Skip to content
Menu

Lightyear vs Trading 212

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Safety and regulation
  2. Costs
  3. Accounts
  4. Platforms and features
  5. Funding
  6. Markets
  7. Research and support
  8. Which should you choose?

Lightyear and Trading 212 are commission-free investing apps for UK and European investors, both with a Stocks and Shares ISA, a Cash ISA, fractional shares and interest on cash. Lightyear is the cheaper choice for investors who buy many US or European shares, because its currency conversion fee is lower, and it holds GBP, USD and EUR balances. Trading 212 offers more: a SIPP, a demo account, dividend reinvestment, extended-hours trading, live chat around the clock and many more funding methods. Pick Lightyear if low currency costs matter most. Pick Trading 212 if you want a pension, more features and faster support.

Minimum deposit
GBP 0
GBP 1
Max leverage
—
1:30 (CFD account) (FCA)
Regulators
FCA, EFSA
FCA, CySEC, BaFin, ASIC
Platforms
Lightyear mobile app, Lightyear web app
Trading 212 mobile app, Trading 212 web platform
Funding methods
4
7
Trustpilot
4.7 / 5
4.6 / 5
Founded
2020
2004
Headquarters
London, United Kingdom
London, United Kingdom

Safety and regulation

Tie. Lightyear's UK company is authorized by the FCA under reference 987226. Its protection is up to GBP 85,000 for non-US assets and cash; US shares held through Alpaca are covered by SIPC up to USD 500,000. EU clients are served by a company licensed by Estonia's financial regulator. Lightyear is privately held and is not listed on a stock exchange.

Trading 212 UK is authorized by the FCA under reference 609146, with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000. It also has companies regulated by CySEC, BaFin and ASIC. Trading 212 is privately held and controlled by co-founders Ivan Ashminov and Borislav Nedialkov.

Both are privately held. Trading 212 has been operating far longer, since 2004, against 2020 for Lightyear.

Costs

Winner: Lightyear for foreign shares; tie otherwise. Lightyear charges no commission on its own orders. Free per order on personal accounts. Trading 212 is commission-free too. Commission-free. US regulatory fees apply on sales (SEC and FINRA fees). Both are commission-free on ETFs.

The difference is the currency conversion fee. Lightyear charges 0.10% on the live interbank rate. Trading 212 charges 0.15%. A UK investor who buys US shares pays this on every purchase and sale, so the gap adds up for frequent foreign trades. Lightyear's multi-currency balances also let you hold dollars between trades and avoid converting back.

Neither charges custody or inactivity fees. UK stamp duty applies to UK share purchases at both.

Accounts

Winner: Trading 212. Lightyear offers a Stocks and Shares ISA, Cash ISA. Trading 212 offers a Stocks and Shares ISA, Cash ISA, SIPP. The SIPP makes Trading 212 the choice for investors who want their pension and ISA in one app.

Minimum deposits are tiny, at 0 GBP at Lightyear and 1 GBP at Trading 212. Lightyear holds GBP, USD, EUR; Trading 212 supports many more account currencies.

On cash, Lightyear pays through its Vaults. 4.01% AER (daily variable) on cash held in Vaults within a Stocks and Shares ISA or general investment account, invested in BlackRock money market funds. Trading 212 pays interest directly. 3.6% on GBP, 3.3% on USD and 2.4% on EUR uninvested cash, paid daily with no minimum balance (opt-in); interest is paid in 10 currencies. Lightyear's Vaults are money market funds rather than bank deposits, so their value can move slightly.

Platforms and features

Winner: Trading 212. Lightyear offers the Lightyear mobile app, Lightyear web app. Trading 212 offers the Trading 212 mobile app, Trading 212 web platform. Both are clean and easy for beginners.

Both support recurring investing and fractional shares. Trading 212 adds a demo account, extended-hours trading, dividend reinvestment and an API. Lightyear has no extended-hours trading, margin or short selling. For a buy-and-hold investor these gaps rarely matter, but traders who want to react to US earnings outside normal hours will need Trading 212.

Funding

Winner: Trading 212. Lightyear charges for card deposits. Free by bank transfer; 0.6% by card, Apple Pay or Google Pay. Incoming USD wire payments cost up to USD 8.50. Its bank withdrawals take About 2 business days. Trading 212 waives card fees up to an allowance. Bank transfer and instant bank transfer free. Card, Apple Pay and Google Pay free until GBP/EUR 2,000 has been deposited in total, then 0.7%. It also takes open banking, iDEAL and BLIK, and card withdrawals take About 1 business day. Card deposits are cheaper at Trading 212 until the free allowance is used.

Markets

Split. Lightyear offers about 6,000 stocks, with ETFs, bonds and funds. Trading 212 offers shares, ETFs, bonds, crypto and CFDs in a separate account; CFDs carry a high risk of losing money because of leverage. Lightyear offers funds and Trading 212 does not; Trading 212 offers crypto and Lightyear does not. Neither offers options or futures.

Research and support

Winner: Trading 212. Trading 212 offers live chat, email and ticket support, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week; no phone line. Lightyear offers email and ticket support: Replies generally within 1 business day. Both are rated highly on Trustpilot: Lightyear 4.7 from 2,933 reviews, and Trading 212 4.6 from 108,110.

Which should you choose?

  • Investors who buy many US or EU shares: Lightyear, for the lower conversion fee and multi-currency balances.
  • Investors who want a SIPP: Trading 212.
  • Beginners who want to practice: Trading 212, for its demo account.
  • Fund investors: Lightyear, which offers funds.
  • Investors who want help quickly: Trading 212, with live chat at any hour.
  • Card funders: Trading 212, free up to its allowance.

Both apps suit long-term investors, and both let you start with a very small amount, so it is easy to try each before you move a larger sum or transfer an existing ISA. When you transfer an ISA, use the new provider's transfer service rather than withdrawing the cash, or you lose the tax wrapper on that money. If most of your portfolio is in UK shares and GBP funds, the conversion fee matters little and Trading 212's extra features may decide it.

Read the full Lightyear review and Trading 212 review, or see all broker comparisons. The value of investments can fall as well as rise, and ISA and pension tax rules can change.

Frequently asked questions

Is Lightyear or Trading 212 cheaper?

Both charge no commission on shares and ETFs. Lightyear's currency conversion fee is lower, so it is cheaper for investors who buy many foreign shares. Trading 212 is free to fund by card up to a set total, while Lightyear charges a percentage on card deposits.

Do both offer an ISA?

Yes. Both offer a Stocks and Shares ISA and a Cash ISA in the UK. Trading 212 also offers a SIPP; Lightyear does not.

Which pays more interest on cash?

Both pay interest on cash, in different ways. Trading 212 pays interest on uninvested cash directly; Lightyear pays through money market fund Vaults. Compare the current rates, as both change.

Can I phone Lightyear or Trading 212?

Neither has a phone line. Trading 212 offers live chat around the clock, plus email; Lightyear supports clients by email and ticket.

Are Lightyear and Trading 212 safe?

Both are FCA-authorized with FSCS cover for UK clients. Lightyear holds US shares through a US partner, where SIPC cover applies instead.