BlackBull Markets vs Vantage
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
BlackBull Markets and Vantage are both ECN-style brokers popular with MetaTrader and TradingView traders, and both pay most withdrawals within a day. BlackBull is a New Zealand broker with no minimum deposit, a published low-cost ECN Prime account, cTrader, a huge market list including real shares and many copy trading services. Vantage is an Australian-founded broker with FCA and ASIC licenses, a Pro ECN account with a reduced commission, spread betting in the UK, free card and e-wallet withdrawals and phone support on weekdays. Pick BlackBull for cTrader, market range and a published raw cost. Pick Vantage for stronger regulation and free e-wallet withdrawals. Both offer demo accounts, swap-free accounts and VPS hosting, so algorithmic traders are well served at either.
- Minimum deposit
- USD 0
- USD 50
- Max leverage
- 1:500 (FMA)
- 1:30 (ASIC)
- EUR/USD average spread
- 1.1 pips (ECN Standard)
- 1.4 pips (Standard STP)
- Regulators
- FMA, FSA
- FSC, VFSC, FSCA, ASIC, FCA, CIMA
- Platforms
- MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader, TradingView, Proprietary platform
- MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, Proprietary platform
- Funding methods
- 16
- 16
- Trustpilot
- 4.7 / 5
- 4.4 / 5
- Founded
- 2014
- 2009
- Headquarters
- Auckland, New Zealand
- Sydney, Australia
Safety and regulation
Winner: Vantage. Vantage serves UK clients under FCA license FRN 590299 with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000, and Australians under ASIC license AFSL 428901. International clients sign with entities in Vanuatu, the Cayman Islands, Mauritius or South Africa. All state negative balance protection.
BlackBull's main license is from New Zealand's FMA, number FSP403326, a tier-1 regulator, with a Seychelles entity (SD045) at leverage up to 1:500. It does not state negative balance protection or a compensation scheme.
Vantage wins on breadth of licenses and stated protections. Vantage is privately owned and not publicly traded. BlackBull Markets is privately owned. Co-founders Michael Walker and Selwyn Loekman each hold roughly 30%, LMAX Group acquired 20% in June 2024, and a private equity fund managed by Milford Asset Management holds a minority stake. Black Bull Group Limited is wholly owned by Black Bull Global Limited.
Costs
Winner: BlackBull. BlackBull's ECN Prime account costs 7.6 USD per standard lot of EUR/USD, round trip, from an average spread of 0.16 pips and 6 USD commission.
Vantage's Raw ECN charges the same commission, 6 USD, but publishes no average spread, so its total cannot be worked out. Its Pro ECN cuts commission to 3 for balances of 10,000 USD or more; BlackBull's Prime+ offers reduced commission for large traders too.
Non-trading fees favor Vantage, which charges only for bank wires. None, except USD 20 for bank wire withdrawals; Neteller and Skrill charge their own fees. BlackBull charges Flat USD 5 per withdrawal. Neither charges an inactivity fee. See BlackBull fees and Vantage fees.
Accounts
Tie. BlackBull has no minimum deposit (0 USD); Vantage's is 50 USD on Standard STP, Raw ECN and Cent. Vantage adds a cent account and spread betting for UK clients. Both offer swap-free accounts.
Platforms
Winner: BlackBull. BlackBull offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader, TradingView, Proprietary platform, including cTrader. Vantage offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, Proprietary platform. Both include TradingView and VPS hosting. BlackBull lists copy trading through BlackBull CopyTrader, ZuluTrade, Myfxbook, cTrader Copy, MetaTrader Signals and an API; Vantage offers Vantage Copy Trading. Vantage allows scalping; BlackBull does not publish its policy.
Funding
Winner: Vantage. At Vantage, cards, Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal, Skrill, Neteller and regional methods are paid Up to 24 hours, free. At BlackBull, cards and e-wallets are Instant on approval, but each withdrawal costs a flat fee. Bank transfers take 1-3 business days at BlackBull and 3-7 business days at Vantage, where wires cost USD 20. Vantage accepts PayPal, which BlackBull does not offer.
Markets
Winner: BlackBull. BlackBull offers about 26,000 instruments, including 91 forex pairs, about 2,000 share CFDs and real shares. Vantage offers about 1,000, including 33 indices, about 800 share CFDs and 57 ETFs.
Research and support
Tie. Both publish an economic calendar, daily analysis and webinars, and both offer courses. Vantage adds Trading Central and news; BlackBull adds Autochartist. BlackBull answers 24/7, with WhatsApp; Vantage offers Live chat 24/7; phone 24/5. Trustpilot scores are 4.7 for BlackBull from 3,526 reviews and 4.4 for Vantage from 16,133.
Two ECN offers side by side
On paper the raw accounts look alike: both pass through tight spreads and charge the same commission per lot, and both offer a discounted tier for large traders. The differences are in what surrounds them. BlackBull publishes its average spread, offers cTrader for traders who prefer its order handling, and lists far more markets. Vantage brings FCA and ASIC licenses, free card and e-wallet withdrawals and a larger set of regional deposit methods. A trader who withdraws small amounts often will feel BlackBull's flat fee; one who withdraws rarely will not. Batching withdrawals into one larger payment each month keeps BlackBull's fee small as a share of the amount.
Choosing a discounted tier
Both brokers reward size. Vantage's Pro ECN needs a large balance in return for a lower commission. BlackBull's Prime+ offers reduced commission for larger traders as well. If you trade high volumes, ask each broker for its exact terms and any rebates before you move a large balance, since the saving per lot can exceed the difference in spreads. Smaller traders should start on the standard raw account and move up only when their volume justifies it.
Spread betting and regional payments
Vantage lists spread betting for UK clients, which lets you trade price moves in pounds per point; under current UK rules, spread betting profits are generally not subject to capital gains tax, though your own position depends on your circumstances. BlackBull does not state spread betting. On the payments side, both support methods common in Asia and the Pacific: BlackBull lists UnionPay, FXPay, Help2Pay and PaymentAsia, while Vantage lists JCB, bitwallet, FasaPay, UPI and local bank transfers. Check which methods are available in your country, since availability varies by entity and region.
Which should you choose?
- UK and Australian traders: Vantage, through its FCA and ASIC entities.
- cTrader users: BlackBull.
- Traders who want a published raw-spread cost: BlackBull.
- Traders who withdraw often by card or e-wallet: Vantage.
- Multi-asset traders: BlackBull, for its market range.
Very high leverage can wipe out an account quickly, and most retail CFD accounts lose money. Read the full BlackBull Markets review and Vantage review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Is BlackBull Markets cheaper than Vantage?
BlackBull publishes an average spread for ECN Prime, giving a known all-in cost. Vantage publishes only minimum spreads, so totals cannot be ranked. Both charge the same standard raw commission, and Vantage's Pro ECN account cuts it for large balances.
Which is better regulated?
Vantage, for most traders. It has FCA and ASIC entities plus several offshore entities, all stating negative balance protection. BlackBull is licensed in New Zealand and the Seychelles, and it does not state negative balance protection.
Does Vantage offer cTrader?
No. Vantage offers MetaTrader 4 and 5, TradingView and its own app. BlackBull offers MetaTrader, cTrader, TradingView and its own platform.
Which has more markets?
BlackBull, by a very wide margin, including real shares.
Which charges less to withdraw?
Vantage, for cards and e-wallets, which are free. BlackBull charges a flat fee on every withdrawal; Vantage charges only on bank wires.