eToro vs IC Markets
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
eToro and IC Markets sit at opposite ends of the retail market. IC Markets is a raw-spread broker built for scalpers and algorithmic traders, with MetaTrader, cTrader and TradingView. eToro is a listed social investing app with real shares and CopyTrader. Pick IC Markets if you trade forex or CFDs often and care about cost per trade. Pick eToro if you want to invest, copy others, or trade under the FCA in the UK.
- Minimum deposit
- USD 50
- USD 0
- Max leverage
- 1:400 (FSA)
- 1:5000 (FSA)
- EUR/USD average spread
- 1 pips (eToro account)
- 0.01 pips (Raw Spread (MetaTrader))
- Regulators
- CySEC, FCA, ASIC, FSA, FSRA, MAS
- FSA, CySEC, ASIC, SCB, CMA
- Platforms
- Proprietary platform
- MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader, TradingView
- Funding methods
- 13
- 16
- Trustpilot
- 4 / 5
- 4.8 / 5
- Founded
- 2007
- 2007
- Headquarters
- Bnei Brak, Israel
- Sydney, Australia
Safety and regulation
Winner: eToro. In Australia and the EU the two are level. Both are licensed by ASIC, and both have CySEC companies covered by the Investor Compensation Fund up to EUR 20,000. Retail leverage there is capped at 1:30 at both.
eToro goes further. It has an FCA entity, license 583263, with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000, plus entities in Abu Dhabi and Singapore, and its Nasdaq listing means audited accounts. IC Markets has no UK entity, is privately held, and does not publish group accounts. It does have a Kenyan license and a Bahamas entity, which eToro lacks.
Both use the Seychelles for many international clients, which makes for a fair comparison. eToro offers negative balance protection there and caps leverage at 1:400. IC Markets allows up to 1:5000, and clients are responsible for negative balances, so the protection does not apply. IC Markets relies on a private insurance policy, up to USD 1,000,000 for all claimants, on insolvency of Raw Trading Ltd, a cap shared by all claimants.
Costs
Winner: IC Markets, clearly. eToro's single account is commission-free, so its natural rival is IC Markets' Standard account, but IC Markets publishes only a "from" spread of 0.8 pips there, not an average. Those two cannot be ranked. IC Markets' raw accounts, however, are cheaper than eToro on any measure. One standard lot of EUR/USD, opened and closed:
- eToro: 10 USD
- IC Markets Raw Spread (MetaTrader): 7.1 USD
- IC Markets Raw Spread (cTrader): 6.1 USD
For someone placing a few forex trades a month next to a share portfolio, the gap is small. For a scalper trading several lots a day, it compounds quickly over a year.
Non-trading fees also favor IC Markets. It charges no deposit, withdrawal or inactivity fee for global clients and offers many base currencies. eToro charges USD 5 on withdrawals from USD accounts; free from GBP and EUR accounts; minimum withdrawal USD 30, and a conversion fee on money moved in currencies other than USD, GBP or EUR. eToro has dropped its inactivity fee, so neither charges for an idle account. Overnight funding applies at both on leveraged positions; IC Markets' swap-free accounts pay a flat holding fee instead.
More detail: eToro fees and IC Markets fees
Accounts
Winner: IC Markets. Its main accounts have a minimum deposit of 0 USD, against 50 USD at eToro. It offers a choice of pricing model and Raw Pro accounts with commission cut to 3 USD per round trip for larger balances.
eToro's single account is simpler and does something IC Markets cannot: it holds real shares, ETFs and crypto alongside CFDs. Both offer micro lots, swap-free accounts and professional status. See eToro account types and IC Markets account types.
Platforms
Winner: IC Markets for technical traders; eToro for beginners. IC Markets offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader and a TradingView connection, with scalping, Expert Advisors, VPS hosting and API access. eToro runs only on its own platform, which is easy to learn but has no MetaTrader and no way to run custom indicators.
Copy trading works at both. eToro's CopyTrader sits inside the same app as your portfolio, with public statistics on each trader. IC Markets connects to cTrader Copy, ZuluTrade, IC Social, Signal Start, which suit traders already using MetaTrader or cTrader. Copying passes on losses as well as gains.
Funding
Winner: IC Markets. Its PayPal, Skrill and Neteller withdrawals are Instant once processed, crypto withdrawals take Up to 2 hours after processing, and card withdrawals 3-5 business days after processing (up to 10). IC Markets charges no fee of its own.
eToro's e-wallet withdrawals take Up to 2 business days, and card and bank withdrawals can take Up to 10 business days, with the flat fee on USD accounts. eToro has the better spread of European methods, including iDEAL and Przelewy24; IC Markets is stronger for Australia, Thailand and Vietnam.
Markets
Split. IC Markets publishes around 2,250 instruments, including 61 forex pairs, 2,100 share CFDs and 94 crypto CFDs. eToro does not publish counts, so the two cannot be ranked by size.
eToro has the one thing IC Markets does not: real assets. Buying a stock, ETF or crypto without leverage at eToro gives you the asset in most regions, with no overnight funding. At IC Markets, everything is a CFD.
Research and support
Split. IC Markets wins research, with Trading Central on top of news, daily analysis, an economic calendar and webinars. eToro wins education: eToro Academy has structured courses and its demo never expires, while IC Markets has no structured courses.
IC Markets wins support. It answers 24/7 by live chat, email and phone. eToro answers 24/5 by ticket; live chat for logged-in clients, with an automated assistant available 24/7, with no phone line for most clients.
Which should you choose?
- Scalpers and algorithmic traders: IC Markets, for raw pricing, cTrader, VPS and API access.
- Investors who want real shares alongside some trading: eToro.
- Beginners who want to copy others in one app: eToro.
- UK residents: eToro, since IC Markets has no FCA entity.
- International clients who want stated negative balance protection: eToro.
- UK traders who want raw spreads: neither offers both. Pepperstone is a third option with an FCA entity and raw-spread accounts (see how it compares with eToro).
Very high leverage can wipe out an account in moments. Read the full eToro review and IC Markets review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Is IC Markets cheaper than eToro?
For forex, yes. IC Markets' Raw Spread account costs clearly less per lot than eToro's commission-free pricing, and IC Markets charges no withdrawal fee. IC Markets publishes no average for its own Standard account, so the two commission-free offers cannot be ranked directly.
Which is safer, eToro or IC Markets?
eToro. Both are regulated in Australia and the EU, but eToro adds an FCA entity and a Nasdaq listing, and offers negative balance protection on its offshore entity. IC Markets serves most international clients from the Seychelles without stated negative balance protection.
Does IC Markets have copy trading like eToro?
Yes, through cTrader Copy, ZuluTrade, IC Social and Signal Start. eToro's CopyTrader is built into its own app and is easier for beginners.
Can I buy real shares at IC Markets?
No. IC Markets is CFD-only. eToro sells real shares and ETFs in most regions when you buy without leverage.
Can UK residents use IC Markets?
IC Markets has no FCA entity. eToro serves UK clients through an FCA-regulated company.