Skip to content
Menu

BlackBull Markets vs XM

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Safety and regulation
  2. Costs
  3. Accounts
  4. Platforms
  5. Funding
  6. Markets
  7. Research and support
  8. Who pays which fee
  9. Copy trading options
  10. Beginners and experienced traders
  11. Which should you choose?

BlackBull Markets and XM both serve traders worldwide with high leverage and MetaTrader, but they suit different people. BlackBull is a New Zealand ECN broker with no minimum deposit, a published low-cost ECN Prime account, cTrader and TradingView, a very large market list and many copy trading options. XM is a global broker with a token minimum deposit, a CySEC entity for EU clients, many regional entities, instant e-wallet withdrawals and courses for beginners. Pick BlackBull for raw pricing, platforms and market range. Pick XM if you are in the EU or want to start with very little and withdraw by e-wallet. Both offer demo accounts and swap-free options.

Minimum deposit
USD 0
USD 5
Max leverage
1:500 (FMA)
1:1000 (FSC Belize)
EUR/USD average spread
1.1 pips (ECN Standard)
1.6 pips (Standard)
Regulators
FMA, FSA
CySEC, FSC Belize, FSC, FSA, BVI FSC, FSCA, DFSA, UAE CMA, CMA
Platforms
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader, TradingView, Proprietary platform
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform
Funding methods
16
9
Trustpilot
4.7 / 5
Not shown
Founded
2014
2009
Headquarters
Auckland, New Zealand
Limassol, Cyprus

Safety and regulation

Winner: XM. XM's EU clients sign with Trading Point of Financial Instruments under CySEC license 120/10, with investor compensation up to EUR 20,000 and negative balance protection. Middle East clients can use its DFSA entity (F003484). International clients sign with XM Global in Belize, at leverage up to 1:1000, with entities also in Mauritius, the Seychelles, the BVI, South Africa and Kenya.

BlackBull's licenses are from New Zealand's FMA (FSP403326), a tier-1 regulator, and the Seychelles FSA (SD045), both at leverage up to 1:500. It does not state negative balance protection or a compensation scheme.

XM wins for its EU entity and stated protections. Both are private. XM is a trading name of Trading Point Holdings Ltd, part of Trading Point Group, which co-founder Costas Cleanthous controls. BlackBull Markets is privately owned. Co-founders Michael Walker and Selwyn Loekman each hold roughly 30%, LMAX Group bought 20% in June 2024, and a private equity fund managed by Milford Asset Management holds a minority stake.

Costs

Winner: BlackBull. BlackBull's ECN Prime account publishes its cost: one standard lot of EUR/USD, opened and closed, costs 7.6 USD, from an average spread of 0.16 pips plus 6 USD commission.

XM publishes no average spread. Its Standard account lists spreads from 1.6 pips, Ultra Low from 0.8, and its Zero account charges 7 USD per round turn, slightly more than BlackBull's commission.

Non-trading fees cut both ways. BlackBull charges Flat USD 5 per withdrawal on withdrawals; XM charges None; XM covers payment fees, except bank wires under USD 200. XM charges USD 10 per month after 90 days without trading, deposits or withdrawals. BlackBull's inactivity fee: None. Live accounts may be closed after one year of inactivity. See BlackBull fees and XM fees.

Accounts

Tie. BlackBull has no minimum deposit on any account (0 USD); XM's minimum is 5 USD on its main accounts. XM adds a Shares account for real stocks, with a minimum of 10,000 USD. Both offer swap-free accounts.

Platforms

Winner: BlackBull. BlackBull offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader, TradingView, Proprietary platform, including cTrader. XM offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform, with TradingView integration. BlackBull lists copy trading through BlackBull CopyTrader, ZuluTrade, Myfxbook, cTrader Copy, MetaTrader Signals, plus an API. XM offers copy trading but does not name providers. Both offer VPS hosting and allow algorithmic trading.

Funding

Winner: XM. At XM, Skrill, Neteller and Google Pay withdrawals are Instant, and XM covers payment fees except small bank wires. At BlackBull, card and e-wallet withdrawals are Instant on approval, equally quick, but each withdrawal costs USD 5. Cards take 2-5 business days at XM, so BlackBull is quicker there. XM supports M-Pesa; BlackBull supports UnionPay and several Asian methods.

Markets

Winner: BlackBull. BlackBull offers about 26,000 instruments, including 91 forex pairs, about 2,000 share CFDs and 40 crypto CFDs. XM offers about 1,400, including about 1,200 share CFDs and 21 indices. Both offer real shares.

Research and support

Winner: XM, narrowly. Both publish an economic calendar, daily analysis and webinars, and both offer courses. XM adds Trading Central and market news; BlackBull adds Autochartist. Both answer around the clock: BlackBull 24/7, XM 24/7. BlackBull scores 4.7 on Trustpilot from 3,526 reviews; XM's score is not published.

Who pays which fee

The two brokers recover costs in different places. BlackBull's flat withdrawal fee hurts traders who withdraw small amounts often; one larger withdrawal a month makes it negligible. XM's inactivity fee hurts traders who stop trading for a few months and leave money in the account. If you trade actively and withdraw rarely, BlackBull's model costs little. If you trade occasionally and like to withdraw small profits, XM's free withdrawals suit better, as long as you do not leave the account idle.

Copy trading options

Both brokers let you copy other traders, but BlackBull offers more routes. It has its own CopyTrader app alongside third-party services such as ZuluTrade, Myfxbook and cTrader Copy, so you can choose a platform whose track records and fee model you trust. XM offers copy trading too, but it does not name the services, so check the details on its site. At either broker, copying passes your account's risk to someone else's decisions: a strategy that has done well can still lose quickly, and you remain responsible for the losses. Start with a small allocation, read how the strategy provider is paid, and set a maximum loss before you begin.

Beginners and experienced traders

XM's token minimum deposit, courses and simple account line-up make it easy for a beginner to start small. BlackBull's ECN pricing, cTrader and API are built more for experienced traders who know what raw spreads and commission mean for their strategy. A beginner can use BlackBull too, since it has no minimum deposit and a commission-free ECN Standard account, but its tools assume more knowledge.

Which should you choose?

  • EU traders: XM, through its CySEC entity.
  • Raw-spread traders who want a published cost: BlackBull.
  • cTrader users and copy traders: BlackBull.
  • Beginners starting small: XM.
  • Traders who withdraw small amounts often: XM.

Very high leverage can wipe out an account quickly, and most retail CFD accounts lose money. Read the full BlackBull Markets review and XM review, or see all broker comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

Is BlackBull Markets cheaper than XM?

BlackBull publishes an average spread for its ECN Prime account, giving a low all-in cost per lot. XM publishes only minimum spreads, so the two cannot be ranked on the same basis. BlackBull charges a flat fee per withdrawal, while XM charges an inactivity fee after a few months.

Which is better regulated?

XM has a CySEC entity for EU clients and a DFSA entity in Dubai, plus several offshore entities. BlackBull is licensed in New Zealand and the Seychelles. For EU traders, XM is the regulated choice.

Does XM offer cTrader?

No. XM offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 and its own platform, with TradingView integration. BlackBull adds cTrader and TradingView.

Which has more markets?

BlackBull, by a wide margin. Both offer real shares, but BlackBull's total market list is many times longer.

Which has better support?

Both answer around the clock. BlackBull adds WhatsApp.