Interactive Brokers vs XTB
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
Interactive Brokers and XTB are both listed brokers with FCA licenses, low costs and investing accounts for UK and European clients. XTB is the simpler, cheaper choice for share and ETF investors who buy in their own currency: no commission up to a monthly limit, interest on cash, fractional shares and an ISA. Interactive Brokers is the stronger choice for global investors: a tiny currency markup, markets in dozens of countries, listed options, futures and bonds, a SIPP, and professional tools. Pick XTB for a low-cost share ISA with interest on idle cash. Pick Interactive Brokers for international investing, derivatives or a pension.
- Minimum deposit
- USD 0
- GBP 0
- Max leverage
- 1:30 (CFDs) (FCA)
- 1:500 (CFDs) (FSC Belize)
- Regulators
- FCA, SEC/FINRA, CBI, CIRO, ASIC, MAS, DFSA
- FCA, KNF, CySEC, FSC Belize
- Platforms
- IBKR Desktop, Trader Workstation (TWS), IBKR Mobile, IBKR GlobalTrader, Client Portal, IMPACT, IBKR APIs
- XTB web platform, XTB mobile app
- Funding methods
- 2
- 4
- Trustpilot
- 3 / 5
- 3.8 / 5
- Founded
- 1977
- 2004
- Headquarters
- Greenwich, Connecticut, United States
- Warsaw, Poland
Safety and regulation
Winner: Interactive Brokers, narrowly. Both serve UK clients through FCA companies with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000: Interactive Brokers under 208159 and XTB under 522157. Both are listed. Interactive Brokers is listed on Nasdaq under the ticker IBKR. It is controlled by its founder and chairman, Thomas Peterffy, through IBG Holdings LLC, which holds about 73.5% of the operating group. XTB has been listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange since 2016.
XTB's EU clients sign with XTB S.A. under Poland's KNF, and Interactive Brokers' with its Irish company under the Central Bank of Ireland. XTB also runs a Belize entity with CFD leverage up to 1:500 (CFDs) and no negative balance protection. Interactive Brokers has no offshore entity, which gives it the edge.
Costs
Winner: XTB on commission; Interactive Brokers on currency. XTB charges 0% commission up to EUR 100,000 monthly turnover; 0.2% (minimum GBP 10) above that. Interactive Brokers has two plans. Fixed: USD 0.005 per share, minimum USD 1.00, maximum 1% of trade value. Tiered: from USD 0.0035 per share, minimum USD 0.35, plus exchange, clearing and regulatory fees. Before FX, a US share purchase costs 0 USD at XTB and 1 USD at Interactive Brokers.
Currency reverses the picture. XTB charges 0.5%. Interactive Brokers charges 0.03% added to the exchange rate on automatic currency conversions. Manual conversions: 0.20 basis points of trade value, minimum USD 2.00. On a US purchase of any size, XTB's conversion fee costs far more than Interactive Brokers' commission.
Other fees at XTB: None up to EUR 250,000 held; above that 0.02% a year, minimum GBP 10. EUR 10 a month after 12 months without trading, if no deposit was made in the last 90 days. At Interactive Brokers: A minimum monthly activity fee of GBP 3 applies to a Stocks and Shares ISA and GBP 1 to a Junior ISA. Two free withdrawals per calendar month; after that GBP 7.00 per bank transfer or GBP 1.00 by BACS or SEPA. XTB's withdrawals are free.
Accounts
Split. Interactive Brokers offers Stocks and Shares ISA, Junior ISA, SIPP. XTB offers Stocks and Shares ISA, Cash ISA. Pension savers need Interactive Brokers.
Interest favors XTB, which pays on uninvested cash in three currencies. 4% AER (variable) on GBP, 2.3% on EUR and 3.45% on USD uninvested funds in a general investment account. Interactive Brokers pays its full rate only on larger accounts. Accounts with a net asset value above USD 100,000 earn 3.483% on GBP cash above GBP 8,000 and 3.38% on USD cash above USD 10,000; smaller accounts earn a lower rate. Both have no minimum deposit. XTB holds GBP, EUR, USD; Interactive Brokers can hold many currencies, which lets an investor keep dollars and avoid converting back and forth.
Platforms and features
Winner: Interactive Brokers. It offers IBKR Desktop, Trader Workstation (TWS), IBKR Mobile, IBKR GlobalTrader, Client Portal, IMPACT, IBKR APIs, with Level 2 data, an API, margin and short selling on the investing account. Both offer fractional shares, recurring investing and a demo or paper account. XTB offers XTB web platform, XTB mobile app, simpler to learn; leverage and short positions at XTB are only on its separate CFD account. App Store ratings are 4.7 for XTB and 4.4 for Interactive Brokers.
Funding
Winner: XTB. XTB takes cards, bank transfers, PayPal and Skrill, and pays out by bank Same business day if requested before 1 pm, otherwise next business day, free. Interactive Brokers takes bank transfers and Wise, and pays out in 1 to 2 business days, with a monthly limit on free withdrawals.
Markets
Winner: Interactive Brokers. It reaches 175 market centers in 40 countries, with shares, ETFs, options, futures, bonds, funds and crypto. XTB offers about 6,900 stocks and 2,300 ETFs from 14 markets, plus CFDs, with no bonds or funds in the investing account.
Research and support
Tie. Both answer by phone and chat on weekdays: XTB 24 hours a day, Monday to Friday, Interactive Brokers 24 hours a day from Sunday afternoon to Friday evening, US Eastern Time. On Trustpilot, XTB scores 3.8 from 3,107 reviews and Interactive Brokers 3 from 5,577.
Who pays less
The answer depends on currency. A UK investor buying UK shares and UK-listed ETFs in pounds pays nothing to deal at XTB and earns interest on idle cash, so XTB is hard to beat. The same investor buying US shares pays XTB's conversion fee on every purchase and sale, and here Interactive Brokers' tiny markup usually wins even after its commission. Investors who keep dollars in an Interactive Brokers account can avoid conversion entirely between trades, which XTB's pound account cannot match unless you also hold a dollar account there.
Idle accounts
The two treat quiet accounts differently. XTB charges its inactivity fee only after a year with no trades and no recent deposit, so a regular investor will never pay it, but a buy-and-forget investor might. Interactive Brokers' activity fee is a monthly minimum on its UK ISAs, so a quiet ISA still pays it. If you plan to buy a few ETFs and leave them for years, compare these two charges against the interest each would pay on any cash you leave in the account.
Which should you choose?
- UK investors buying UK shares and ETFs: XTB.
- Investors buying mostly US and international shares: Interactive Brokers.
- Pension savers: Interactive Brokers, which offers a SIPP.
- Investors who hold cash between purchases: XTB, for its interest rate.
- Investors who want listed options, futures or bonds: Interactive Brokers.
Most retail CFD accounts lose money, and margin can lose more than you invest. Read the full Interactive Brokers review and XTB review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Is XTB cheaper than Interactive Brokers?
On commission, yes, since XTB charges none up to a high monthly turnover. On currency conversion, Interactive Brokers is far cheaper. Investors who mainly buy foreign shares in large amounts often pay less at Interactive Brokers.
Does XTB offer a SIPP?
No. XTB offers a Stocks and Shares ISA and a Cash ISA. Interactive Brokers offers a Stocks and Shares ISA, Junior ISA and SIPP.
Which pays more interest on cash?
XTB, for most accounts, since it pays on all uninvested cash in several currencies. Interactive Brokers pays only above a cash threshold and at a lower rate on smaller accounts.
Can I trade options or futures at XTB?
Not as real exchange-traded contracts in its investing account. XTB offers CFDs on many markets. Interactive Brokers offers listed options and futures on exchanges worldwide.
Which is safer?
Both serve UK clients through FCA-regulated companies with FSCS cover and both are listed. XTB also runs an offshore entity in Belize with high CFD leverage for some international clients.