DEGIRO vs XTB
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
DEGIRO and XTB are both European brokers with low costs, but they reach investors in different ways. XTB charges no commission on shares and ETFs up to a monthly turnover limit, pays interest on cash, offers fractional shares and an ISA in the UK, and runs a large CFD business alongside. DEGIRO charges a small commission and handling fee, pays no interest, but has a lower currency fee, longer exchange and ETF lists, and real options and futures. Pick XTB for zero-commission investing and interest on idle cash. Pick DEGIRO for wider market access, derivatives or a lower FX fee.
- Minimum deposit
- EUR 0
- GBP 0
- Max leverage
- —
- 1:500 (CFDs) (FSC Belize)
- Regulators
- BaFin
- FCA, KNF, CySEC, FSC Belize
- Platforms
- DEGIRO web platform, DEGIRO mobile app
- XTB web platform, XTB mobile app
- Funding methods
- 4
- 4
- Trustpilot
- 4.5 / 5
- 3.8 / 5
- Founded
- 2008
- 2004
- Headquarters
- Amsterdam, Netherlands (DEGIRO brand); parent flatexDEGIRO Bank SE is based in Frankfurt am Main, Germany
- Warsaw, Poland
Safety and regulation
Winner: XTB, narrowly. DEGIRO operates as flatexDEGIRO Bank SE under BaFin number 10119766, with protection of 90% of securities claims up to EUR 20,000; cash in the flatexDEGIRO cash account up to EUR 100,000.
XTB has been listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange since 2016. It is licensed by Poland's KNF under DDM-M-4021-57-1/2005, with compensation up to EUR 20,100, by the FCA under 522157 and by CySEC. It also runs a Belize entity for international clients, with CFD leverage up to 1:500 (CFDs) and no negative balance protection.
XTB takes the area for its UK license and for stating negative balance protection at its European entities. DEGIRO mentions none for its margin accounts. If you would join XTB's Belize entity, the comparison reverses.
Costs
Winner: XTB on commission; DEGIRO on currency. XTB's pricing is 0% commission up to EUR 100,000 monthly turnover; 0.2% (minimum GBP 10) above that. DEGIRO's US pricing is EUR 1.00 commission plus EUR 1.00 handling fee per trade (US and Canada). DEGIRO's European share pricing: Xetra: EUR 3.90 commission plus EUR 1.00 handling fee. Euronext rates vary by country of residence.
Currency conversion favors DEGIRO, which charges a low automatic rate. 0.25% on automatic conversion (AutoFX); manual conversion EUR 10 plus 0.25%. XTB charges 0.5%. A euro investor buying US shares at XTB pays no commission but a higher conversion rate than DEGIRO's, so on large US orders DEGIRO can be cheaper overall.
Holding costs at XTB: None up to EUR 250,000 held; above that 0.02% a year, minimum GBP 10. At DEGIRO: None on shares and ETFs. A yearly exchange connectivity fee of EUR 2.50 applies per exchange outside the home market, capped at 0.25% of account value. XTB has one fee DEGIRO does not: EUR 10 a month after 12 months without trading, if no deposit was made in the last 90 days. Both deposit and withdraw for free by bank transfer.
Accounts
Winner: XTB. It pays interest on uninvested cash. 4% AER (variable) on GBP, 2.3% on EUR and 3.45% on USD uninvested funds in a general investment account. DEGIRO's position on cash is simpler. None; no interest is paid on uninvested cash. XTB offers Stocks and Shares ISA, Cash ISA for UK clients; DEGIRO offers no tax wrappers.
Both have no minimum, at 0 EUR and 0 GBP. DEGIRO offers more account currencies, with EUR, GBP, CHF, DKK, SEK, CZK, PLN against GBP, EUR, USD at XTB.
Platforms and features
Winner: XTB. Both run a web platform and app. XTB adds fractional shares, recurring investing and a demo account. DEGIRO adds margin, short selling and extended-hours trading on its investing account; at XTB, leverage and short positions are only available through the separate CFD account. Apps are rated 4.7 on the App Store for XTB and 4.5 for DEGIRO.
Funding
Winner: XTB. XTB takes cards, bank transfers, PayPal and Skrill, and bank withdrawals arrive Same business day if requested before 1 pm, otherwise next business day. DEGIRO takes bank transfers, iDEAL, Sofort and Trustly, and withdraws by bank in Up to 3 business days.
Markets
Winner: DEGIRO for investors. DEGIRO offers 50 exchanges in 30 countries and around 5,000 ETFs, plus options, futures, bonds and funds. XTB offers about 6,900 stocks and 2,300 ETFs from 14 markets, with no bonds or funds in its investing account. XTB's CFDs cover far more markets, but as leveraged contracts rather than investments you own.
Research and support
Winner: XTB. XTB answers by live chat, email and phone, 24 hours a day, Monday to Friday. DEGIRO answers by phone and email, Monday to Friday, 8:00 to 22:00 CET. On Trustpilot, DEGIRO scores 4.5 from 5,937 reviews and XTB 3.8 from 3,107, so users rate DEGIRO higher even though XTB offers more channels and hours.
Working out which costs less for you
Because XTB and DEGIRO charge in different places, the cheaper broker depends on what you buy. Three questions settle most cases:
- Do you buy mainly in your own currency? If you are a euro investor buying shares listed in euros, there is no conversion at either broker, and XTB's zero commission wins.
- Do you buy mainly in another currency? Then conversion is the main cost. XTB's rate applies to the whole order value; DEGIRO's commission is small and its conversion rate lower. Work out both for your usual order size.
- Will you trade every month? If not, XTB's inactivity fee can apply after a year without trading and without a deposit, while DEGIRO charges nothing for an idle account.
The currency conversion fee calculator can help with the second question.
Two different kinds of broker
XTB began as a CFD and forex broker and added real shares and ETFs later; its investing account sits beside a CFD account in the same app. DEGIRO has always been an investment broker, and it offers margin and derivatives as extras for experienced investors on the same account. Neither approach is unsafe, but in both cases new investors should make sure they know which product an order uses before they place it.
Which should you choose?
- Investors who want zero commission and interest on cash: XTB.
- Euro investors who mainly buy US shares in large amounts: DEGIRO, for its lower FX fee.
- Options and futures investors: DEGIRO.
- UK residents: XTB, since DEGIRO does not accept new UK clients.
- Investors who may leave the account idle for a year or more: DEGIRO, which has no inactivity fee.
Most retail CFD accounts lose money, and margin at DEGIRO can lose more than you deposit. Read the full DEGIRO review and XTB review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Is XTB cheaper than DEGIRO?
For most share and ETF investors, yes on commission, since XTB charges none up to a monthly turnover limit. DEGIRO's currency conversion fee is lower than XTB's, so investors who mostly buy in other currencies should compare both costs.
Does XTB charge an inactivity fee?
Yes, after a long period without trading and without a recent deposit. DEGIRO has no inactivity fee.
Which pays interest on cash?
XTB pays interest on uninvested cash in several currencies. DEGIRO pays none.
Which has more markets?
DEGIRO lists more exchanges and many more ETFs, and offers options and futures for investors. XTB offers a large share and ETF list, plus CFDs on many more markets.
Can UK residents use both?
XTB serves UK clients through an FCA-regulated company with an ISA. DEGIRO is closed to new UK clients.