IC Markets vs XTB
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
IC Markets and XTB are both large, long-running brokers with no minimum deposit, but they serve different traders. IC Markets is a raw-spread specialist for scalpers and algorithmic traders on MetaTrader, cTrader and TradingView. XTB is a listed European broker whose xStation platform holds CFDs, real stocks and ETFs in one account. Pick IC Markets for the lowest forex cost and automation. Pick XTB if you live in Europe and want to trade and invest in one place.
- Minimum deposit
- USD 0
- USD 0
- Max leverage
- 1:5000 (FSA)
- 1:500 (CMF)
- EUR/USD average spread
- 0.01 pips (Raw Spread (MetaTrader))
- 1.06 pips (Standard)
- Regulators
- FSA, CySEC, ASIC, SCB, CMA
- KNF, FCA, CySEC, DFSA, UAE CMA, CMF, BAPPEBTI, FSC Belize
- Platforms
- MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader, TradingView
- Proprietary platform
- Funding methods
- 16
- 5
- Trustpilot
- 4.8 / 5
- 3.8 / 5
- Founded
- 2007
- 2004
- Headquarters
- Sydney, Australia
- Warsaw, Poland
Safety and regulation
Split: XTB in the UK and EU, IC Markets in Australia. XTB serves UK clients under FCA license FRN 522157, with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000, and most EU clients from Poland with the KDPW investor compensation scheme up to EUR 20,100. It is listed in Warsaw and publishes audited results. IC Markets has no UK entity and is privately held.
Both have CySEC companies covered by the Investor Compensation Fund up to EUR 20,000. IC Markets adds an ASIC entity, license 335692, and Kenya; XTB adds Dubai, onshore UAE, Chile and Indonesia.
Offshore, neither is reassuring. XTB International in Belize allows leverage up to 1:500 and offers no negative balance protection. IC Markets' Seychelles company allows up to 1:5000, makes clients responsible for negative balances, and relies on a private insurance policy. Either way, an account there can end below zero after a sharp gap.
Costs
Winner: IC Markets for active forex traders. XTB prices forex through the spread only, so its natural rival is IC Markets' Standard account, but IC Markets publishes only a "from" spread of 0.8 pips there, so those two cannot be ranked. IC Markets' raw accounts, though, are cheaper than XTB's published cost. One standard lot of EUR/USD, opened and closed:
- IC Markets Raw Spread (cTrader): 6.1 USD
- IC Markets Raw Spread (MetaTrader): 7.1 USD
- XTB Standard: 10.6 USD
XTB's figure is a group average of 1.06 pips for retail trades; IC Markets' is its own published raw average of 0.01 pips plus commission. The gap matters most to frequent traders; someone placing a few trades a month will save more at XTB through commission-free stock and ETF investing than they lose on forex.
Winner on non-trading fees: IC Markets. It charges no deposit, withdrawal or inactivity fee for global clients. XTB charges EUR 10 per month if no buy or sell transaction has been made within 365 days, Free above USD 50; USD 30 below USD 50 on withdrawals, percentage charges on Skrill and Neteller deposits, and a conversion fee of 0.5%, with only a few base currencies.
More detail: IC Markets fees and XTB fees
Accounts
Tie. Both list no minimum deposit: 0 USD at IC Markets and 0 USD at XTB. IC Markets offers a choice of pricing model and Raw Pro accounts for large balances. XTB's single account holds CFDs, real stocks and ETFs together.
Both allow micro lots and professional status. IC Markets offers swap-free accounts with a flat holding fee; XTB offers swap-free status only in some countries and for limited periods. See IC Markets account types and XTB account types.
Platforms
Winner: IC Markets. It offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader and TradingView, with scalping, Expert Advisors, VPS hosting, API access and copy trading through cTrader Copy, ZuluTrade, IC Social, Signal Start.
XTB runs only on xStation, one of the best-rated trading apps, with sentiment data, trading statistics and investing built in. It has no MetaTrader, no copy trading, no VPS, no API and no automated trading. Manual traders who also invest may prefer it; algorithmic traders cannot use it.
The platform choice often decides this pair on its own. A trader who runs Expert Advisors, cBots or TradingView alerts needs IC Markets, because XTB has no way to run them. A trader who places orders by hand, wants sentiment data and trading statistics on screen, and also buys shares and ETFs, may find xStation the more complete tool. At XTB, check which order ticket you are using: a real share purchase and a CFD on the same share look similar but carry very different risks. Both brokers allow scalping and hedging.
Funding
Winner: IC Markets. It charges nothing of its own and has a long list of methods, with e-wallet withdrawals Instant once processed and crypto in Up to 2 hours after processing.
XTB processes bank withdrawals Same or next business day, which is quick, but cards, Skrill and Neteller can be used for deposits only, so every withdrawal goes to a bank account, and small ones carry a fee. European clients with a local bank account will find this simple; clients who prefer e-wallets or crypto will find IC Markets more flexible.
Markets
Winner: XTB. It lists roughly 12,200 instruments, including 71 forex pairs, about 2,251 share CFDs, around 2,400 ETFs and real stocks. IC Markets lists around 2,250, with 61 forex pairs and about 2,100 share CFDs, all as CFDs.
IC Markets has more crypto CFDs, 94 against 54, and publishes an index count of 25, which XTB does not.
Research and support
Winner: XTB for research and education; IC Markets for support hours. Both publish news, daily analysis, an economic calendar and webinars. XTB adds an in-house analyst team and structured courses. IC Markets adds Trading Central but has no courses.
IC Markets answers 24/7. XTB answers 24/5. Both offer live chat, email and phone.
Which should you choose?
- Scalpers and algorithmic traders: IC Markets.
- European traders who also invest: XTB, for real stocks and ETFs in one account.
- UK residents: XTB, which has an FCA entity.
- Australian residents: IC Markets, which has an ASIC entity.
- Beginners: XTB, for its courses and platform.
- UK traders who want raw pricing on MetaTrader: neither offers both. Pepperstone is a third option (see how it compares with IC Markets).
Leveraged CFDs can lose more than you expect offshore. Read the full IC Markets review and XTB review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Is IC Markets cheaper than XTB for forex?
For active traders, yes. IC Markets' Raw Spread account costs less per lot than XTB's commission-free pricing. IC Markets publishes no average for its own Standard account, so the two commission-free offers cannot be ranked directly.
Which is safer, IC Markets or XTB?
In the UK and EU, XTB, which has an FCA entity, a Polish license with investor compensation and a stock-exchange listing. In Australia, IC Markets, which has an ASIC entity. Offshore, neither offers clear negative balance protection.
Can I use MetaTrader or cTrader at XTB?
No. XTB runs only on xStation and does not support automated trading. IC Markets offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader and TradingView.
Can I buy real stocks at IC Markets?
No. IC Markets is CFD-only. XTB holds real stocks and ETFs in the same account as CFDs.
Which is better for beginners?
XTB, for its structured courses, in-house research and well-designed platform. IC Markets suits traders who already know MetaTrader or cTrader.