Skip to content
Menu

OANDA vs XM

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Safety and regulation
  2. Costs
  3. Accounts
  4. Platforms
  5. Funding
  6. Markets
  7. Research and support
  8. Which should you choose?

OANDA and XM are both long-running forex brokers, but they serve different parts of the world. OANDA is regulated in the major financial centers, including the US, UK and Canada, with TradingView, MetaTrader 5, an API and its own platform. XM serves the EU from Cyprus and most other clients from offshore companies, with a token minimum deposit, MetaTrader 4 and 5, local payment methods and support in many languages. Pick OANDA for regulation and technical tools. Pick XM for local access, education and Islamic accounts.

OANDA
4.0 / 5
Visit
XM
4.6 / 5
Visit
Minimum deposit
USD 0
USD 5
Max leverage
1:50 (CFTC/NFA)
1:1000 (FSC Belize)
EUR/USD average spread
1.69 pips (Standard)
1.6 pips (Standard)
Regulators
BVI FSC, CFTC/NFA, FCA, KNF, ASIC, CIRO, MAS, JFSA
CySEC, FSC Belize, FSC, FSA, BVI FSC, FSCA, DFSA, UAE CMA, CMA
Platforms
MetaTrader 5, TradingView, Proprietary platform
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform
Funding methods
6
9
Trustpilot
3.5 / 5
Not shown
Founded
1996
2009
Headquarters
New York, United States
Limassol, Cyprus

Safety and regulation

Winner: OANDA. It serves US clients under CFTC and NFA registration NFA 0325821, UK clients under FCA license 542574, EU clients from Poland under the KNF, Australians under ASIC, Canadians with the Canadian Investor Protection Fund, and clients in Singapore and Japan. XM has none of the US, UK, Australian or Canadian licenses.

In the EU the two are close. XM serves EU clients from Cyprus under CySEC license 120/10, with investor compensation up to EUR 20,000; OANDA's Polish company offers negative balance protection but does not publish a compensation amount. XM adds the DFSA in Dubai and local licenses in South Africa and Kenya.

For rest-of-world clients, XM is clearer. XM Global in Belize offers negative balance protection, though with leverage up to 1:1000. OANDA's BVI company, license SIBA/L/20/1130, publishes neither leverage nor protection terms. Neither has a compensation scheme offshore. Both are privately owned; OANDA recently by FTMO. Trustpilot withholds XM's rating, citing a guidelines breach.

Costs

No winner on spreads. Both publish only minimums. On spread-only accounts, the like-for-like test, OANDA quotes EUR/USD from 0.6 pips and XM's Ultra Low from 0.8 pips. A minimum is the tightest spread seen, not what you typically pay, so these cannot be ranked.

Raw pricing does not settle it either. XM's Zero account charges 7 USD per lot round trip and opens with a small deposit, but has no published average spread. OANDA's Premium Plus core-pricing account is for very high-volume traders, and OANDA does not state its commission.

The practical test is a demo at each. Note the live EUR/USD spread at the times you trade over several days, compare the same type of account, and add commission where it applies. OANDA's US entity prices separately.

Non-trading fees: split. XM charges USD 10 per month after 90 days without trading, deposits or withdrawals; OANDA charges Up to USD 20 per month after 12 months without trading activity; not charged while a position is open, so it is far gentler on idle accounts. But OANDA charges USD 20 per bank wire withdrawal and a conversion fee of 0.5% when money is converted between currencies, while XM covers payment fees except small bank wires and offers more base currencies.

More detail: OANDA fees and XM fees

Accounts

Split. Both are cheap to open: OANDA lists 0 USD and XM 5 USD. OANDA adds spread betting and guaranteed stops for UK clients, and a Premium tier with rebates.

XM puts raw pricing within reach of small accounts, offers Islamic accounts, which OANDA does not, and has a Shares account for real shares in selected regions. XM's EU and international companies sell different accounts. See OANDA account types and XM account types.

Platforms

Tie, for different traders. Both offer MetaTrader 5, their own well-rated apps and VPS hosting. OANDA adds TradingView connected to the account and an API, and allows scalping. XM adds MetaTrader 4, which OANDA's international entity does not offer.

OANDA's copy trading runs through MetaTrader 5 signals. XM offers copy trading but does not name its providers, has no API, and does not publish its scalping policy. TradingView and API users should choose OANDA; MetaTrader 4 users, XM.

US clients of OANDA should also note that US rules restrict hedging within one account and require positions to be closed first in, first out, so strategies built for XM's MetaTrader accounts may not transfer directly. Both brokers allow Expert Advisors, and both offer VPS hosting for strategies that need to run around the clock.

Funding

Winner: XM. XM covers payment fees on most methods and offers local options such as M-Pesa and local bank transfers. Skrill and Neteller withdrawals take Instant, and crypto withdrawals Instant to 24 hours.

OANDA is quicker on cards, at About 1 business day against 2-5 business days at XM, and free. But its bank wires carry a fee and take 2-5 business days, and its international list has no crypto or local methods.

Markets

Winner: XM, narrowly. XM lists around 1,400 instruments, including 21 indices, 20 commodities and about 1,200 share CFDs, plus real shares in some regions. OANDA lists 18 indices and 10 commodities, and cites around 1,500 instruments without breaking down share CFDs.

OANDA publishes 48 forex pairs and 18 crypto CFDs; XM gives no single count for either. US clients of OANDA can trade forex only.

Research and support

Winner: XM. Both publish news, daily analysis, an economic calendar and webinars. XM adds Trading Central and structured courses in many languages; OANDA adds Autochartist and a demo that never expires, but has no courses.

XM answers 24/7 by live chat, email and phone. OANDA answers 24/5, Sunday evening to Friday evening, adding WhatsApp.

Which should you choose?

  • US, UK, Australian and Canadian residents: OANDA, which has regulated companies in all four.
  • TradingView and API users: OANDA.
  • MetaTrader 4 users and small accounts: XM.
  • Traders in Africa and Asia who rely on local payments: XM.
  • Traders who need Islamic accounts: XM.
  • Occasional traders: OANDA, whose inactivity fee starts much later.
  • Traders who want published raw-spread averages: neither publishes them. Pepperstone is a third option (see how it compares with OANDA).

High offshore leverage magnifies losses as fast as gains. Read the full OANDA review and XM review, or see all broker comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

Is OANDA cheaper than XM?

Their spreads cannot be ranked, because both publish only minimums. Their non-trading fees differ. XM covers most payment fees but charges an inactivity fee quickly, while OANDA's inactivity fee starts much later but it charges for bank wires and currency conversion.

Which is safer, OANDA or XM?

OANDA, for clients of its regulated companies in the US, UK, EU, Australia, Canada, Singapore and Japan. XM is regulated by CySEC in the EU, but most of its other clients sign with offshore companies.

Can US or UK residents use XM?

No. XM restricts US residents and refers UK residents to a separate group brand. OANDA serves both through regulated local companies.

Which offers MetaTrader 4?

XM. OANDA's international entity offers MetaTrader 5, TradingView and its own platform, but not MetaTrader 4.

Which is better for traders in Africa and Asia?

XM, for most. It offers local payment methods such as M-Pesa, support in many languages and local licenses in South Africa and Kenya.