Skip to content
Menu

Eightcap vs XM

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Safety and regulation
  2. Costs
  3. Accounts
  4. Platforms
  5. Funding
  6. Markets
  7. Research and support
  8. The cost of a pause
  9. Charting and execution
  10. Real shares and professional terms
  11. Which should you choose?

Eightcap and XM are both MetaTrader brokers with CySEC entities in Europe and offshore entities for the rest of the world, but they differ elsewhere. Eightcap is an Australian broker with ASIC and FCA licenses, a published Standard account cost, raw pricing, no inactivity fee and close TradingView integration. XM is a global broker with a token minimum deposit, many regional entities, instant e-wallet withdrawals, copy trading, real shares and support around the clock, but an inactivity fee after a short break. Pick Eightcap if you live in Australia or the UK, or trade on TradingView. Pick XM for a very small start, copy trading and fast e-wallet payouts. Both offer demo accounts, so you can compare their platforms and live spreads before depositing. Both also offer Islamic accounts for traders who cannot pay or receive swaps.

XM
4.6 / 5
Visit
Minimum deposit
USD 100
USD 5
Max leverage
1:500 (SCB)
1:1000 (FSC Belize)
EUR/USD average spread
1 pips (Standard)
1.6 pips (Standard)
Regulators
ASIC, FCA, CySEC, SCB, FSA, FSC
CySEC, FSC Belize, FSC, FSA, BVI FSC, FSCA, DFSA, UAE CMA, CMA
Platforms
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform
Funding methods
7
9
Trustpilot
Not shown
Not shown
Founded
2009
2009
Headquarters
Melbourne, Australia
Limassol, Cyprus

Safety and regulation

Winner: Eightcap. Eightcap serves Australian clients under ASIC license AFSL 391441, UK clients under FCA license FRN 921296 with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000, and EU clients under CySEC license 246/14. Its Bahamas entity allows leverage up to 1:500.

XM's EU entity holds CySEC license 120/10, with compensation up to EUR 20,000, and it has a DFSA entity in Dubai. International clients sign with XM Global in Belize, at up to 1:1000. XM has no UK or Australian entity.

Both state negative balance protection on their main entities. Eightcap is a private company controlled by chairman and former CEO Joel Murphy and by Joe Jeffriess. XM is a private company: it is a trading name of Trading Point Holdings Ltd, part of Trading Point Group, which co-founder Costas Cleanthous controls.

Costs

Winner: Eightcap. Eightcap publishes a benchmark for its Standard account: one standard lot of EUR/USD costs 10 USD, from an average spread of 1 pip. XM publishes only minimums: from 1.6 pips on Standard and 0.8 on Ultra Low. Without an average, XM's spread-only accounts cannot be ranked against Eightcap's.

Raw accounts are level: Eightcap's Raw charges 7 USD per round turn and XM's Zero 7 USD.

Eightcap takes the area on non-trading fees. Its inactivity fee is None; XM charges USD 10 per month after 90 days without trading, deposits or withdrawals. Withdrawal fees at XM: None; XM covers payment fees, except bank wires under USD 200. At Eightcap: No internal fees. Bank transfer via Eurobank EUR 4-10. See Eightcap fees and XM fees.

Accounts

Winner: XM. XM's minimum is 5 USD on Standard, Ultra Low and Zero, against 100 USD at Eightcap. XM adds a Shares account for real stocks and swap-free versions of Ultra Low and Zero. Eightcap offers Standard and Raw and lists an Islamic account.

Platforms

Winner: Eightcap for TradingView; XM for copy trading. Eightcap offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, with TradingView at the center of its offer. XM offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform, with TradingView integration and copy trading; Eightcap does not offer copy trading. Both offer VPS hosting and allow algorithmic trading. Eightcap allows scalping; XM does not publish its policy.

Funding

Winner: XM for e-wallets; Eightcap for cards. At XM, Skrill, Neteller and Google Pay withdrawals are Instant, and cards and bank transfers 2-5 business days. At Eightcap, cards, Skrill and PayPal take 1-2 business days, Neteller 1 business day, and bank transfers 1-5 business days. Eightcap adds PayPal and BPAY; XM adds crypto and M-Pesa.

Markets

Winner: XM. XM offers about 1,400 instruments, including 21 indices, 20 commodities and about 1,200 share CFDs, plus real shares. Eightcap offers about 800, including 56 forex pairs, 16 indices and about 590 share CFDs.

Research and support

Winner: XM. Both publish news, an economic calendar, daily analysis and webinars. XM adds Trading Central and courses. XM answers 24/7; Eightcap answers 24/5. Neither has a published Trustpilot score, so reviews cannot be compared.

The cost of a pause

XM's inactivity fee starts after a short period without trading, deposits or withdrawals, and it is taken from your balance each month after that. Eightcap has none. For a trader who trades every week, the difference is irrelevant. For someone who opens an account, tries a strategy and then stops for a season, XM's fee can slowly drain what is left. If you plan to pause, withdraw your balance first. Check the exact trigger in XM's fee schedule, since it counts deposits and withdrawals as activity too. Eightcap's main non-trading costs are bank-related: certain bank transfer routes carry a fee, and PayPal withdrawals in another currency carry conversion.

Charting and execution

Eightcap's appeal for many traders is that they can analyze and trade in TradingView without switching windows, using its charting, alerts and community scripts. XM's platforms are MetaTrader and its own app, with TradingView integration as an option. Algorithmic traders who use Expert Advisors will find MetaTrader at both. If your strategy depends on TradingView alerts and Pine Script indicators, test the TradingView connection at each broker on a demo account before you fund a live one.

Real shares and professional terms

XM is one of the few forex brokers in this comparison set with an account for real, unleveraged shares, although its minimum deposit puts it out of reach of small investors. Eightcap offers shares as CFDs only. On the professional side, Eightcap's EU entity lists leverage of up to 1:400 for clients who qualify as professional, and both brokers list professional account terms. Qualifying as professional removes retail leverage caps but also some retail protections, so weigh the trade-off before you apply. For most retail traders the regulated retail account, with negative balance protection and capped leverage, is the safer starting point.

Which should you choose?

  • Australian and UK traders: Eightcap, since XM has no ASIC or FCA entity.
  • TradingView traders: Eightcap.
  • Traders starting with a very small deposit: XM.
  • Copy traders: XM.
  • Traders who may pause for months: Eightcap, which charges no inactivity fee.

Most retail CFD accounts lose money. Read the full Eightcap review and XM review, or see all broker comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better regulated, Eightcap or XM?

Eightcap, for Australian and UK traders, since it has ASIC and FCA entities and XM does not. In the EU both use CySEC entities. Outside these regions both place clients with offshore entities.

Which is cheaper?

Eightcap publishes an average spread on its Standard account, while XM publishes only minimum spreads, so they cannot be ranked like for like. Both charge the same commission on their raw accounts. XM charges an inactivity fee; Eightcap does not.

Does Eightcap have a minimum deposit?

Yes, a modest one. XM's minimum is a token amount on its main accounts.

Which is better for TradingView?

Eightcap, which builds much of its offer around TradingView. XM also integrates with TradingView.

Does Eightcap offer copy trading?

It does not offer a copy trading service. XM offers copy trading.