Skip to content
Menu

BlackBull Markets vs Octa

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Safety and regulation
  2. Costs
  3. Accounts
  4. Platforms
  5. Funding
  6. Markets
  7. Research and support
  8. Day trader or swing trader
  9. Guaranteed stops at Octa
  10. One price list or several
  11. Which should you choose?

BlackBull Markets and Octa both serve international traders with high leverage and low entry costs, but they are built for different styles. BlackBull is a New Zealand ECN broker with no minimum deposit, a low published raw-spread cost, cTrader and TradingView, a very large market list including real shares, and many copy trading services. Octa is a simple, low-deposit broker with one pricing model across three platforms, swap-free accounts, free deposits and withdrawals, fast e-wallet and crypto payouts and guaranteed stops. Pick BlackBull for raw pricing, platform choice and market range. Pick Octa for a simple swap-free forex account, if you accept weaker regulation outside the EU.

Minimum deposit
USD 0
USD 25
Max leverage
1:500 (FMA)
1:1000 (MISA)
EUR/USD average spread
1.1 pips (ECN Standard)
0.9 pips (OctaTrader)
Regulators
FMA, FSA
MISA, CySEC, FSCA, FSC
Platforms
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader, TradingView, Proprietary platform
Proprietary platform, MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5
Funding methods
16
10
Trustpilot
4.7 / 5
3.7 / 5
Founded
2014
2011
Headquarters
Auckland, New Zealand
Mwali, Comoros

Safety and regulation

Winner: BlackBull for international clients; Octa in the EU. BlackBull's main license is from New Zealand's FMA, number FSP403326, a tier-1 regulator, with a second entity in the Seychelles (SD045). It does not state negative balance protection or a compensation scheme.

Octa's international clients mostly sign with Octa Markets LTD, registered with the Mwali authority (T2023320), a tier-4 body with little supervision. In the EU, Octa Markets Cyprus holds CySEC license 372/18, with compensation up to EUR 20,000. Octa offers negative balance protection on all its entities.

For a trader outside Europe, BlackBull's New Zealand license is stronger oversight than anything Octa offers there. BlackBull Markets is privately owned. Co-founders Michael Walker and Selwyn Loekman each hold roughly 30%, LMAX Group acquired 20% in June 2024, and a private equity fund managed by Milford Asset Management holds a minority stake. Black Bull Group Limited is wholly owned by Black Bull Global Limited. Octa is privately owned and not publicly traded. It traded as OctaFX until a rebrand to Octa.

Costs

Winner: BlackBull per trade; Octa for holding and withdrawals. One standard lot of EUR/USD, opened and closed:

  • BlackBull ECN Prime: 7.6 USD, from an average spread of 0.16 pips and 6 USD commission
  • Octa (all accounts): 9 USD, from an average spread of 0.9 pips

BlackBull's commission-free ECN Standard account lists spreads from 0.8 pips but has no published average, so Octa's commission-free cost cannot be compared with it directly.

Octa's accounts are swap-free, which saves money on positions held overnight. Octa charges None for withdrawals; BlackBull charges Flat USD 5 per withdrawal. See BlackBull fees and Octa fees.

Accounts

Tie. BlackBull has no minimum deposit (0 USD) and three accounts, from commission-free ECN Standard to Prime+. Octa's minimum is 25 USD, and its three accounts share one pricing model, differing only by platform. Both offer swap-free trading.

Platforms

Winner: BlackBull. BlackBull offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader, TradingView, Proprietary platform, including cTrader and TradingView, plus VPS hosting and an API. Octa offers Proprietary platform, MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, with guaranteed stops, which BlackBull does not state, but no VPS. BlackBull lists copy trading through BlackBull CopyTrader, ZuluTrade, Myfxbook, cTrader Copy, MetaTrader Signals; Octa lists copy trading without naming providers. Octa allows scalping; BlackBull does not publish its policy.

Funding

Winner: Octa. At Octa, Skrill and Neteller withdrawals take 1-3 hours, and crypto 1-3 hours to approve, up to 30 minutes to transfer, all free. At BlackBull, card and e-wallet withdrawals are Instant on approval and crypto 1-2 business days, each for a flat fee. BlackBull supports more regional methods, including UnionPay and several Asian payment services.

Markets

Winner: BlackBull. BlackBull offers about 26,000 instruments, including 91 forex pairs, about 2,000 share CFDs and real shares. Octa offers about 260, including 52 forex pairs, 5 commodities and 27 crypto CFDs.

Research and support

Winner: BlackBull, narrowly. Both publish an economic calendar, daily analysis and webinars, and both offer courses. BlackBull adds Autochartist; Octa adds market news. Both answer around the clock, and BlackBull adds phone and WhatsApp to chat and email. Trustpilot scores are 4.7 for BlackBull from 3,526 reviews and 3.7 for Octa from 9,986.

Day trader or swing trader

The cost picture depends on how long you hold. A day trader who closes every position before the rollover pays only spread and commission, and BlackBull's ECN Prime account is cheaper per lot. A swing trader holding for a week pays several nights of swaps at BlackBull but none at Octa, which can cancel out the spread advantage. Estimate both with the cost of trade calculator and the swap calculator for your usual pairs and holding period.

Guaranteed stops at Octa

Octa lists guaranteed stops, which close a position at the exact level you set even if the market gaps past it. That protection is rare among offshore forex brokers and useful around weekends and major news. BlackBull does not state it. A guaranteed stop can carry an extra cost at Octa. At brokers that offer them, guaranteed stops often widen the effective cost of a trade, so they are best used selectively around known risk events.

One price list or several

Octa's approach is deliberately simple: every account has the same average spread, no commission and no swaps, and you choose only the platform. That makes costs easy to predict and suits newer traders. BlackBull gives more choice: a commission-free account for simplicity, ECN Prime for raw pricing, and Prime+ for larger traders, each on four platforms. More choice can mean lower costs for an experienced trader who picks the right account, but it also means more to understand before you start. Both offer demo accounts, which are the easiest way to see which approach suits you.

Which should you choose?

  • Scalpers and day traders: BlackBull, for its lower all-in cost.
  • Swing traders and those who need Islamic accounts: Octa, for swap-free trading.
  • cTrader and TradingView users: BlackBull.
  • Multi-asset traders: BlackBull, for its market range and real shares.
  • EU traders: Octa's CySEC entity, since BlackBull has no EU license.

Very high leverage can wipe out an account quickly, and most retail CFD accounts lose money. Read the full BlackBull Markets review and Octa review, or see all broker comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

Is BlackBull Markets cheaper than Octa?

On a per-lot basis, yes. BlackBull's ECN Prime account has a lower published all-in cost than Octa's commission-free accounts. Octa's accounts are swap-free, though, and it charges no withdrawal fee, while BlackBull charges a flat fee per withdrawal.

Which is better regulated?

BlackBull, for international clients. Its main license is from New Zealand's FMA, while Octa's main international entity is registered in Mwali, which gives very little oversight. Octa has a CySEC entity for EU clients.

Does Octa offer cTrader or TradingView?

No. Octa offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 and its own OctaTrader platform. BlackBull offers MetaTrader, cTrader and TradingView.

Which has more markets?

BlackBull, by a very wide margin, including real shares. Octa focuses on forex, metals, indices and crypto.

Do both offer copy trading?

Yes. BlackBull lists several services; Octa lists copy trading without naming providers.