Skip to content
Menu

AvaTrade vs XTB

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Safety and regulation
  2. Costs
  3. Accounts
  4. Platforms
  5. Funding
  6. Markets
  7. Research and support
  8. Which should you choose?

AvaTrade and XTB both offer commission-free forex to retail traders, but they are built for different jobs. Pick XTB if you live in the UK or EU and want forex CFDs and real stocks and ETFs in one account, on a well-designed platform, from a listed broker. Pick AvaTrade if you want MetaTrader, automated or copy trading, a slightly lower forex spread, or negative balance protection outside Europe.

XTB
4.1 / 5
Visit
Minimum deposit
USD 100
USD 0
Max leverage
1:400 (BVI FSC)
1:500 (CMF)
EUR/USD average spread
0.93 pips (Standard (retail))
1.06 pips (Standard)
Regulators
CBI, CySEC, ASIC, BVI FSC, JFSA, FSCA, FSRA, CMA, ISA
KNF, FCA, CySEC, DFSA, UAE CMA, CMF, BAPPEBTI, FSC Belize
Platforms
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform
Proprietary platform
Funding methods
6
5
Trustpilot
4.8 / 5
3.8 / 5
Founded
2006
2004
Headquarters
Dublin, Ireland
Warsaw, Poland

Safety and regulation

Winner: XTB in the UK and EU; AvaTrade elsewhere. XTB is listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange and publishes audited results; AvaTrade is privately held. UK clients of XTB sign with XTB Limited, FCA FRN 522157, with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000. AvaTrade has no UK entity.

In the EU both are strong. XTB S.A. is authorized by the KNF in Poland, with the KDPW investor compensation scheme covering eligible clients up to EUR 20,100. AvaTrade serves EU clients from Ireland, license C53877, and both have CySEC companies covered up to EUR 20,000. AvaTrade also holds an ASIC license, which XTB does not.

Outside those regions the order reverses. XTB International in Belize offers leverage up to 1:500 with no negative balance protection, so a sharp gap can leave the account owing money. AvaTrade's BVI company offers negative balance protection, with leverage up to 1:400. Neither offshore company has a compensation scheme.

Costs

Winner: AvaTrade on forex; XTB for investing. Both are spread-only on forex, so this is like for like. One standard lot of EUR/USD, opened and closed:

  • AvaTrade Standard: 9.3 USD, from an average spread of 0.93 pips
  • XTB Standard: 10.6 USD, from a group average of 1.06 pips

The gap is small. XTB's bigger cost advantage is outside forex: real stocks and ETFs are commission-free up to a monthly turnover limit, which AvaTrade cannot match because it does not sell real assets.

Non-trading fees are mixed. XTB's inactivity fee is EUR 10 per month if no buy or sell transaction has been made within 365 days, far gentler than AvaTrade's 50 units of the account currency per quarter after 3 months without activity, plus a 100-unit administration fee after 12 months. But XTB charges more around funding: Free above USD 50; USD 30 below USD 50 on withdrawals, percentage charges on Skrill and Neteller deposits, and a conversion fee of 0.5%. AvaTrade's deposits and withdrawals are free, and it publishes no conversion fee.

More detail: AvaTrade fees and XTB fees

Accounts

Winner: XTB. It has no minimum deposit, 0 USD, against 100 USD at AvaTrade, and its single account holds CFDs, real stocks and ETFs together. Both allow micro lots and professional status.

AvaTrade's advantages are swap-free trading, through an Islamic account that waives overnight fees for a limited number of days, and a clearer professional route. XTB offers swap-free status only in some countries, for specific periods and not on all products. See AvaTrade account types and XTB account types.

Platforms

Winner: AvaTrade. It offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 and its own app, and allows Expert Advisors, scalping and hedging. Copy trading runs through AvaSocial, DupliTrade, ZuluTrade.

XTB runs only on xStation, on web, desktop and mobile. It is well regarded, with built-in sentiment data, an economic calendar and trading statistics, and its app ratings are among the best in the market. But it has no MetaTrader, no TradingView, no copy trading, no VPS, no API and no automated trading. If you rely on bots, XTB is not an option. For a manual trader who also invests, though, having stocks, ETFs and CFDs in one well-designed app is a real convenience. Check which ticket you are using before you confirm an order, because a real share purchase and a CFD on the same stock look similar but carry very different risks.

Funding

Winner: AvaTrade, narrowly. AvaTrade accepts cards, bank wires and several e-wallets for both deposits and withdrawals, with no fee of its own. Card withdrawals are processed in 1-2 working days to process, though bank wires take Up to 10 business days.

XTB is quick but narrow. Bank withdrawals are processed Same or next business day, which is faster than AvaTrade's wires, but cards, Skrill and Neteller can be used to deposit only. Every withdrawal goes to a verified bank account, and small ones carry the fee above.

Markets

Winner: XTB, clearly. It lists roughly 12,200 instruments, including 71 forex pairs, about 2,251 share CFDs, 54 crypto CFDs and around 2,400 ETFs, plus real stocks. AvaTrade lists around 1,260, with 53 forex pairs and 25 crypto CFDs.

AvaTrade publishes an index count of 36; XTB does not publish one, so indices cannot be compared. UK retail clients cannot trade crypto CFDs at XTB under FCA rules, and AvaTrade has no UK entity at all, so crypto CFDs matter mainly to clients elsewhere.

Research and support

Winner: AvaTrade, narrowly. Both publish news, daily analysis, an economic calendar and webinars, and both have structured courses. AvaTrade adds Trading Central, which XTB does not offer. XTB's own analyst team and the sentiment tools in xStation partly make up for it. XTB's demo accounts are time-limited; AvaTrade does not state whether its demo expires.

Support is a tie on hours: 24/5 at XTB and 24/5 by phone, email and live chat; chatbot available 24/7 at AvaTrade. Both offer live chat, email and phone, and AvaTrade adds WhatsApp.

Which should you choose?

  • European traders who also invest: XTB, for real stocks and ETFs in the same account.
  • UK residents: XTB, which has an FCA entity.
  • MetaTrader users and algorithmic traders: AvaTrade, as XTB supports neither.
  • Copy traders: AvaTrade.
  • Clients outside Europe: AvaTrade, whose offshore entity offers negative balance protection.
  • Traders who want raw pricing: neither offers it. Pepperstone is a third option with raw-spread accounts on MetaTrader and cTrader (see how it compares with AvaTrade).

Leveraged CFDs can lose more than you expect, especially without negative balance protection. Read the full AvaTrade review and XTB review, or see all broker comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

Is AvaTrade cheaper than XTB for forex?

Slightly. Both are commission-free on forex CFDs, and AvaTrade's average EUR/USD spread is a little tighter than XTB's group average.

Can I use MetaTrader at XTB?

No. XTB runs only on its own xStation platform and does not support Expert Advisors or automated trading. AvaTrade offers MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5.

Which broker lets me buy real stocks and ETFs?

XTB. Its single account holds both CFDs and real stocks and ETFs, with no commission up to a monthly turnover limit. AvaTrade is a CFD broker only.

Which is safer, AvaTrade or XTB?

In the UK and EU, XTB has the edge, with an FCA entity, a compensation scheme and a stock-exchange listing. Outside those regions AvaTrade is safer, because its offshore entity offers negative balance protection and XTB's Belize entity does not.

Which has the stricter inactivity fee?

AvaTrade's starts after a few months. XTB charges only after a full year without a trade.