IG vs XTB
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
IG and XTB are two listed European brokers that let you trade CFDs and buy real shares from the same provider, both commission-free on forex and both regulated by the FCA. The difference is scope. IG has a wider market list, spread betting, guaranteed stops and a choice of platforms including MetaTrader and ProRealTime. XTB keeps everything in one account on its own xStation platform, with no minimum deposit and commission-free stock and ETF investing up to a monthly limit. Pick IG for range and tools. Pick XTB for simplicity and investing.
- Minimum deposit
- USD 0
- USD 0
- Max leverage
- 1:200 (BMA)
- 1:500 (CMF)
- EUR/USD average spread
- 1.13 pips (CFD account)
- 1.06 pips (Standard)
- Regulators
- BMA, FCA, ASIC, BaFin, FINMA, DFSA, MAS, JFSA, CFTC/NFA
- KNF, FCA, CySEC, DFSA, UAE CMA, CMF, BAPPEBTI, FSC Belize
- Platforms
- Proprietary platform, MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, ProRealTime, L2 Dealer
- Proprietary platform
- Funding methods
- 6
- 5
- Trustpilot
- 3.7 / 5
- 3.8 / 5
- Founded
- 1974
- 2004
- Headquarters
- London, United Kingdom
- Warsaw, Poland
Safety and regulation
Winner: IG, narrowly. In the UK the two are level: IG Markets Ltd holds FCA license 195355 and XTB Limited FRN 522157, both with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000. Both are listed, IG in London and XTB in Warsaw, and both publish audited results.
In the EU, IG serves clients from Germany under BaFin, and XTB from Poland under the KNF, with the KDPW investor compensation scheme up to EUR 20,100. IG adds ASIC, FINMA, the MAS and the Japanese FSA; XTB adds Cyprus, onshore UAE, Chile and Indonesia. Both have DFSA companies in Dubai.
Offshore, IG's terms are less extreme. Its Bermuda company caps leverage at 1:200, though it prints no license number and does not state negative balance protection. XTB's Belize company allows up to 1:500 and offers no negative balance protection. Neither has a compensation scheme offshore.
Costs
Winner: XTB, narrowly on forex. Both are spread-only, so this is like for like. One standard lot of EUR/USD, opened and closed:
- XTB: 10.6 USD, from a group average of 1.06 pips
- IG: 11.3 USD, from an average of 1.13 pips
IG's average is several years old and the only one it publishes, so the gap today may differ. For index and share CFDs, IG's pricing is competitive and its list is longer. For real stocks and ETFs, XTB is commission-free up to a monthly turnover limit; there is no like-for-like figure for IG's share dealing, so they cannot be ranked on investing costs.
Non-trading fees are mixed:
- Inactivity: IG charges USD 18 per month after 24 months without dealing activity at the Bermuda entity (GBP 12 per month at the UK entity). XTB charges EUR 10 per month if no buy or sell transaction has been made within 365 days, which starts sooner but is avoided by one trade a year.
- Conversion: XTB charges 0.5%, half of IG's 1.0% on CFD trades in a currency other than the account base currency.
- Funding: IG's withdrawals are free but credit card deposits are not. XTB charges Free above USD 50; USD 30 below USD 50 and a percentage on Skrill and Neteller deposits.
More detail: IG fees and XTB fees
Accounts
Winner: IG, narrowly. Both list no minimum deposit: 0 USD at IG and 0 USD at XTB. IG adds spread betting for UK and Irish clients and guaranteed stops, neither of which XTB offers.
XTB's single account is simpler: CFDs, real stocks and ETFs under one login and balance. It also offers swap-free status in some countries, which IG does not. Both offer professional status. See IG account types and XTB account types.
Platforms
Winner: IG. IG offers its own web platform and app, MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, ProRealTime, L2 Dealer and APIs, with automated trading and VPS hosting.
XTB runs only on xStation. It is one of the best-rated trading apps, with sentiment data, trading statistics and investing built in, and its app scores 4.7 on the App Store. But it has no MetaTrader, no API, no VPS and no automated trading. Neither broker offers copy trading.
The platform question often decides this pair. A trader who runs Expert Advisors, uses TradingView alerts or wants ProRealTime's charting needs IG. A trader who places orders by hand, wants sentiment data on screen and also buys shares and ETFs may find xStation the more complete single tool. At XTB, check which order ticket you are using: a real share purchase and a CFD on the same share look similar but carry very different risks.
Funding
Winner: IG, narrowly. IG withdraws to cards, taking 2-5 working days, and to bank accounts in 1-3 working days, free of IG charges. It also accepts PayPal and Wise.
XTB is faster to a bank, processing withdrawals Same or next business day, but cards, Skrill and Neteller work for deposits only, and small withdrawals carry a fee.
Markets
Winner: IG. It lists roughly 17,000 markets, including 90 forex pairs, 40 commodities, around 13,000 shares and 5,400 ETFs. XTB lists roughly 12,200, with 71 forex pairs, 32 commodities, about 2,251 share CFDs and around 2,400 ETFs.
Both offer real shares. XTB publishes 54 crypto CFDs; IG does not publish a single count. UK retail clients cannot trade crypto CFDs at either under FCA rules.
Research and support
Winner: IG. Both publish news, daily analysis, an economic calendar and webinars, both have in-house analysts, and both offer structured courses. IG adds Autochartist and a demo that never expires; XTB's demo accounts are time-limited.
IG answers 24 hours a day, except from 6am to 4pm on Saturday (UTC+8). XTB answers 24/5. Both offer live chat, phone and email, and IG adds WhatsApp.
Which should you choose?
- UK traders who want spread betting or guaranteed stops: IG.
- Technical traders who need MetaTrader, TradingView or ProRealTime: IG.
- European investors who want stocks, ETFs and CFDs in one simple account: XTB.
- Cost-focused traders on commission-free forex: XTB, narrowly.
- Australian residents: IG, which has an ASIC entity.
- Forex traders who want raw pricing: neither offers it to retail clients. Pepperstone is a third option with an FCA entity and raw-spread accounts (see how it compares with IG).
Leveraged CFDs can lose money quickly at either broker. Read the full IG review and XTB review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Is XTB cheaper than IG for forex?
Slightly. Both are commission-free on forex, and XTB's current group average EUR/USD spread is a little tighter than IG's published average, which is several years old.
Which is safer, IG or XTB?
Both are listed and regulated by the FCA and EU regulators, with compensation schemes. IG has more top-tier regulators, including ASIC. Offshore, XTB's Belize entity offers no negative balance protection.
Can I buy real shares at both?
Yes. XTB holds real stocks and ETFs in the same account as CFDs. IG offers share dealing and investment accounts in the UK and some other regions.
Does XTB offer MetaTrader or spread betting?
No to both. XTB runs only on xStation. IG offers its own platform, MetaTrader, TradingView and ProRealTime, plus spread betting for UK clients.
Which is better for beginners?
Both are good. IG Academy and a never-expiring demo give IG the edge for learning, while XTB's xStation is one of the easiest platforms to use.