Skip to content
Menu

eToro vs XTB

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Safety and regulation
  2. Costs
  3. Accounts
  4. Platforms
  5. Funding
  6. Markets
  7. Research and support
  8. Which should you choose?

eToro and XTB are the two listed brokers that most European investors weigh against each other, because both put real stocks, ETFs and CFDs in a single account. The difference is style. eToro is built around social trading, with CopyTrader and a news feed. XTB is built around its own xStation platform and analyst team, with no minimum deposit. Pick eToro if you want to copy others or live outside Europe. Pick XTB if you trade and invest on your own and want a well-designed platform.

eToro
4.4 / 5
Visit
XTB
4.1 / 5
Visit
Minimum deposit
USD 50
USD 0
Max leverage
1:400 (FSA)
1:500 (CMF)
EUR/USD average spread
1 pips (eToro account)
1.06 pips (Standard)
Regulators
CySEC, FCA, ASIC, FSA, FSRA, MAS
KNF, FCA, CySEC, DFSA, UAE CMA, CMF, BAPPEBTI, FSC Belize
Platforms
Proprietary platform
Proprietary platform
Funding methods
13
5
Trustpilot
4 / 5
3.8 / 5
Founded
2007
2004
Headquarters
Bnei Brak, Israel
Warsaw, Poland

Safety and regulation

Winner: eToro, because of its offshore terms. In the UK and EU the two are level. Both are listed, eToro on Nasdaq and XTB on the Warsaw Stock Exchange, and both publish audited results. UK clients sign with an FCA-regulated company at both: eToro (UK) Ltd, license 583263, and XTB Limited, FRN 522157, each with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000.

In the EU, eToro serves clients from Cyprus, covered by the Investor Compensation Fund up to EUR 20,000. XTB serves most EU clients from Poland, covered by the KDPW investor compensation scheme up to EUR 20,100. eToro adds an ASIC entity, which XTB lacks; XTB adds entities in Dubai, onshore UAE, Chile and Indonesia.

The difference is offshore. eToro's Seychelles company offers negative balance protection, with leverage up to 1:400. XTB International in Belize allows leverage up to 1:500 and offers no negative balance protection, so a sharp gap can leave the account owing money.

Costs

Winner: eToro on forex, narrowly. Both price forex CFDs through the spread with no commission, so this is like for like. One standard lot of EUR/USD, opened and closed:

  • eToro: 10 USD, from a typical spread of 1 pip
  • XTB: 10.6 USD, from a group average of 1.06 pips

The gap is small enough that non-trading fees may matter more:

  • Inactivity: eToro charges none. XTB charges EUR 10 per month if no buy or sell transaction has been made within 365 days, which one trade a year avoids.
  • Withdrawals: eToro charges USD 5 on withdrawals from USD accounts; free from GBP and EUR accounts; minimum withdrawal USD 30. XTB's charge is Free above USD 50; USD 30 below USD 50.
  • Conversion: XTB charges 0.5%. eToro's rate varies by location, payment method and Club level.
  • Deposits: XTB charges a percentage on Skrill and Neteller deposits; eToro's deposits are free.

XTB publishes its stock and ETF pricing clearly: commission-free up to a monthly turnover limit, then a small percentage. There is no like-for-like figure for eToro's share dealing, so the two cannot be ranked on investing costs.

More detail: eToro fees and XTB fees

Accounts

Winner: XTB, for its entry point. It has no minimum deposit, 0 USD, against 50 USD at eToro in most countries. Otherwise the two are alike: one account for everything, micro lots, professional status and a swap-free option. Both offer only EUR, USD, GBP as account currencies, so clients outside those areas pay conversion at either.

Keep the difference between real and CFD positions clear at both. A real share purchase has no leverage and no overnight funding; a CFD on the same share does. See eToro account types and XTB account types.

Platforms

Winner: eToro, for copy trading and an API; xStation for analysis. Both run on their own platforms only, with no MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 or cTrader. Both apps are among the best rated in the market.

eToro adds CopyTrader and a trading API. XTB offers neither, and it does not support automated trading or VPS hosting. In return, xStation has built-in sentiment data, trading statistics and an economic calendar, which self-directed traders value. Copying another trader passes on their losses as well as their gains.

Funding

Split. XTB is faster but narrower. Bank withdrawals are processed Same or next business day, but cards, Skrill and Neteller can be used to deposit only, so every withdrawal goes to a bank account.

eToro withdraws to more methods, including PayPal, Skrill and Neteller in Up to 2 business days, and local methods such as iDEAL and Przelewy24. Its card and bank withdrawals are slow, at up to Up to 10 business days.

Markets

No winner on counts. XTB lists roughly 12,200 instruments, including 71 forex pairs, about 2,251 share CFDs, around 2,400 ETFs and 54 crypto CFDs. eToro does not publish counts, so the two cannot be ranked.

Both sell real stocks and ETFs. eToro also sells real crypto in most regions; XTB offers crypto as CFDs. For a long-term investor, both accounts can hold a simple portfolio of shares and ETFs, and the decision usually comes down to the platform you prefer and whether you want to copy others. For a short-term trader, the larger published CFD list at XTB is the more concrete advantage. UK retail clients cannot trade crypto CFDs at either under FCA rules.

Research and support

Split. Both publish news, daily analysis, an economic calendar and webinars, and both have structured courses. XTB's in-house analyst team is a strength. eToro's demo never expires, while XTB's demo accounts are time-limited, which gives eToro the edge for beginners who want to practice at their own pace.

XTB wins support, answering 24/5 by live chat, email and phone. eToro answers 24/5 by ticket; live chat for logged-in clients, with an automated assistant available 24/7, with no phone line for most clients.

Which should you choose?

  • Copy traders and beginners who want to follow others: eToro.
  • Self-directed European traders and investors: XTB, for xStation and its research.
  • Clients outside Europe: eToro, for negative balance protection offshore.
  • Australian residents: eToro, which has an ASIC entity.
  • Investors who trade rarely: eToro, which has no inactivity fee.
  • Traders who want MetaTrader or raw spreads: neither offers them. Pepperstone is a third option (see how it compares with eToro).

Leveraged CFDs can lose money quickly at either broker. Read the full eToro review and XTB review, or see all broker comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

Is eToro or XTB cheaper for forex?

eToro, by a small margin. Both are commission-free on forex CFDs, and eToro's typical EUR/USD spread is slightly tighter than XTB's group average.

Can I buy real stocks and ETFs at both?

Yes. Both hold real stocks and ETFs in the same account as CFDs, in most of the regions they serve. XTB is commission-free on stocks and ETFs up to a monthly turnover limit.

Which is safer, eToro or XTB?

In the UK and EU they are level, with FCA and EU entities and compensation schemes, and both are listed. eToro adds an ASIC entity and offers negative balance protection offshore, while XTB's offshore entity in Belize does not offer it.

Does XTB have copy trading?

No. eToro's CopyTrader is its main feature. XTB focuses on its xStation platform and in-house research.

Which platform is better?

It depends on your style. xStation is designed for active self-directed traders, with sentiment data and trading statistics. eToro's app is simpler and built around social trading.