Maven vs Topstep
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
Maven and Topstep serve different traders, though both suit manual day traders. Maven is a Saint Lucia-registered forex and CFD firm with some of the lowest challenge prices available, a pay-later option and swap-free accounts. Topstep is a Chicago futures-only firm with a monthly Trading Combine on its own platform and a very large payout record. Pick Maven if you trade forex, gold or indices, want a refundable fee and want to hold trades overnight. Pick Topstep if you day-trade US futures and value a long-established firm. We compare the parts that apply to both.
- Max profit split
- 90% with add-on
- 90%
- Platforms
- MetaTrader 5, Match-Trader
- Proprietary platform
- Trustpilot
- Not shown
- 3.7 / 5
- Founded
- 2022
- 2012
- Headquarters
- Rodney Bay, Gros-Islet, Saint Lucia
- Chicago, Illinois, United States
Challenge models and prices
No direct winner: different markets; Maven on refunds. Maven charges once. At 50,000 its Standard 2-Step costs 220 USD and its 1-Step 170, both refunded with the third withdrawal. Its pay-later route starts at 5.
Topstep charges monthly. The 50,000 Combine costs 49 USD a month plus an activation fee on passing, or 95 a month without one. Nothing is refunded. A trader who needs three months at Topstep pays several times Maven's one-off fee.
Topstep's largest account is 150,000; Maven's is 100,000, and Maven adds instant accounts that Topstep does not sell. See Maven challenges and the Topstep Trading Combine.
Profit targets and drawdown
Winner: Maven, for a fixed floor and room. Maven's 2-Step at 50,000 asks for 8%, 5% with 4%, calculated from the higher of balance or equity at 00:00 UTC daily and 8% of initial balance, static, with Unlimited (one trade every 30 days) as its time rule.
Topstep's 50,000 Combine asks for $3,000 in one step, with $2,000, set at the end of each day from the account balance high. One phase is faster, but the floor climbs with each strong close. Maven's 1-Step is a trailing test too, and stricter in one way: 5% trailing from the highest equity, which follows open equity.
Trading rules
Winner: Maven for holding; tie on automation. Topstep closes every position each day. Not allowed. Positions must be flat by 3:10 PM CT each weekday; trading resumes at 5:00 PM CT. Positions cannot be carried from one session to the next. Maven allows overnight and weekend holding on every account.
News: Topstep bans trading full size into major releases. Maven's Standard plans block two minutes either side of red-folder news, and a breach ends a challenge.
Automation is restricted at both. Maven bans EAs. Prohibited on all platforms; all trades must be executed manually. Topstep bans systems that give an unfair edge. Software, AI or ultra-high-speed systems that give an unfair advantage are prohibited, as are scalping algorithms designed to exploit simulated fills.
Consistency: Topstep: Trading Combine: best day at most 55% of the profit target, otherwise the target increases. Express Funded Account Consistency path: best day within 40% of total profit. Maven: None on Standard and Omo plans. Instant and funded Buy Now Pay Later: 20% consistency score. Mini: 15%. See Maven rules and Topstep rules.
Payouts and profit split
Winner: tie. Both pay a similar top split: 90% with add-on at Maven and 90% at Topstep. Maven pays Every 10 business days with a USD 20 of profit before the split (Standard plans) minimum, but caps withdrawals: USD 200,000 (also the maximum combined balance when merging funded accounts). Withdrawals are capped at USD 10,000 before the split per rolling 30 days. Topstep's first payout rule: Express Funded Account: after 5 winning days of USD 150 or more (Standard path) or 3 trading days meeting the 40% consistency objective (Consistency path). It has a USD 125 minimum and per-request caps on Express accounts.
Methods suit different regions. Maven pays through Cryptocurrency (USDT-BSC or USDC-ERC20), Rise, Direct bank transfer (Nigeria, Kenya and Ghana). Topstep pays through Prop-to-Brokerage (US only), Aeropay (US banks), Wise (China, Canada, UK), ACH (US banks, USD 30 fee), Wire/SWIFT (international, USD 30 fee). Topstep states it has paid more than USD 1.5 billion; Maven publishes no total. See Maven payouts and Topstep payouts.
Platforms
Winner: Maven, for choice. Maven supports MetaTrader 5, Match-Trader. Topstep trades only on TopstepX, its Proprietary platform platform. Commission is USD 2 per lot per side (USD 4 round trip) on forex at Maven, with no swaps, and USD 1.00 round turn commission plus exchange and NFA fees (ES total USD 3.78) on futures minis at Topstep.
Scaling
Winner: Maven. Maven grows the account balance. Account grows by 25% after a four-month cycle with 10% profit (2.5% a month) and at least one payout a month; repeatable up to USD 1,000,000. Topstep scales position size with the balance instead. The Scaling Plan applies to the Express Funded Account and sets the maximum position size from the current account balance. It does not apply to the Live Funded Account, which uses Dynamic Live Risk Expansion.
Identity rules
Winner: Maven, for flexibility. Maven allows VPNs within limits. VPN use is allowed. The IP address should stay in the same geographical region; significant changes may require proof such as travel documents. Devices must belong to the trader. Topstep bans VPNs and remote servers. VPNs, proxies, TOR and other location or identity masking services are prohibited. Orders must originate from the trader's personal device; a VPS or remote server may not place or relay orders.
Inactivity and support
Winner: Topstep on support. Maven asks for activity every month. At least one trading activity every 30 days. Topstep may close an idle funded account after a month. An Express Funded Account with more than 30 days of inactivity may be closed. Topstep's support runs 24/7 by live chat and Discord. Maven offers email, phone and Discord, without live chat, and its hours are not published.
Reputation
Winner: Topstep, on visibility. Topstep is rated 3.7 from 15,083 reviews, low for its size, with complaints about outages. Trustpilot withholds Maven's score and lists 5,226 reviews without an average. Topstep launched its evaluation in 2012; Maven was founded in 2022.
Which should you choose?
- Forex and CFD traders: Maven. Topstep has no CFDs.
- US futures day traders: Topstep. Maven has no futures.
- Traders on a tight budget: Maven, including its pay-later option.
- Traders who pass quickly: Topstep's monthly model rewards speed.
- Swing traders: Maven.
- Traders who want a long payout record: Topstep.
Read the full Maven review and Topstep review, or see all prop firm comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Which should I choose, Maven or Topstep?
Choose by market. Maven offers forex and CFDs only; Topstep offers futures only.
How do the fees compare?
Maven charges a one-off fee, refunded on most plans at the third withdrawal, and offers a pay-later start. Topstep charges a monthly subscription until you pass or cancel.
Can I hold positions overnight?
At Maven, yes, including weekends. At Topstep, no; every position must be closed each afternoon.
Can I automate my trading?
Neither firm suits full automation. Maven bans EAs, and Topstep bans unfair technology and orders sent from a VPS.
Which has a visible Trustpilot score?
Topstep. Trustpilot currently withholds Maven's score.