Skip to content
Menu

Freetrade vs XTB

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Safety and regulation
  2. Costs
  3. Accounts
  4. Platforms and features
  5. Funding
  6. Markets
  7. Research and support
  8. Which costs less for your habits
  9. The CFD question
  10. Which should you choose?

Freetrade and XTB both offer UK investors zero-commission share dealing inside a Stocks and Shares ISA, with fractional shares and FCA regulation. XTB pays more interest on cash, has a lower FX fee than Freetrade's free plan, publishes a large share and ETF list, offers a Cash ISA, and answers by phone. Freetrade offers a SIPP and Junior ISA, investment funds and bonds, no inactivity fee and no CFD business. Pick XTB for a low-cost share ISA with interest on idle cash. Pick Freetrade if you want a pension, a children's account or funds. Both are solid, regulated choices for a UK share ISA.

Minimum deposit
GBP 0
GBP 0
Max leverage
—
1:500 (CFDs) (FSC Belize)
Regulators
FCA
FCA, KNF, CySEC, FSC Belize
Platforms
Freetrade mobile app, Freetrade web platform
XTB web platform, XTB mobile app
Funding methods
4
4
Trustpilot
4.2 / 5
3.8 / 5
Founded
2016
2004
Headquarters
London, United Kingdom
Warsaw, Poland

Safety and regulation

Tie for UK clients. Freetrade Limited holds FCA reference 783189 and XTB Limited holds 522157, both with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000. Both parents are listed. Freetrade is part of IG Group, a FTSE 100 listed company. XTB has been listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange since 2016.

XTB also runs entities regulated by the KNF and CySEC, and a Belize entity with CFD leverage up to 1:500 (CFDs) for some international clients. UK investors are not placed there. Freetrade offers no leveraged products at all.

Costs

Winner: XTB for most investors. XTB charges 0% commission up to EUR 100,000 monthly turnover; 0.2% (minimum GBP 10) above that. Freetrade charges GBP 0 dealing commission on all plans. For a typical investor both cost nothing to deal.

FX: XTB charges 0.5% on conversions. Freetrade charges 0.99% on the Basic plan, 0.59% on Standard and 0.39% on Plus, on non-GBP trades. XTB beats Freetrade's free plan; Freetrade's paid plans beat XTB but add a monthly cost.

Account fees at XTB: None up to EUR 250,000 held; above that 0.02% a year, minimum GBP 10. At Freetrade: No platform fee on the Basic plan. Standard costs GBP 5.99 a month (GBP 59.88 a year) and Plus GBP 11.99 a month (GBP 119.88 a year).

The fee that can catch out a long-term investor is XTB's inactivity fee: EUR 10 a month after 12 months without trading, if no deposit was made in the last 90 days. Freetrade charges none. Withdrawals at XTB: Free. At Freetrade: Free for standard withdrawals; GBP 5 for a same-day withdrawal.

Accounts

Winner: Freetrade for wrappers; XTB for interest. Freetrade offers Stocks and Shares ISA, Junior ISA, SIPP. XTB offers Stocks and Shares ISA, Cash ISA. Pension savers and parents need Freetrade.

Interest favors XTB, which pays on uninvested cash in three currencies. 4% AER (variable) on GBP, 2.3% on EUR and 3.45% on USD uninvested funds in a general investment account. Freetrade pays by plan, on capped balances. 1% AER on up to GBP 1,000 of uninvested cash on Basic, 2.5% on up to GBP 2,000 on Standard and 3.5% on up to GBP 3,000 on Plus. Both have no minimum deposit. XTB holds GBP, EUR, USD; Freetrade holds GBP only.

Platforms and features

Winner: XTB, narrowly. Both run a web platform and app, with fractional shares and recurring investing. XTB adds a demo account. Freetrade adds extended-hours trading. At XTB, short positions and leverage exist only through the separate CFD account. App ratings are 4.7 on the App Store for XTB and 4.4 for Freetrade; on Google Play, 4.6 against 4.4.

Funding

Winner: XTB. XTB takes cards, bank transfers, PayPal and Skrill, though Skrill deposits cost 2% for UK clients. It pays out by bank Same business day if requested before 1 pm, otherwise next business day, and to cards in Up to 3 business days. Freetrade takes bank transfers, debit cards, Apple Pay and Google Pay, and pays out by bank in About 2 business days.

Markets

Split. XTB publishes about 6,900 stocks and 2,300 ETFs from 14 markets, but no bonds or funds in its investing account. Freetrade offers shares, ETFs, funds and bonds, but publishes no counts. Fund and bond investors need Freetrade; share and ETF investors can compare lists on each app.

Research and support

Winner: XTB for access. XTB answers by live chat, email and phone, 24 hours a day, Monday to Friday. Freetrade supports clients by chat and email and publishes no hours. On Trustpilot, Freetrade scores 4.2 from 7,534 reviews and XTB 3.8 from 3,107, so users rate Freetrade higher despite XTB's longer hours.

Which costs less for your habits

Three habits decide the cheaper app. First, how much of your money goes into US shares: the more you convert, the more XTB's lower rate saves against Freetrade's free plan, while a paid Freetrade plan can turn that around if your portfolio is large enough to justify the monthly price. Second, how much cash you hold: XTB pays interest on all of your uninvested pounds, euros and dollars, while Freetrade pays only up to a capped balance. Third, how often you trade: if you might go a year without placing an order or adding money, XTB's inactivity fee can wipe out the interest you earned, while Freetrade charges nothing for an idle account. An investor who adds money every month will rarely meet XTB's inactivity rule.

The CFD question

XTB's investing account and CFD account share one app. The investing account buys real shares and ETFs that you own, inside an ISA if you choose; the CFD account trades price movements with leverage, which can magnify losses. Most retail CFD accounts lose money. Freetrade has no such product, which some investors prefer simply because it removes the temptation. If you open XTB for investing, make sure each order goes through the investing or ISA account.

Which should you choose?

  • ISA investors who hold cash between purchases: XTB, for higher interest.
  • Pension savers and parents: Freetrade, for its SIPP and Junior ISA.
  • US share buyers on a free plan: XTB, for its lower FX fee.
  • Investors who may leave the account idle for a year or more: Freetrade, which has no inactivity fee.
  • Investors who want phone support: XTB.

Read the full Freetrade review and XTB review, or see all broker comparisons. The value of investments can fall as well as rise.

Frequently asked questions

Is XTB or Freetrade cheaper?

Both charge no commission for normal retail volumes. XTB's FX fee is lower than Freetrade's free plan, and it pays more interest on cash, but it charges an inactivity fee after a long idle period. Freetrade's paid plans have lower FX fees than XTB but cost a monthly amount.

Does XTB offer a SIPP?

No. Freetrade offers a SIPP, Stocks and Shares ISA and Junior ISA. XTB offers a Stocks and Shares ISA and a Cash ISA.

Does Freetrade charge an inactivity fee?

No. XTB charges one after a long period with no trades and no recent deposit; Freetrade does not.

Which has phone support?

XTB, on weekdays around the clock, along with live chat and email. Freetrade supports clients by chat and email only.

Is XTB safe for UK investors?

UK clients sign with XTB Limited, which is FCA authorized with FSCS cover, and the parent is listed in Warsaw. XTB also offers leveraged CFDs, which are separate from its investing account and high risk.