trading: AvaTrade through AvaSocial, DupliTrade, ZuluTrade, BlackBull through BlackBull CopyTrader, ZuluTrade, Myfxbook, cTrader Copy, MetaTrader Signals. AvaTrade allows scalping; BlackBull does not publish its policy.
Funding
Winner: BlackBull for speed. At BlackBull, card and e-wallet withdrawals are Instant on approval and bank transfers 1-3 business days. At AvaTrade, card withdrawals take 1-2 working days to process and bank transfers Up to 10 business days; it accepts Skrill, Neteller, PayPal and WebMoney but publishes no times for them. AvaTrade wins on cost, since it charges nothing to withdraw.
Markets
Winner: BlackBull. BlackBull offers about 26,000 instruments, including 91 forex pairs, about 2,000 share CFDs and real shares. AvaTrade offers about 1,260, including 53 forex pairs, 36 indices and 607 ETFs.
Research and support
Winner: tie. Both publish an economic calendar, daily analysis and webinars, and both offer courses. AvaTrade adds Trading Central and news; BlackBull adds Autochartist. BlackBull answers 24/7; AvaTrade offers 24/5 by phone, email and live chat; chatbot available 24/7. Both offer WhatsApp. Trustpilot scores are 4.8 for AvaTrade from 13,752 reviews and 4.7 for BlackBull from 3,526.
Market maker or ECN
AvaTrade takes the other side of client trades as a market maker and builds its cost into the spread. BlackBull routes orders to liquidity providers and charges a commission on top of raw spreads on its ECN accounts. Neither model is good or bad on its own. Market-maker pricing is simple and predictable; ECN pricing is usually cheaper per lot for active traders but has two parts to watch. AvaTrade's model suits traders who want one number and copy trading; BlackBull's suits scalpers and algorithmic traders who measure every pip.
Local licenses
AvaTrade's long license list means traders in Australia, Japan, South Africa, the UAE, Kenya, Israel and the EU can usually join a locally regulated entity. BlackBull's international clients are typically placed with its Seychelles entity, though its group holds a New Zealand license. If you live in one of AvaTrade's licensed countries, that local protection is a real advantage. Check your account agreement to see which company you would join.
The cost of going quiet
AvaTrade's inactivity fee starts after a short idle period and is charged every quarter, so a small balance left untouched can shrink noticeably. BlackBull charges no inactivity fee, though live accounts may be closed after a long period of inactivity. If you trade in bursts, with long pauses between, BlackBull's terms are kinder; if you do open an AvaTrade account and stop trading, withdraw what is left before the fee begins. BlackBull's flat withdrawal fee, by contrast, is a cost of being active, so batch withdrawals into fewer, larger payments to keep it small.
Which should you choose?
- Traders in Australia, Japan, the EU or the Middle East: AvaTrade, through a local entity.
- Raw-spread traders who want a low published cost: BlackBull.
- cTrader and TradingView users: BlackBull.
- Beginners who want copy trading and a simple price: AvaTrade.
- Traders who may pause for months: BlackBull, which charges no inactivity fee.
Very high leverage can wipe out an account quickly, and most retail CFD accounts lose money. Read the full AvaTrade review and BlackBull Markets review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Is BlackBull Markets cheaper than AvaTrade?
Yes. BlackBull's ECN Prime account has a lower all-in cost per lot than AvaTrade's Standard account. AvaTrade has no raw account. BlackBull charges a flat fee per withdrawal, while AvaTrade charges a large inactivity fee after a short idle period.
Which is better regulated?
AvaTrade, by breadth. It holds licenses in Ireland, Cyprus, Australia, Japan, South Africa, Abu Dhabi, Kenya and Israel, and offers negative balance protection on its main entities. BlackBull is licensed in New Zealand and the Seychelles.
Does AvaTrade offer cTrader or TradingView?
AvaTrade does not offer either. AvaTrade offers MetaTrader 4 and 5 and its own platforms. BlackBull offers MetaTrader, cTrader, TradingView and its own platform.
Which has more markets?
BlackBull, by a very wide margin, including real shares.
Do both offer copy trading?
Yes. AvaTrade offers AvaSocial, DupliTrade and ZuluTrade. BlackBull offers its own CopyTrader plus ZuluTrade, Myfxbook, cTrader Copy and MetaTrader signals.