Skip to content
Menu

Charles Schwab vs E*TRADE

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Safety and regulation
  2. Costs
  3. Accounts
  4. Platforms and features
  5. Funding
  6. Markets
  7. Research and support
  8. Which should you choose?

Charles Schwab and ETRADE are large US brokers with no commission on online US stock and ETF trades, no account minimum, retirement accounts and advanced platforms for active traders. ETRADE is the cheaper choice for frequent options traders and for futures, and it offers paper trading. Schwab offers the wider range of account types, including an Individual 401(k) and 529 plans, and support around the clock. Pick E*TRADE if you trade options or futures often. Pick Schwab if you want one home for every type of account and the thinkorswim platform. Both serve US residents only.

Minimum deposit
USD 0
USD 0
Regulators
SEC/FINRA, CFTC/NFA
SEC/FINRA, CFTC/NFA
Platforms
Schwab.com, Schwab Mobile, thinkorswim desktop, thinkorswim web, thinkorswim mobile
E*TRADE Web, Power E*TRADE (web), Power E*TRADE Pro (desktop), E*TRADE Mobile, Power E*TRADE mobile app
Funding methods
—
1
Trustpilot
1.5 / 5
1.1 / 5
Founded
1971
1982
Headquarters
Westlake, Texas, United States
Arlington, Virginia, United States

Safety and regulation

Tie. Charles Schwab & Co., Inc. is registered with the SEC and FINRA as CRD 5393, with SIPC cover up to USD 500,000 including USD 250,000 cash. The parent, The Charles Schwab Corporation, is listed on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE: SCHW).

ETRADE's securities accounts are registered as CRD 149777, with SIPC cover up to USD 500,000 including USD 250,000 cash. ETRADE has been owned by Morgan Stanley (NYSE: MS) since October 2020.

Both are backed by some of the largest financial groups in the US. SIPC covers the failure of the broker, not losses on investments.

Costs

Winner: E*TRADE for active traders; tie for investors. Schwab charges USD 0 online for listed stocks and ETFs (USD 25 service charge broker-assisted); OTC equities USD 6.95. E*TRADE charges USD 0 online for US-listed stocks; broker-assisted trades USD 25 extra; OTC and foreign stock trades are excluded from USD 0 pricing. SEC fee of USD 0.0000206 x principal on sales. For ordinary online purchases of listed shares and ETFs, both cost nothing.

On derivatives, Schwab charges USD 0 base commission plus USD 0.65 per contract online; futures and futures options USD 2.25 per contract. ETRADE charges USD 0.65 per contract, or USD 0.50 with 30 or more trades a quarter; futures USD 1.50 per contract per side (E-nano USD 0.75). Traders who qualify for ETRADE's frequent-trader rate pay less per options contract, and E*TRADE's futures commission is lower.

Foreign shares are costly at both. Schwab charges a flat fee on OTC trades online and more for trades placed by phone or with a broker. Foreign stocks on the US OTC market: USD 50 foreign transaction fee online. On local exchanges by broker only: greater of USD 100 or 0.75% of principal. E*TRADE excludes foreign stock trades from its zero pricing and adds a currency cost. Foreign currency disbursement fee of up to 2.50%.

Neither charges an account fee. No account opening or maintenance fee. E*TRADE passes through only ADR custody fees. No annual, inactivity or IRA fees. ADR custody fees are passed through. Neither charges an inactivity fee.

Accounts

Winner: Charles Schwab. Schwab offers Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, Rollover IRA, SEP-IRA, SIMPLE IRA, Individual 401(k), 529 plan, Coverdell education savings account, UGMA/UTMA custodial. E*TRADE offers Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, Rollover IRA, Inherited IRA, SEP IRA, SIMPLE IRA. Both cover the main IRAs; Schwab adds workplace-style and education accounts, which suits self-employed investors and families.

Both have no minimum deposit: 0 USD at Schwab and 0 USD at ETRADE. On cash, ETRADE's rate comes through a linked savings account. A promotional 4.25% APY for six months on a linked Morgan Stanley Private Bank Premium Savings account. E*TRADE does not publish its brokerage sweep rate. Schwab's cash rate is not published.

Platforms and features

Tie. Schwab offers Schwab.com, Schwab Mobile, thinkorswim desktop, thinkorswim web, thinkorswim mobile. E*TRADE offers E*TRADE Web, Power E*TRADE (web), Power E*TRADE Pro (desktop), E*TRADE Mobile, Power E*TRADE mobile app. Both give active traders advanced charting, options tools and futures trading, along with simpler web and mobile apps for everyday investing.

E*TRADE offers a demo account, paper trading, extended-hours trading and margin. thinkorswim is widely known for its paper trading mode.

Funding

Winner: E*TRADE. E*TRADE funds by bank transfer, with deposits Free. Its withdrawal terms: Outgoing wire USD 25; full outgoing account transfer USD 75. Schwab's funding methods and fees are not published, so costs cannot be compared directly.

Markets

Tie. Both offer US shares, fractional shares, options, futures, bonds, funds and crypto. Neither offers CFDs. Both offer foreign shares only through costly routes, so investors who want international exchanges should look at a global broker instead.

Research and support

Winner: Charles Schwab. Schwab supports clients by phone and chat, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. ETRADE's support channels are not published. On Trustpilot, both score low, as is common for large US brokers: Schwab is rated 1.5 from 794 reviews and ETRADE 1.1 from 790. App store ratings are much higher: Schwab scores 4.8 and E*TRADE 4.7 on the App Store.

Both brokers publish market research and education. Schwab clients can also use thinkorswim's analysis tools, while E*TRADE clients get research through Morgan Stanley.

Which should you choose?

  • Frequent options traders: E*TRADE, for its lower rate on high volumes.
  • Futures traders: E*TRADE, for the lower per-contract commission.
  • Self-employed retirement savers: Schwab, for the Individual 401(k).
  • Families saving for education: Schwab, for 529 plans and custodial accounts.
  • Traders who want to practice first: E*TRADE, for paper trading.
  • Investors who want help at any hour: Schwab.

Before you switch, check what an outgoing transfer would cost at your current broker, and whether your existing funds can move across. Both brokers have large fund ranges, but some proprietary funds cannot be held elsewhere. For long-term investors who buy US shares and ETFs, the two are close, so the platform you prefer may decide it. For heavy options and futures traders, E*TRADE's pricing is the stronger point.

Read the full Charles Schwab review and E*TRADE review, or see all broker comparisons. The value of investments can fall as well as rise, and options and futures carry a high risk of loss.

Frequently asked questions

Is Schwab or E*TRADE cheaper?

For online US stocks and ETFs, both charge nothing. E*TRADE can be cheaper for frequent options traders, who qualify for a lower per-contract rate, and its futures commission is lower than Schwab's.

Which has the better trading platform?

Both have strong active-trader platforms. Schwab offers thinkorswim on desktop, web and mobile; E*TRADE offers Power E*TRADE on web, desktop and mobile. Try each one, as the choice is often personal.

Which is better for retirement accounts?

Both offer a wide range of IRAs. Schwab also offers an Individual 401(k), 529 plans and custodial accounts.

Does either offer paper trading?

E*TRADE offers a demo and paper trading. Schwab does not publish details of these features.

Are Schwab and E*TRADE safe?

Both are long-established US brokers registered with the SEC and FINRA, with SIPC cover on securities accounts. Schwab is listed on the NYSE; E*TRADE is owned by Morgan Stanley.