Skip to content
Menu

Charles Schwab vs Fidelity

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Safety and regulation
  2. Costs
  3. Accounts
  4. Platforms and features
  5. Funding
  6. Markets
  7. Research and support
  8. Which should you choose?

Charles Schwab and Fidelity are two of the largest US brokers, and for most investors they are close: both charge nothing for online US stock and ETF trades, have no account minimum, offer a full range of IRAs, 529 plans and custodial accounts, and answer the phone around the clock. Schwab is the better pick for active traders, thanks to thinkorswim and futures. Fidelity is the better pick for investors who want to buy shares on foreign exchanges online, and it offers dividend reinvestment and recurring investing. Both serve US residents only.

Minimum deposit
USD 0
USD 0
Regulators
SEC/FINRA, CFTC/NFA
SEC/FINRA
Platforms
Schwab.com, Schwab Mobile, thinkorswim desktop, thinkorswim web, thinkorswim mobile
Fidelity.com, Fidelity mobile app, Active Trader Pro
Funding methods
—
1
Trustpilot
1.5 / 5
1.3 / 5
Founded
1971
1946
Headquarters
Westlake, Texas, United States
Boston, Massachusetts, United States

Safety and regulation

Tie. Charles Schwab & Co., Inc. is registered with the SEC and FINRA as CRD 5393, with SIPC cover up to USD 500,000 including USD 250,000 cash. The parent, The Charles Schwab Corporation, is listed on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE: SCHW).

Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC is registered as CRD 7784, with SIPC cover up to USD 500,000 including USD 250,000 cash. Fidelity is private: FMR LLC is controlled by Abigail Johnson and the Johnson family together with current and former employees.

Both have operated for decades and hold very large client assets. SIPC protects you if the broker fails; it does not protect against falls in the value of your investments. Schwab is listed, so it publishes quarterly results; Fidelity is private but still files regulatory reports.

Costs

Tie for US investing; Fidelity for foreign shares. Schwab charges USD 0 online for listed stocks and ETFs (USD 25 service charge broker-assisted); OTC equities USD 6.95. Fidelity charges USD 0 online for US equities, including OTC and penny stocks. ETFs are free online at both, although Fidelity adds a condition: USD 0 online; a limited list of ETFs carries a USD 100 transaction-based service fee.

Options cost the same per contract. Schwab charges USD 0 base commission plus USD 0.65 per contract online; futures and futures options USD 2.25 per contract. Fidelity matches the contract fee and waives cheap closing orders. USD 0 commission plus USD 0.65 per contract; buy-to-close orders at USD 0.65 or less are free.

Foreign shares are where the two differ. Schwab charges a flat fee on OTC trades online and more for trades placed by phone or with a broker. Foreign stocks on the US OTC market: USD 50 foreign transaction fee online. On local exchanges by broker only: greater of USD 100 or 0.75% of principal. Fidelity trades foreign shares online. Available through international trading (25 markets) in taxable accounts; a USD 50 foreign settlement fee applies per trade in foreign ordinary shares that are not DTC eligible. Fidelity also publishes its currency terms. Currency for international trades is exchanged by Fidelity FOREX, LLC at a marked-up rate; foreign exchange wires up to 3% of principal; 1% on foreign dividends and reorganizations. Schwab's currency mark-up is not published.

Neither charges an account fee. No account opening or maintenance fee. Neither has an inactivity fee.

Accounts

Tie. Schwab offers Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, Rollover IRA, SEP-IRA, SIMPLE IRA, Individual 401(k), 529 plan, Coverdell education savings account, UGMA/UTMA custodial. Fidelity offers Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, Rollover IRA, SEP-IRA, SIMPLE IRA, Inherited IRA, 529 plan, Custodial account, Youth Account. Self-employed investors may prefer Schwab for the Individual 401(k); families may like Fidelity's Youth Account for teenagers.

Both have no minimum deposit: 0 USD at Schwab and 0 USD at Fidelity. Neither publishes a single cash interest rate, so check the current sweep and money market options on each site.

Platforms and features

Winner: Schwab for traders; Fidelity for automated investing. Schwab offers Schwab.com, Schwab Mobile, thinkorswim desktop, thinkorswim web, thinkorswim mobile. The thinkorswim platforms are among the most complete available to US retail traders, with advanced charting, options analysis and futures trading. Fidelity offers Fidelity.com, Fidelity mobile app, Active Trader Pro.

Fidelity offers extended-hours trading, recurring investing, dividend reinvestment, margin and level 2 data. It has no demo account or paper trading. Schwab also offers extended-hours trading, recurring investing and margin, but it does not mention dividend reinvestment or level 2 data.

Funding

No winner on funding. Fidelity funds by bank transfer at no cost. Wires out cost little at home. Domestic bank wire USD 0; foreign exchange wire up to 3% of principal. Schwab does not publish its funding methods and fees, so the two cannot be compared on cost.

Markets

Split. Both offer US shares, fractional shares, options, bonds, funds and crypto. Schwab also offers futures. Fidelity offers international trading in 25 foreign markets in taxable accounts. Neither offers CFDs.

Research and support

Tie. Schwab supports clients by phone and chat, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Fidelity offers phone, chat and email, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Trustpilot scores are low for both, as is common for large US brokers: 1.5 for Schwab from 794 reviews, and 1.3 for Fidelity from 1,184. App store ratings are much higher: Schwab scores 4.8 and Fidelity 4.8 on the App Store.

Which should you choose?

  • Active stock and options traders: Schwab, for thinkorswim.
  • Futures traders: Schwab; Fidelity does not mention futures.
  • Investors who want foreign shares on local exchanges: Fidelity, for online international trading.
  • Self-employed retirement savers: Schwab, for the Individual 401(k).
  • Families investing for teenagers: Fidelity, for its Youth Account.
  • Hands-off investors: either; both have free US trades, IRAs and round-the-clock phone support.

Because the core pricing is so similar, many investors decide on the platform and the fund range. Open the app or website of each before you transfer money, look at the funds and research you would actually use, and check the current cash sweep rate, which is not published for either broker. Moving an account later is possible, but outgoing transfers can take time and some funds cannot move between brokers.

Read the full Charles Schwab review and Fidelity review, or see all broker comparisons. The value of investments can fall as well as rise.

Frequently asked questions

Is Schwab or Fidelity cheaper?

For online US stock and ETF trades, both charge nothing, and both charge the same per-contract fee on options. The differences are in foreign shares, broker-assisted trades and fund choices, so compare the products you will actually buy.

Which is better for retirement accounts?

Both offer a full range of IRAs, 529 plans and custodial accounts. Schwab adds an Individual 401(k), and Fidelity adds Inherited IRAs and a Youth Account.

Which is better for active traders?

Schwab, for most. Its thinkorswim platform is built for active stock, options and futures traders. Fidelity's Active Trader Pro is capable, but Fidelity does not mention futures.

Can I buy international shares?

Fidelity offers online trading on many foreign markets in taxable accounts. Schwab's foreign trading is mostly through US over-the-counter listings online, with local-exchange trades by broker only, at a higher cost.

Are Schwab and Fidelity safe?

Both are large, long-established US brokers registered with the SEC and FINRA, with SIPC cover on securities accounts. Schwab is listed on the NYSE; Fidelity is privately owned.