Skip to content
Menu

FXIFY vs Topstep

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Challenge models and prices
  2. Profit targets and drawdown
  3. Trading rules
  4. Payouts and profit split
  5. Platforms
  6. Scaling
  7. Inactivity and support
  8. Reputation
  9. Which should you choose?

FXIFY and Topstep serve different traders. FXIFY is a London CFD firm backed by a broker, with one of the widest menus of evaluations: one, two and three phases, a fast Lightning test and instant accounts. Topstep is a Chicago futures-only firm with one product, the Trading Combine, billed monthly and traded on its own platform. Pick FXIFY if you trade forex, indices, stocks or crypto CFDs, want a refundable fee and want to hold positions. Pick Topstep if you day-trade US futures and want a long payout record. The comparable parts are set out below.

Max profit split
100% (Two Phase Classic 30-day cycle); 90% elsewhere
90%
Platforms
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, DXtrade, TradingView
Proprietary platform
Trustpilot
4.3 / 5
3.7 / 5
Founded
2023
2012
Headquarters
London, United Kingdom
Chicago, Illinois, United States

Challenge models and prices

No direct winner: different markets; FXIFY on refunds. FXIFY charges once per attempt. At 50,000, Two Phase Standard costs 379 USD and Three Phase 249, both refunded with the first payout on request.

Topstep bills monthly. The 50,000 Combine costs 49 USD a month plus an activation fee on passing, or 95 a month without one. Nothing is refunded. A quick pass at Topstep can cost less than an FXIFY challenge; a slow one costs more.

FXIFY's Lightning challenge is the closest to Topstep's fast single-target format, at 249 for 50,000. FXIFY also sells instant accounts, which Topstep does not. See FXIFY challenges and the Topstep Trading Combine.

Profit targets and drawdown

Winner: FXIFY, for choice. Topstep's 50,000 Combine asks for $3,000 in one step, with $2,000, set at the end of each day from the account balance high, and no daily limit by default.

FXIFY Lightning asks for 5% with 4% trailing, locking at the starting balance and a time limit of 5 trading days. For more room and no deadline, FXIFY's Three Phase uses 5% of the starting balance, static, and Two Phase Classic 10% of the starting balance, static. Topstep offers only its trailing model.

Trading rules

Winner: FXIFY. Topstep closes every position each day. Not allowed. Positions must be flat by 3:10 PM CT each weekday; trading resumes at 5:00 PM CT. Positions cannot be carried from one session to the next. FXIFY allows holding in the evaluation. Allowed on evaluation programs. Instant Funding accounts must close all positions by Friday 3:45 PM EST.

News: Topstep only bans trading full size into major releases. FXIFY allows news on its phase challenges and blocks it on instant accounts.

Automation: FXIFY allows EAs with prior approval, and martingale and grid. Topstep bans unfair technology and orders from a VPS: VPNs, proxies, TOR and other location or identity masking services are prohibited. Orders must originate from the trader's personal device; a VPS or remote server may not place or relay orders.

Consistency: Topstep: Trading Combine: best day at most 55% of the profit target, otherwise the target increases. Express Funded Account Consistency path: best day within 40% of total profit. FXIFY: None on One Phase, Two Phase Standard and Pro, Three Phase and Instant Funding. Two Phase Classic: 25% on the funded account. Lightning: 30% in the assessment and funded stage. Instant Funding Lite: 20% for every payout. The best day does not reset after a withdrawal. See FXIFY rules and Topstep rules.

Payouts and profit split

Winner: Topstep on frequency; FXIFY on top split. FXIFY's split can reach 100% (Two Phase Classic 30-day cycle); 90% elsewhere; Topstep pays 90%. FXIFY pays Every 30 days (14 with the Bi-weekly Payouts add-on) on One, Two Standard and Three Phase; 14 or 30 days on Two Phase Classic; 10 days on Two Phase Pro and Instant Funding Lite; bi-weekly on Instant Funding and Lightning. Topstep's first payout rule: Express Funded Account: after 5 winning days of USD 150 or more (Standard path) or 3 trading days meeting the 40% consistency objective (Consistency path). Its schedule is Per payout path; daily access to up to 100% of profits after 30 winning days in a Live Funded Account.

Topstep pays US traders instantly through Aeropay after approval; others use Wise or wire. FXIFY pays through Rise (bank transfer or crypto), USDC or USDT for traders in Ukraine. Topstep states it has paid more than USD 1.5 billion, FXIFY more than USD 40 million. See FXIFY payouts and Topstep payouts.

Platforms

Winner: FXIFY, for choice. FXIFY supports MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, DXtrade, TradingView. Topstep trades only on TopstepX, its Proprietary platform platform, where an outage halts all trading. Commission is USD 6 per lot on the Raw feed; none on the All-In feed at FXIFY and USD 1.00 round turn commission plus exchange and NFA fees (ES total USD 3.78) on futures minis at Topstep.

Scaling

Winner: FXIFY. FXIFY grows the account on a schedule. One, Two and Three Phase only: a 10% total return over 3 months with at least 2 profitable months raises the account by 25%; each later qualifying 3-month period doubles it, up to four scale-ups and at most 10 times the initial size (USD 400,000 can reach USD 4,000,000). Not available on Instant Funding, Lightning or Two Phase Pro. Topstep scales position size instead. The Scaling Plan applies to the Express Funded Account and sets the maximum position size from the current account balance. It does not apply to the Live Funded Account, which uses Dynamic Live Risk Expansion. Topstep's growth leads to a live account rather than a larger simulated one.

Inactivity and support

Winner: FXIFY on inactivity; Topstep on stated hours. FXIFY allows two months without trading. 60 days without trading is a breach. Topstep may close an idle funded account after one. An Express Funded Account with more than 30 days of inactivity may be closed. Topstep's support runs 24/7. FXIFY offers live chat, email, tickets and Discord, with hours not published.

Reputation

Winner: FXIFY. FXIFY is rated 4.3 from 6,643 reviews. Topstep is rated 3.7 from 15,083 reviews, low for its size, with complaints about outages. Both are visible. Topstep launched its evaluation in 2012, FXIFY was founded in 2023, and FXIFY is backed by the broker FXPIG.

Which should you choose?

  • Forex, stock and crypto CFD traders: FXIFY. Topstep has no CFDs.
  • US futures day traders: Topstep. FXIFY has no futures.
  • Traders who want their fee back after passing: FXIFY.
  • Swing traders: FXIFY, on a phase challenge.
  • EA and VPS users: FXIFY.
  • Traders who want frequent payouts without add-ons: Topstep.

Read the full FXIFY review and Topstep review, or see all prop firm comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

Which should I choose, FXIFY or Topstep?

Choose by market. FXIFY offers forex, CFDs, stocks and crypto CFDs but no futures. Topstep offers futures only.

Does either firm refund the fee?

FXIFY refunds the fee with the first payout on several of its challenges. Topstep's monthly subscription is not refunded.

Can I hold trades over the weekend?

At FXIFY, on its evaluation programs, yes. At Topstep, no; positions must be flat every afternoon.

Which pays out more often?

Topstep, once the payout conditions are met. FXIFY's main phase challenges pay every 30 days unless you buy a bi-weekly add-on.

Which has the better Trustpilot score?

FXIFY's score is higher. Topstep has more reviews. Both are visible.