Interactive Brokers vs tastytrade
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
Interactive Brokers and tastytrade both serve experienced traders who use options and futures, but they are built differently. tastytrade is a US broker designed around options: commission-free stocks and ETFs, an opening fee per options contract that is capped per leg, and nothing to close. Interactive Brokers is a global broker with access to markets in dozens of countries, low per-contract options fees on both sides of the trade, a very low currency conversion fee and an API. Pick tastytrade if you mainly trade US options in size and want a platform built for that. Pick Interactive Brokers if you want global markets, more account types or the lowest fees on small trades.
- Minimum deposit
- USD 0
- USD 0
- Max leverage
- 1:30 (CFDs) (FCA)
- —
- Regulators
- FCA, SEC/FINRA, CBI, CIRO, ASIC, MAS, DFSA
- SEC/FINRA, CFTC/NFA
- Platforms
- IBKR Desktop, Trader Workstation (TWS), IBKR Mobile, IBKR GlobalTrader, Client Portal, IMPACT, IBKR APIs
- tastytrade desktop, tastytrade web, tastytrade mobile (iOS, Android, iPad)
- Funding methods
- 2
- 1
- Trustpilot
- 3 / 5
- 2.9 / 5
- Founded
- 1977
- 2011
- Headquarters
- Greenwich, Connecticut, United States
- Chicago, Illinois, United States
Safety and regulation
Tie. Interactive Brokers LLC is registered with the SEC and FINRA as CRD 36418, with SIPC cover up to USD 500,000. Interactive Brokers is listed on Nasdaq (IBKR), and founder and chairman Thomas Peterffy controls it through IBG Holdings LLC, which holds about 73.5% of the operating group. It also has regulated companies in the UK, Ireland, Canada, Australia and Singapore.
tastytrade, Inc. is registered as CRD 277027, with SIPC cover up to USD 500,000 including USD 250,000 cash. tastytrade has been owned by IG Group Holdings plc (LSE: IGG) since 2021. Its futures business is registered separately with the CFTC and NFA.
Both parents are listed and publish audited results. Futures and options can lose more than the margin you post, so position sizing matters more than the broker's safety rating.
Costs
Split: tastytrade for large options trades; Interactive Brokers for small ones and for foreign shares. Options pricing at Interactive Brokers: US options: USD 0.65 per contract for premiums of USD 0.10 or more (USD 0.25 to 0.50 for lower premiums), minimum USD 1.00 per order. At tastytrade: Stock and ETF options USD 1 per contract to open (capped at USD 10 per leg), USD 0 to close; index options USD 1 to open. Futures USD 1 per contract (micros USD 0.75); futures options USD 1.25.
The structures reward different habits. tastytrade's cap per leg and free closing make large trades cheap: once a leg reaches the cap, extra contracts add nothing to the opening fee. Interactive Brokers' lower per-contract fee is usually cheaper for traders who open and close a few contracts at a time.
On US shares, Interactive Brokers has two plans. Fixed: USD 0.005 per share, minimum USD 1.00, maximum 1% of trade value. Tiered: from USD 0.0035 per share, minimum USD 0.35, plus exchange, clearing and regulatory fees. tastytrade charges USD 0 to open and close; exchange, clearing and regulatory fees apply. For foreign shares, Interactive Brokers' conversion fee is 0.03% added to the exchange rate on automatic currency conversions. Manual conversions: 0.20 basis points of trade value, minimum USD 2.00. tastytrade does not offer foreign exchanges.
Account fees at Interactive Brokers: None charged by IBKR; third parties may charge custody fees. At tastytrade: No annual or IRA maintenance fee; IRA closure USD 60. Neither has a general inactivity fee.
Accounts
Winner: Interactive Brokers, narrowly. Both have no minimum deposit: 0 USD at Interactive Brokers and 0 USD at tastytrade. tastytrade offers IRAs with no maintenance fee. Interactive Brokers lists Stocks and Shares ISA, Junior ISA, SIPP for UK clients, and it accepts clients in many more countries.
Accounts with a net asset value above USD 100,000 earn 3.483% on GBP cash above GBP 8,000 and 3.38% on USD cash above USD 10,000; smaller accounts earn a lower rate. tastytrade's cash rate is not published.
Platforms and features
Tie. Interactive Brokers offers IBKR Desktop, Trader Workstation (TWS), IBKR Mobile, IBKR GlobalTrader, Client Portal, IMPACT, IBKR APIs. tastytrade offers tastytrade desktop, tastytrade web, tastytrade mobile (iOS, Android, iPad). tastytrade's platforms put options chains, probability figures and strategy builders front and center, which many options traders find faster to use. Trader Workstation is more complex but covers far more instruments and order types.
Interactive Brokers offers a demo account, paper trading, margin, short selling, level 2 data and an API. tastytrade offers margin; its other features are not stated.
Funding
Tie. Interactive Brokers takes deposits at no cost and limits free withdrawals. Two free withdrawals per calendar month; after that GBP 7.00 per bank transfer or GBP 1.00 by BACS or SEPA. tastytrade charges for wires and transfers out. ACH free; outgoing wire USD 25 domestic, USD 45 foreign; outgoing ACAT USD 75. Both fund mainly by bank transfer.
Markets
Winner: Interactive Brokers. Interactive Brokers gives access to 175 market centers in 40 countries, with shares, ETFs, options, futures, bonds, funds, crypto and CFDs. tastytrade offers US shares, options, futures, bonds and crypto, but no funds or CFDs. CFDs carry a high risk of losing money because of leverage.
Research and support
Tie. Interactive Brokers offers phone, chat and ticket support, 24 hours a day from Sunday afternoon to Friday evening, US Eastern Time. tastytrade offers phone, chat and email; its hours are not published. tastytrade is known for its own financial video network and options education. On Trustpilot, Interactive Brokers is rated 3 from 5,577 reviews and tastytrade 2.9 from 637.
Which should you choose?
- Options traders who trade many contracts at once: tastytrade, for its capped opening fee and free closing.
- Options traders who trade one or two contracts: Interactive Brokers, for the lower per-contract fee.
- Global investors: Interactive Brokers, for its market access and conversion fee.
- US stock and ETF investors: tastytrade charges no commission; Interactive Brokers charges a small fee.
- Algorithmic traders: Interactive Brokers, for its API.
- Traders outside the US: Interactive Brokers, which serves many more countries.
Work out your cost on a typical month of trades at each broker, counting both the opening and closing legs. The cheaper broker depends on your contract sizes more than on the headline rate.
Read the full Interactive Brokers review and tastytrade review, or see all broker comparisons. Options and futures carry a high risk of loss.
Frequently asked questions
Is tastytrade cheaper than Interactive Brokers for options?
It depends on how you trade. tastytrade charges a per-contract fee to open, caps it per leg and charges nothing to close, which suits large multi-contract trades. Interactive Brokers charges a lower per-contract fee on both opening and closing, which can be cheaper for small trades held to expiry or closed early.
Which is better for stock investors?
tastytrade charges no commission on US stocks and ETFs. Interactive Brokers charges a small per-share fee on Fixed pricing but offers far more markets and a much cheaper route into foreign shares.
Can I trade futures at both?
Yes. Both offer futures and futures options, with per-contract commissions.
Who owns tastytrade?
tastytrade is owned by IG Group, which is listed on the London Stock Exchange. Interactive Brokers is listed on Nasdaq.
Are both regulated?
Yes. Both have US brokers registered with the SEC and FINRA, with SIPC cover on securities accounts.