Skip to content
Menu

AvaTrade vs IC Markets

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Safety and regulation
  2. Costs
  3. Accounts
  4. Platforms
  5. Funding
  6. Markets
  7. Research and support
  8. Which should you choose?

AvaTrade and IC Markets both offer MetaTrader to retail traders worldwide, but they suit different people. Pick IC Markets if you trade often and want raw spreads, cTrader or TradingView, no inactivity fee and a large list of share and crypto CFDs. Pick AvaTrade if you want one commission-free price per trade, structured courses, a broker-built app and stated negative balance protection on its offshore entity.

Minimum deposit
USD 100
USD 0
Max leverage
1:400 (BVI FSC)
1:5000 (FSA)
EUR/USD average spread
0.93 pips (Standard (retail))
0.01 pips (Raw Spread (MetaTrader))
Regulators
CBI, CySEC, ASIC, BVI FSC, JFSA, FSCA, FSRA, CMA, ISA
FSA, CySEC, ASIC, SCB, CMA
Platforms
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader, TradingView
Funding methods
6
16
Trustpilot
4.8 / 5
4.8 / 5
Founded
2006
2007
Headquarters
Dublin, Ireland
Sydney, Australia

Safety and regulation

Winner: AvaTrade, for clients outside Australia and the EU. Inside those regions the two are level. Both hold ASIC licenses, AvaTrade 406684 and IC Markets 335692, and both run CySEC companies covered by the Investor Compensation Fund up to EUR 20,000. AvaTrade also serves EU clients from Ireland. Both have Kenyan licenses, and neither has a UK entity.

International clients are where they part. AvaTrade's BVI company offers negative balance protection, with leverage up to 1:400. IC Markets onboards most of them through Raw Trading Ltd in the Seychelles, with leverage up to 1:5000. IC Markets clients are responsible for negative balances there, so that protection does not apply. In place of a compensation scheme it points to a private insurance policy, up to USD 1,000,000 for all claimants, on insolvency of Raw Trading Ltd.

Costs

Winner: IC Markets for frequent traders. AvaTrade has no raw account, and IC Markets publishes no average for its Standard account, so a strict like-for-like ranking of the two spread-only accounts is not possible. Here is the cheapest published option at each, for one standard lot of EUR/USD opened and closed:

  • AvaTrade Standard: 9.3 USD
  • IC Markets Raw Spread (MetaTrader): 7.1 USD
  • IC Markets Raw Spread (cTrader): 6.1 USD

IC Markets' Standard account quotes EUR/USD from 0.8 pips, against AvaTrade's average of 0.93 pips. A "from" figure is a minimum, not a typical cost, so it does not settle the question.

For a trader who opens a few positions a month, the raw-versus-spread difference is small, and AvaTrade's single quoted price is easier to follow. For a scalper trading several lots a day, the gap between AvaTrade's figure and IC Markets' cTrader figure repeats on every trade and adds up quickly over a year. The platform choice at IC Markets also matters: its cTrader commission is lower than its MetaTrader commission on the same raw spread.

On non-trading fees IC Markets also wins. It has no inactivity fee for global clients. AvaTrade charges 50 units of the account currency per quarter after 3 months without activity, plus a 100-unit administration fee after 12 months. Neither publishes a currency conversion fee.

More detail: AvaTrade fees and IC Markets fees

Accounts

Winner: IC Markets. Its main accounts have a minimum deposit of 0 USD, against 100 USD at AvaTrade. It also offers a choice of pricing model and Raw Pro accounts with lower commission for large balances. AvaTrade keeps one retail account plus a professional account.

Both offer micro lots, swap-free accounts and professional status. AvaTrade's Islamic account waives overnight fees only for a limited number of days; IC Markets replaces swaps with a flat holding fee. A low minimum deposit makes it easy to open an account, but a realistic trading balance is higher at either broker; see how much money you need to start forex trading. See AvaTrade account types and IC Markets account types.

Platforms

Winner: IC Markets. Both give you MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5. IC Markets adds cTrader, a TradingView connection, VPS hosting and API access. AvaTrade adds its own web platform and app, which are easier for new traders, but does not mention VPS or TradingView support.

Copy trading is available at both. IC Markets supports cTrader Copy, ZuluTrade, IC Social, Signal Start; AvaTrade supports AvaSocial, DupliTrade, ZuluTrade.

Funding

Winner: IC Markets. Neither charges its own funding fees, but IC Markets has the longer list and faster e-wallet payouts. PayPal withdrawals are Instant once processed, and crypto withdrawals take Up to 2 hours after processing. Australians can use BPAY and POLi.

AvaTrade processes card withdrawals in 1-2 working days to process, which is quicker than IC Markets' card timing of 3-5 business days after processing (up to 10). AvaTrade's bank wires are slow, at Up to 10 business days, and it does not publish e-wallet withdrawal times. IC Markets is also one of the few brokers that lets you withdraw to crypto as well as deposit with it, and clients in Thailand and Vietnam can use local bank transfers.

Markets

Winner: IC Markets, overall. It lists around 2,250 instruments, including 61 forex pairs, 2,100 share CFDs and 94 crypto CFDs. AvaTrade lists around 1,260, with 53 forex pairs and 25 crypto CFDs.

AvaTrade leads on indices, 36 against 25, and lists 607 ETF CFDs, while IC Markets does not publish an ETF count. Both are CFD-only.

Research and support

Split. AvaTrade wins education: both offer Trading Central, news, daily analysis, an economic calendar and webinars, but only AvaTrade has structured courses. IC Markets wins support hours, at 24/7 against AvaTrade's 24/5 by phone, email and live chat; chatbot available 24/7. AvaTrade adds WhatsApp and covers more languages. Beginners who want guided learning will get more from AvaTrade's courses, while experienced traders who need help at weekends, when crypto CFDs still trade, are better served by IC Markets.

Which should you choose?

  • Scalpers and algorithmic traders: IC Markets, for raw pricing, cTrader, VPS and API access.
  • Beginners who will trade regularly: AvaTrade, for courses and its own app.
  • Traders who may leave the account idle: IC Markets, which has no inactivity fee.
  • International clients who want negative balance protection in writing: AvaTrade.
  • Share and crypto CFD traders: IC Markets, for the longer lists.
  • UK residents: neither has an FCA entity. Pepperstone is a third option with an FCA entity and raw pricing (see how it compares with AvaTrade).

Very high leverage on offshore entities can wipe out an account quickly. Read the full AvaTrade review and IC Markets review, or see all broker comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

Is IC Markets cheaper than AvaTrade?

For active forex traders, yes. IC Markets' Raw Spread account costs less per lot than AvaTrade's commission-free account. IC Markets publishes no average for its own Standard account, so the two spread-only accounts cannot be ranked.

Which is safer for international clients?

AvaTrade. Its British Virgin Islands company offers negative balance protection and lower maximum leverage. IC Markets serves most international clients from the Seychelles, where negative balance protection is not stated and leverage is far higher.

Do AvaTrade and IC Markets charge an inactivity fee?

AvaTrade does, and it is steep, with a further administration fee after a year. IC Markets charges no inactivity fee for global clients.

Which is better for beginners?

AvaTrade offers structured courses and its own simpler app, which IC Markets does not. IC Markets suits traders who already know MetaTrader or cTrader.

Can UK residents use either broker?

Neither has an FCA-regulated entity, so UK residents are not served under UK rules by either.