IG vs XM
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
IG and XM both appeal to newer traders, but from opposite directions. IG is a London-listed broker with top-tier regulation, one of the widest market lists available, spread betting, guaranteed stops and advanced platforms. XM is a Cyprus-based MetaTrader broker for emerging markets, with a token deposit, local payment methods, support in many languages and high leverage offshore. Pick IG for safety, range and tools. Pick XM for local access, Islamic accounts and raw pricing.
- Minimum deposit
- USD 0
- USD 5
- Max leverage
- 1:200 (BMA)
- 1:1000 (FSC Belize)
- EUR/USD average spread
- 1.13 pips (CFD account)
- 1.6 pips (Standard)
- Regulators
- BMA, FCA, ASIC, BaFin, FINMA, DFSA, MAS, JFSA, CFTC/NFA
- CySEC, FSC Belize, FSC, FSA, BVI FSC, FSCA, DFSA, UAE CMA, CMA
- Platforms
- Proprietary platform, MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, ProRealTime, L2 Dealer
- MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform
- Funding methods
- 6
- 9
- Trustpilot
- 3.7 / 5
- Not shown
- Founded
- 1974
- 2009
- Headquarters
- London, United Kingdom
- Limassol, Cyprus
Safety and regulation
Winner: IG. UK clients sign with IG Markets Ltd under FCA license 195355, with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000. EU clients sign with IG Europe under BaFin, and IG also holds ASIC, FINMA, MAS, Japanese and DFSA licenses. Its parent is listed and publishes audited results.
XM serves EU clients from Cyprus under CySEC license 120/10, with investor compensation up to EUR 20,000, and has a DFSA company in Dubai, as IG does. It adds local licenses in South Africa and Kenya. It has no UK or Australian entity and is privately owned.
Offshore, XM is clearer on one point. XM Global in Belize offers negative balance protection, though with leverage up to 1:1000. IG's Bermuda company caps leverage at 1:200 but does not state negative balance protection. Neither has a compensation scheme offshore. Trustpilot currently withholds XM's rating, citing a guidelines breach; IG is rated 3.7.
Costs
No winner on spreads. On spread-only accounts, the like-for-like test, neither gives a usable current figure. IG's only published average EUR/USD spread is 1.13 pips, an all-in cost of 11.3 USD per standard lot round trip, and it is several years old. XM publishes only minimums, such as 0.8 pips on Ultra Low.
XM also offers a raw-pricing Zero account with commission of 7 USD per lot round trip, but without a published average spread. IG's retail forex is spread-only. To compare real costs, use both demos and watch the pairs you trade at the times you trade them.
Non-trading fees suit different habits. XM covers payment fees except small bank wires, but charges USD 10 per month after 90 days without trading, deposits or withdrawals. IG's withdrawals are free and its inactivity fee starts much later, USD 18 per month after 24 months without dealing activity at the Bermuda entity (GBP 12 per month at the UK entity), but it charges a conversion fee of 1.0% on CFD trades in a currency other than the account base currency and a percentage on credit card deposits. Occasional traders will pay less at IG; active traders who fund by card or e-wallet may pay less at XM.
More detail: IG fees and XM fees
Accounts
Split. Both are cheap to open: IG lists 0 USD, and XM's main accounts need 5 USD. IG adds spread betting for UK and Irish clients, guaranteed stops and share dealing in some regions.
XM adds a choice of pricing model, Islamic accounts, which IG does not offer, micro lots on its commission-free accounts, and a Shares account in selected regions. Note that XM's EU and international companies sell different accounts. See IG account types and XM account types.
Platforms
Winner: IG. Both offer MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 and a well-rated own app. IG adds TradingView, ProRealTime, L2 Dealer and APIs, and allows scalping.
XM has no API and does not state its scalping policy. It offers copy trading without naming providers; IG offers no copy trading. XM Global offers a free VPS to clients who meet balance and volume conditions.
Funding
Winner: XM. XM covers payment fees on most methods and offers local options such as M-Pesa. Skrill and Neteller withdrawals take Instant, and crypto withdrawals Instant to 24 hours. Card withdrawals take 2-5 business days.
IG's list is shorter: cards, bank transfer, PayPal, Wise and FPS in Hong Kong. Card withdrawals take 2-5 working days, and IG does not publish a PayPal withdrawal time. IG is the better fit where bank transfers and debit cards are the norm.
Which matters more depends on where you live. In much of Africa and Asia, local wallets and mobile money are how people move money, and XM's support for them is a practical advantage that no amount of regulation offsets. In the UK, EU or Australia, debit cards and bank transfers cover almost everyone, and IG's free withdrawals and regulated entities make it the simpler choice. At both brokers, withdrawals generally return to the method you deposited with.
Markets
Winner: IG, by a wide margin. IG lists roughly 17,000 markets, including 80 indices, 40 commodities and around 13,000 shares, plus real shares in some regions. XM lists around 1,400, with 21 indices, 20 commodities and about 1,200 share CFDs.
IG publishes 90 forex pairs; XM does not publish a count. Both offer real shares in some regions.
Research and support
Tie on research; XM on support. Both publish news, daily analysis, an economic calendar and webinars, and both offer structured courses. IG adds its own news desk, Autochartist and a demo that does not expire; XM adds Trading Central.
XM answers 24/7, by live chat, email and phone, in one of the longest language lists in the market. IG answers 24 hours a day, except from 6am to 4pm on Saturday (UTC+8), adding WhatsApp.
Which should you choose?
- UK, EU and Australian residents who want top-tier protection: IG.
- Multi-asset traders and investors: IG.
- Traders in Africa and Asia who rely on local payments and languages: XM.
- Traders who need Islamic accounts: XM.
- Traders who leave accounts idle: IG, whose inactivity fee starts much later.
- Traders who want raw pricing with published averages: neither offers it. Pepperstone is a third option (see how it compares with IG).
High offshore leverage magnifies losses as fast as gains. Read the full IG review and XM review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Is IG cheaper than XM?
They cannot be ranked on spreads. IG's only published average is several years old, and XM publishes only minimum spreads. XM offers a raw-pricing account, which IG does not offer to retail clients.
Which is safer, IG or XM?
IG. It is listed in London and regulated by the FCA, BaFin, ASIC and others. XM is regulated by CySEC in the EU, but most of its other clients sign with offshore companies.
Which needs a smaller deposit?
Both are low. IG has no minimum to open, and XM's main accounts open with a token amount.
Does XM offer spread betting or guaranteed stops?
No. IG offers both to eligible clients. XM offers Islamic accounts and a raw-pricing Zero account instead.
Which is better for traders in Africa and Asia?
XM, for most. It offers local payment methods such as M-Pesa, support in many languages and local licenses in South Africa and Kenya.