Skip to content
Menu

Eightcap vs Vantage

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Safety and regulation
  2. Costs
  3. Accounts
  4. Platforms
  5. Funding
  6. Markets
  7. Research and support
  8. Two brokers from the same starting point
  9. Published prices
  10. Spread betting and the UK
  11. Which should you choose?

Eightcap (founded 2009) and Vantage (founded 2009) both started in Australia and both hold ASIC and FCA licenses, so they are close rivals. Eightcap is focused on TradingView and MetaTrader, with a published Standard account cost, a CySEC entity for the EU, a long share CFD list and no inactivity fee. Vantage adds its own app, copy trading, a cent account, spread betting in the UK, a Pro ECN account with a reduced commission, free card and e-wallet withdrawals within a day and round-the-clock chat. Pick Eightcap if you trade mainly on TradingView or live in the EU. Pick Vantage for copy trading, lower raw commissions and faster free withdrawals. Both offer demo accounts and allow Expert Advisors, so algorithmic traders can test either before funding.

Minimum deposit
USD 100
USD 50
Max leverage
1:500 (SCB)
1:30 (ASIC)
EUR/USD average spread
1 pips (Standard)
1.4 pips (Standard STP)
Regulators
ASIC, FCA, CySEC, SCB, FSA, FSC
FSC, VFSC, FSCA, ASIC, FCA, CIMA
Platforms
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, Proprietary platform
Funding methods
7
16
Trustpilot
Not shown
4.4 / 5
Founded
2009
2009
Headquarters
Melbourne, Australia
Sydney, Australia

Safety and regulation

Winner: Eightcap, narrowly. Both serve Australians under ASIC, Eightcap under AFSL 391441 and Vantage under AFSL 428901, and UK clients under the FCA, Eightcap under FRN 921296 and Vantage under FRN 590299, both with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000.

Eightcap adds a CySEC entity (246/14) for EU clients, with investor compensation up to EUR 20,000. Vantage has no EU entity. Offshore, Eightcap uses the Bahamas, Seychelles and Mauritius; Vantage uses Vanuatu, the Cayman Islands, Mauritius and South Africa.

Both state negative balance protection on their main entities. Eightcap edges the area for its EU license. Eightcap is a private company controlled by chairman and former CEO Joel Murphy and by Joe Jeffriess. Vantage is a private company and is not publicly traded.

Costs

Winner: Vantage on raw accounts; no winner on spread-only accounts. Eightcap publishes a Standard account benchmark: one standard lot of EUR/USD costs 10 USD, from an average spread of 1 pip. Vantage's Standard STP lists spreads from 1.4 pips with no published average, so the two cannot be ranked.

On raw accounts, Eightcap charges 7 USD per round turn and Vantage's Raw ECN 6. Vantage's Pro ECN cuts that to 3 for a balance of 10,000 USD. Neither publishes a raw average spread, so this compares commission only.

Neither charges an inactivity fee. Withdrawal fees at Eightcap: No internal fees. Bank transfer via Eurobank EUR 4-10. At Vantage: None, except USD 20 for bank wire withdrawals; Neteller and Skrill charge their own fees. See Eightcap fees and Vantage fees.

Accounts

Winner: Vantage. Vantage's minimum is 50 USD, against 100 USD at Eightcap. Vantage offers four accounts, including a cent account and Pro ECN, plus spread betting in the UK. Eightcap offers Standard and Raw and lists an Islamic account. Both list professional terms.

Platforms

Winner: Vantage, narrowly. Both offer MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 and TradingView, with VPS hosting and scalping allowed. Vantage adds its own app and copy trading through Vantage Copy Trading. Eightcap does not offer copy trading. TradingView is the center of Eightcap's offer, which TradingView-first traders may value more than Vantage's extras.

Funding

Winner: Vantage. At Vantage, cards, Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal, Skrill, Neteller and regional methods are paid Up to 24 hours, free. At Eightcap, cards, Skrill and PayPal take 1-2 business days, Neteller 1 business day and BPAY 1-3 business days. Bank transfers take 1-5 business days at Eightcap and 3-7 business days at Vantage, where a wire withdrawal costs USD 20.

Markets

Tie. Both list about the same number of instruments: Eightcap about 800 and Vantage about 1,000. Eightcap publishes 56 forex pairs and about 590 share CFDs. Vantage publishes 33 indices, about 800 share CFDs and 57 ETFs, which Eightcap does not offer.

Research and support

Winner: Vantage. Both publish news, an economic calendar, daily analysis and webinars. Vantage adds Trading Central and courses. Vantage offers Live chat 24/7; phone 24/5; Eightcap answers 24/5. Vantage scores 4.4 on Trustpilot from 16,133 reviews; Eightcap's score is not published.

Two brokers from the same starting point

Eightcap and Vantage both began in Australia and both expanded into the UK, which is why their regulation looks so similar. Their paths have since diverged. Eightcap kept a narrow focus on MetaTrader and TradingView with a short list of accounts, and added an EU entity. Vantage built a wider product: its own app, copy trading, a cent account, a premium raw account for large traders, spread betting in the UK and a long list of regional payment methods. A trader who values simplicity and lives in the EU will find Eightcap easier; one who wants more tools and faster free withdrawals will find more at Vantage.

Published prices

Eightcap's published average spread on its Standard account lets you compare it directly with any broker on our trading cost index. Vantage publishes only minimum spreads, which appear at the most liquid moments and do not show typical costs. Before you choose on price alone, open demo accounts at both and watch the EUR/USD spread at the times you trade; that gives you a fair comparison. Note the spread during news releases as well, when the gap between minimum and typical spreads is widest.

Spread betting and the UK

UK clients at Vantage can trade through spread betting as well as CFDs. Spread bets are priced in pounds per point, and under current UK rules their profits are generally free of capital gains tax and stamp duty, though tax treatment depends on your circumstances and can change. Eightcap does not offer spread betting, so UK traders there trade CFDs only, where gains may be taxable. For a UK trader who expects to make taxable gains, this can matter more than a small difference in spreads. Losses on spread bets cannot usually be offset against other gains, so the tax benefit cuts both ways.

Which should you choose?

  • EU traders: Eightcap, through its CySEC entity.
  • TradingView-first traders: Eightcap, though Vantage also offers TradingView.
  • Copy traders: Vantage.
  • Raw-account traders with large balances: Vantage's Pro ECN.
  • Traders who withdraw often by card or e-wallet: Vantage.

Most retail CFD accounts lose money. Read the full Eightcap review and Vantage review, or see all broker comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

Is Eightcap cheaper than Vantage?

Eightcap publishes an average spread on its Standard account, while Vantage publishes only minimum spreads, so commission-free accounts cannot be ranked like for like. On raw accounts, Vantage's standard commission is a little lower, and its Pro ECN account is lower still for large balances.

Which is better regulated?

Both have ASIC and FCA entities. Eightcap adds CySEC for EU clients; Vantage has no EU entity. Both state negative balance protection on their main entities.

Do both offer TradingView?

Yes. TradingView is central to Eightcap's offer, and Vantage also offers it alongside MetaTrader and its own app.

Which offers copy trading?

Vantage, through its own copy trading service. Eightcap does not offer copy trading.

Which has better support?

Vantage offers live chat around the clock and phone on weekdays. Eightcap answers on weekdays around the clock.