IG vs OANDA
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
IG and OANDA are two of the oldest names in online trading, both regulated in many financial centers, both offering TradingView, MetaTrader, spread betting for UK clients and guaranteed stops. The difference is breadth. IG is a multi-asset broker with one of the widest market lists available, ProRealTime, direct market access and real shares. OANDA is a forex specialist with a strong US presence, an API and a well-regarded own platform. Pick IG for markets and tools. Pick OANDA for forex in the US or Canada.
- Minimum deposit
- USD 0
- USD 0
- Max leverage
- 1:200 (BMA)
- 1:50 (CFTC/NFA)
- EUR/USD average spread
- 1.13 pips (CFD account)
- 1.69 pips (Standard)
- Regulators
- BMA, FCA, ASIC, BaFin, FINMA, DFSA, MAS, JFSA, CFTC/NFA
- BVI FSC, CFTC/NFA, FCA, KNF, ASIC, CIRO, MAS, JFSA
- Platforms
- Proprietary platform, MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, ProRealTime, L2 Dealer
- MetaTrader 5, TradingView, Proprietary platform
- Funding methods
- 6
- 6
- Trustpilot
- 3.7 / 5
- 3.5 / 5
- Founded
- 1974
- 1996
- Headquarters
- London, United Kingdom
- New York, United States
Safety and regulation
Winner: IG, narrowly. Both are regulated by the FCA, IG through IG Markets Ltd, license 195355, and OANDA through OANDA Europe Limited, license 542574. Both hold ASIC, MAS and Japanese licenses. IG publishes FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000 for its UK clients; OANDA does not publish compensation amounts for its UK, EU or Australian companies.
The footprints differ at the edges. IG serves the EU from Germany under BaFin, and adds Switzerland and the DIFC. OANDA serves the EU from Poland under the KNF, adds Canada with the Canadian Investor Protection Fund, and runs a full US forex business, registration NFA 0325821. IG's US offer is the separate tastyfx brand. IG's parent is listed and publishes audited results; OANDA is privately owned, recently by FTMO.
For rest-of-world clients, IG uses Bermuda, with leverage up to 1:200 and no license number printed. OANDA uses the BVI, license SIBA/L/20/1130, and publishes no leverage or protection terms there. Neither mentions negative balance protection for its offshore entity, and neither has a compensation scheme there.
Costs
No winner on trading costs. Both price standard forex through the spread with no commission, so this would be a like-for-like test, but neither publishes much spread detail. IG's only published average EUR/USD spread is 1.13 pips, an all-in cost of 11.3 USD per standard lot round trip, but it is several years old. OANDA publishes only a minimum of 0.6 pips for international clients. We do not rank them.
Both offer something for high-volume traders: IG through Forex Direct on L2 Dealer for professional clients, and OANDA through its Premium Plus core-pricing account, whose commission it does not state. Neither publishes a raw-spread average for retail clients.
Non-trading fees suit different habits:
- Inactivity: IG charges USD 18 per month after 24 months without dealing activity at the Bermuda entity (GBP 12 per month at the UK entity). OANDA charges Up to USD 20 per month after 12 months without trading activity; not charged while a position is open, so it starts sooner.
- Conversion: IG charges 1.0% on CFD trades in a currency other than the account base currency. OANDA charges 0.5% when money is converted between currencies.
- Withdrawals: IG charges nothing. OANDA's card withdrawals are free, but it charges USD 20 per bank wire.
More detail: IG fees and OANDA fees
Accounts
Winner: IG, narrowly. Both list no minimum deposit, 0 USD at IG and 0 USD at OANDA. Both offer spread betting to UK clients, guaranteed stops and professional accounts. Neither offers Islamic accounts.
IG adds share dealing and investment accounts in the UK and some other regions. OANDA adds a Premium tier with tighter spreads and rebates from 10,000 USD. See IG account types and OANDA account types.
Platforms
Winner: IG. Both offer their own well-regarded web and mobile platforms, TradingView, MetaTrader 5, API access and VPS hosting. IG adds MetaTrader 4, ProRealTime and L2 Dealer for direct market access.
OANDA offers copy trading through MetaTrader 5 signals; IG offers none. Both allow scalping, hedging and Expert Advisors. US clients of OANDA should note that US rules restrict hedging within one account.
Funding
Split. OANDA is quicker on cards, at About 1 business day against 2-5 working days at IG, and lists Skrill and Neteller withdrawals Within 1 business day. IG is cheaper on bank transfers, which are free and take 1-3 working days, against OANDA's fee and 2-5 business days.
IG accepts PayPal and FPS in Hong Kong, but charges for credit card deposits. Both accept Wise. Methods differ by entity at both, so check your region's funding page. Withdrawals generally return to the method you deposited with.
Markets
Winner: IG, by a wide margin. IG lists roughly 17,000 markets, including 90 forex pairs, 80 indices, 40 commodities and around 13,000 shares, plus real shares in some regions. OANDA lists 48 forex pairs, 18 indices and 10 commodities, around 1,500 instruments in all.
OANDA publishes 18 crypto CFDs; IG does not publish a single count. For a pure forex trader, both lists cover the majors and crosses; for anyone who also trades shares, indices or ETFs, IG is in a different league. US clients of either can trade forex only.
Research and support
Winner: IG. Both publish news, daily analysis, an economic calendar and webinars, both include Autochartist, and both offer demos that do not expire. IG adds its own news desk and IG Academy courses; OANDA has no structured courses, so beginners will learn more at IG.
IG answers 24 hours a day, except from 6am to 4pm on Saturday (UTC+8). OANDA answers 24/5, Sunday evening to Friday evening. Both offer live chat, phone, email and WhatsApp, in several languages.
Which should you choose?
- US forex traders: OANDA, which serves US residents directly under its own name.
- Canadian traders: OANDA, which has a CIRO-regulated company.
- Multi-asset traders and investors: IG, for its market range and real shares.
- ProRealTime and MetaTrader 4 users: IG.
- Beginners: IG, for IG Academy.
- Cost-focused forex traders: neither publishes a current raw-spread average. Pepperstone is a third option with an FCA entity and published raw-account averages (see how it compares with IG).
Leveraged CFDs and spread bets can lose money quickly at either broker. Read the full IG review and OANDA review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Is IG cheaper than OANDA?
There is no clear answer. IG's only published average spread is several years old, and OANDA publishes only minimum spreads, so there is no like-for-like current figure for either. Their non-trading fees differ in ways that suit different habits.
Which is safer, IG or OANDA?
Both are long-established and regulated in the UK, Australia, Singapore and Japan. IG adds BaFin, FINMA and the DFSA and is listed in London. OANDA adds Canada and a full US forex business. IG has the slight edge on transparency.
Which is better for US traders?
OANDA, for most. It serves US residents directly for forex. IG serves the US only through its separate tastyfx brand, also forex only.
Do both offer spread betting?
Yes, for UK clients. Both also offer guaranteed stops. Neither offers Islamic accounts.
Which has more markets?
IG, by a wide margin, including real shares in some regions. OANDA's list is focused on forex.