Eightcap vs Octa
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
Eightcap and Octa are both commission-free forex brokers at heart, but their regulation and tools set them apart. Eightcap is an Australian broker with ASIC, FCA and CySEC licenses, a published Standard account cost, a raw account, a long share CFD list and TradingView at the center of its offer. Octa is a low-deposit broker with one simple price across three platforms, swap-free accounts, free deposits and withdrawals, fast e-wallet and crypto payouts, guaranteed stops and copy trading, but its main international entity is lightly regulated. Pick Eightcap for strong regulation and TradingView. Pick Octa for low entry costs and swap-free holding.
- Minimum deposit
- USD 100
- USD 25
- Max leverage
- 1:500 (SCB)
- 1:1000 (MISA)
- EUR/USD average spread
- 1 pips (Standard)
- 0.9 pips (OctaTrader)
- Regulators
- ASIC, FCA, CySEC, SCB, FSA, FSC
- MISA, CySEC, FSCA, FSC
- Platforms
- MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView
- Proprietary platform, MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5
- Funding methods
- 7
- 10
- Trustpilot
- Not shown
- 3.7 / 5
- Founded
- 2009
- 2011
- Headquarters
- Melbourne, Australia
- Mwali, Comoros
Safety and regulation
Winner: Eightcap. Eightcap serves Australian clients under ASIC license AFSL 391441, UK clients under FCA license FRN 921296 with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000, and EU clients under CySEC license 246/14. Its offshore entities are in the Bahamas, the Seychelles and Mauritius.
Octa's EU entity holds CySEC license 372/18, with compensation up to EUR 20,000. Its main international entity is registered with the Mwali authority (T2023320), the weakest of our regulator tiers, with leverage up to 1:1000.
Both state negative balance protection on their main entities. Eightcap is a private company controlled by chairman and former CEO Joel Murphy and by Joe Jeffriess. Octa is a private company and is not publicly traded. It traded as OctaFX until its rebrand.
Costs
Winner: Octa, narrowly, on commission-free accounts. Both publish an average EUR/USD spread. One standard lot, opened and closed:
- Octa (all accounts): 9 USD, from an average of 0.9 pips
- Eightcap Standard: 10 USD, from an average of 1 pip
The gap is small. Eightcap adds a Raw account at 7 USD per round turn, but publishes no raw average spread, so its raw cost cannot be placed on the same basis.
Octa's accounts are swap-free, which helps on longer holds. Neither charges an inactivity fee. Octa charges None for withdrawals. Eightcap's withdrawal terms: No internal fees. Bank transfer via Eurobank EUR 4-10. See Eightcap fees and Octa fees.
Accounts
Winner: Octa for entry; Eightcap for choice. Octa's minimum is 25 USD, against 100 USD at Eightcap. Octa's three accounts share one pricing model. Eightcap offers commission-free and raw accounts, professional terms and an Islamic account.
Platforms
Winner: Eightcap. Eightcap offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, with TradingView central to its offer, plus VPS hosting. Octa offers Proprietary platform, MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, with copy trading and guaranteed stops, neither of which Eightcap offers, but no VPS. Both allow scalping and algorithmic trading.
Funding
Winner: Octa. At Octa, Skrill and Neteller withdrawals take 1-3 hours, and crypto 1-3 hours to approve, up to 30 minutes to transfer, all free. At Eightcap, cards, Skrill and PayPal take 1-2 business days, Neteller 1 business day, and BPAY 1-3 business days. Eightcap supports PayPal; Octa supports crypto and FasaPay.
Markets
Winner: Eightcap. Eightcap offers about 800 instruments, including 56 forex pairs and about 590 share CFDs. Octa offers about 260, including 52 forex pairs, 10 indices and 27 crypto CFDs. Their forex lists are similar; Eightcap's share list is far longer.
Research and support
Winner: Octa for hours. Both publish news, an economic calendar, daily analysis and webinars. Octa adds courses. Octa answers 24/7 by chat and email; Eightcap answers 24/5 by chat, email and phone. Octa scores 3.7 on Trustpilot from 9,986 reviews; Eightcap's score is not published.
The value of a strong license
Octa's prices are competitive, and its swap-free accounts are genuinely useful. The trade-off is oversight. An international client at Octa's Mwali entity has no regulator that supervises capital, client money or conduct in the way ASIC, the FCA or CySEC do, and no compensation scheme. Eightcap's clients in Australia, the UK and the EU have all of those, and even its offshore entities sit with tier-3 regulators. For many traders, that difference is worth a small amount of extra spread. EU residents can sidestep the issue at Octa by joining its CySEC entity, which brings European rules and compensation, although with lower leverage than Octa offers elsewhere.
Holding overnight
Eightcap charges normal swaps on positions held past the daily rollover, while Octa charges none. For a trader who holds a position for a week, several nights of swaps can exceed the spread difference between the two. For a day trader who always closes before the rollover, swaps never apply. Run your usual trade through the swap calculator to see which effect dominates for you.
Tools each one adds
Octa lists two tools Eightcap does not: copy trading, which mirrors another trader's positions in your account, and guaranteed stops, which close a trade at your chosen level even if the price gaps past it. Both can help newer traders manage risk, although copying passes decisions to someone else and guaranteed stops may carry a cost. Eightcap's additions are aimed at more technical traders: VPS hosting for Expert Advisors that need to run around the clock, professional account terms and a Raw account for traders who prefer to pay commission in exchange for interbank spreads. Its integration with TradingView also lets chart-based traders place orders straight from their analysis.
Starting small
Octa's lower minimum deposit and single price make it easy to open a small account and learn without worrying about which account type to choose. Eightcap's minimum is higher but still modest, and its Standard account is similarly simple. Whichever you choose, both offer demo accounts, so you can practice the platform and see live spreads before you fund the account. Start with a size you can afford to lose while you learn how leverage affects your balance.
Which should you choose?
- Australian, UK and EU traders: Eightcap, or Octa's CySEC entity in the EU.
- TradingView traders: Eightcap.
- Swing traders and those who need swap-free trading: Octa.
- Share CFD traders: Eightcap.
- Traders starting with a small deposit: Octa.
Most retail CFD accounts lose money. Read the full Eightcap review and Octa review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Is Eightcap safer than Octa?
For most traders, yes. Eightcap serves Australian, UK and EU clients through ASIC, FCA and CySEC entities, and its offshore entities are in the Bahamas and Seychelles. Octa's main international entity is registered in Mwali, which gives very little oversight, though it has a CySEC entity for EU clients.
Which has lower spreads?
Octa's published average EUR/USD spread is a little tighter than Eightcap's Standard account average, so its commission-free cost per lot is slightly lower. Eightcap also offers a raw account with commission, which Octa does not.
Does Octa charge swaps?
Octa's accounts are swap-free. Eightcap charges normal swaps and lists an Islamic account.
Which is better for TradingView?
Eightcap, which offers TradingView as a main platform. Octa offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 and its own OctaTrader platform.
Which has more markets?
Eightcap, mainly because of its much longer share CFD list.