Skip to content
Menu

AvaTrade vs Tickmill

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Safety and regulation
  2. Costs
  3. Accounts
  4. Platforms
  5. Funding
  6. Markets
  7. Research and support
  8. Reputation and regulation together
  9. Raw pricing or one simple spread
  10. Execution models
  11. Idle accounts
  12. Spread betting and UK clients
  13. Which should you choose?

AvaTrade and Tickmill are both well-regulated MetaTrader brokers, but they suit different traders. AvaTrade is a market maker with licenses in Ireland, Cyprus, Australia, Japan and several other countries, a commission-free Standard account with a published average spread, three copy trading services and very strong reviews, but no raw account and an inactivity fee. Tickmill is a raw-pricing broker with FCA and CySEC entities, low commissions on its Raw and TradingView Raw accounts, private insurance offshore and withdrawals within a working day, but a weak Trustpilot score. Pick AvaTrade for license reach, copy trading and service reputation. Pick Tickmill for UK regulation and raw pricing.

Minimum deposit
USD 100
USD 100
Max leverage
1:400 (BVI FSC)
1:1000 (FSCA)
EUR/USD average spread
0.93 pips (Standard (retail))
1.6 pips (Classic)
Regulators
CBI, CySEC, ASIC, BVI FSC, JFSA, FSCA, FSRA, CMA, ISA
FSA, FCA, CySEC, FSCA, DFSA
Platforms
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, Proprietary platform
Funding methods
6
12
Trustpilot
4.8 / 5
2.2 / 5
Founded
2006
2014
Headquarters
Dublin, Ireland
Mahe, Seychelles

Safety and regulation

Winner: tie. Both serve EU clients under strong regulators: AvaTrade through the Central Bank of Ireland (C53877) and CySEC (347/17), and Tickmill through CySEC (278/15). Tickmill adds an FCA entity (717270) with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000.

AvaTrade adds ASIC (406684), Japan's FSA, Abu Dhabi, Kenya and Israel. Both have FSCA entities in South Africa. Offshore, AvaTrade uses the BVI at up to 1:400; Tickmill uses the Seychelles, covered by Excess of Loss insurance policy up to EUR 1,000,000.

Both state negative balance protection on their main entities. AvaTrade is a private company. Tickmill is a private company and is not publicly traded. It belongs to the Tickmill Group, co-founded by Ingmar Mattus.

Costs

No clear winner. AvaTrade's Standard account costs 9.3 USD per standard lot of EUR/USD, round trip, from an average spread of 0.93 pips. Tickmill's Classic account lists spreads from 1.6 pips with no average, so the two cannot be ranked.

Tickmill's Raw account charges 6 USD per round turn on top of raw spreads, and its TradingView Raw 7. AvaTrade has no raw account. Active traders usually pay less on raw pricing, but Tickmill publishes no raw average to prove the total.

Non-trading fees: AvaTrade charges 50 units of the account currency per quarter after 3 months without activity, plus a 100-unit administration fee after 12 months. Tickmill's inactivity terms are not published. AvaTrade charges None for withdrawals; Tickmill's terms are: None from Tickmill; intermediary banks or e-wallets may charge and None; bank fees up to USD 100 are refunded on wire deposits of USD 5,000 or more. See AvaTrade fees and Tickmill fees.

Accounts

Winner: Tickmill. Both ask for a modest minimum: 100 USD at AvaTrade and 100 USD at Tickmill. Tickmill offers spread-only, raw and TradingView Raw accounts; AvaTrade offers Standard and Professional. Both offer swap-free accounts and professional terms, with leverage up to 1:400 at AvaTrade's Irish entity and 1:500 at Tickmill's UK entity for clients who qualify.

Platforms

Winner: Tickmill. Tickmill offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, Proprietary platform, including TradingView, with VPS hosting and an API. AvaTrade offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform. Both offer copy trading; AvaTrade names AvaSocial, DupliTrade, ZuluTrade. Both allow scalping.

Funding

Winner: Tickmill. At Tickmill, cards, Skrill, Neteller, PayPal, Trustly and Przelewy24 are paid Within 1 working day, crypto Within 24 hours and bank transfers 1-3 working days. At AvaTrade, cards take 1-2 working days to process and bank transfers Up to 10 business days, with no times published for its e-wallets.

Markets

Split. AvaTrade offers about 1,260 instruments, including 53 forex pairs, 36 indices and 607 ETFs. Tickmill lists 62 forex pairs, 19 indices, about 492 share CFDs and 25 ETFs. AvaTrade has far more ETFs; Tickmill has more forex pairs and publishes a share count.

Research and support

Winner: AvaTrade. Both publish news, an economic calendar, daily analysis and webinars. AvaTrade adds Trading Central and courses. AvaTrade offers 24/5 by phone, email and live chat; chatbot available 24/7, with WhatsApp; Tickmill offers 24/5 (chatbot 24/7; phone Monday to Friday 7:00-16:00 GMT). Trustpilot strongly favors AvaTrade, rated 4.8 from 13,752 reviews, against 2.2 from 1,205 for Tickmill.

Reputation and regulation together

AvaTrade combines broad licensing with a strong Trustpilot record from many reviews, which makes it a reassuring choice for traders who value service. Tickmill has the stronger set-up for UK clients and insured offshore accounts, but its low score suggests more client complaints. Read the most recent reviews of Tickmill before you open an account, and note whether complaints concern withdrawals or verification. A UK or EU client at either broker has access to an official ombudsman if a dispute is not resolved.

Raw pricing or one simple spread

Tickmill's raw accounts pass through interbank spreads and add a fixed commission, which suits scalpers and algorithmic traders who measure cost per lot. AvaTrade's Standard account builds everything into one published average spread, which is easier to understand and suits traders who place fewer, larger trades. For copy traders, AvaTrade's three services are a further reason to choose it.

Execution models

AvaTrade describes itself as a market maker, which can take the other side of client trades. Tickmill describes a Market maker and STP model. Both allow scalping and Expert Advisors, so neither appears to restrict short-term strategies. What matters in practice is the spread you pay, how often orders slip and how fills behave around news. Test both on demo accounts during the hours you trade if execution is central to your strategy.

Idle accounts

AvaTrade charges a quarterly inactivity fee once an account has been idle for a short time, which can eat into a small balance. Tickmill's inactivity terms are not published, so check its fee page. If you plan to pause trading for a season at either broker, withdraw your balance first, or keep the account active with an occasional trade or deposit.

Spread betting and UK clients

Tickmill's UK entity gives UK residents FCA protection and FSCS cover, which AvaTrade does not offer. Neither offers spread betting, so UK clients at Tickmill trade CFDs, where gains may be taxable.

Which should you choose?

  • UK traders: Tickmill, through its FCA entity.
  • Traders in Australia, Japan or the Middle East: AvaTrade, through a local entity.
  • Scalpers and raw-account traders: Tickmill.
  • Copy traders: AvaTrade.
  • Traders who put service reputation first: AvaTrade.

Most retail CFD accounts lose money. Read the full AvaTrade review and Tickmill review, or see all broker comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

Is Tickmill cheaper than AvaTrade?

Tickmill publishes only minimum spreads, while AvaTrade publishes an average, so commission-free accounts cannot be ranked. Tickmill offers raw accounts with a low commission, which AvaTrade does not, and active traders usually pay less on raw pricing.

Which is better regulated?

Both are well regulated. Tickmill has an FCA entity for UK clients, which AvaTrade does not have, and private insurance offshore. AvaTrade holds licenses in more countries, including Ireland, Australia and Japan.

Which has better reviews?

AvaTrade, by a wide margin on Trustpilot.

Does AvaTrade offer TradingView?

AvaTrade does not offer it. Tickmill offers a dedicated TradingView Raw account, plus MetaTrader 4 and 5.

Which charges an inactivity fee?

AvaTrade charges one after a short idle period. Tickmill's inactivity terms are not published.