Octa vs Tickmill
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
Octa and Tickmill both serve international forex traders with MetaTrader and low entry costs, but they are built differently. Octa offers one commission-free price across three platforms, swap-free accounts, guaranteed stops, copy trading and fast free e-wallet and crypto payouts, with a lightly regulated international entity. Tickmill is a raw-pricing broker with FCA and CySEC entities, low commissions on its Raw and TradingView Raw accounts, private insurance on its offshore entity and quick card and e-wallet withdrawals, but a weak Trustpilot score. Pick Octa for swap-free simplicity. Pick Tickmill for stronger regulation and raw pricing. Both offer demo accounts, so you can test each before depositing.
- Minimum deposit
- USD 25
- USD 100
- Max leverage
- 1:1000 (MISA)
- 1:1000 (FSCA)
- EUR/USD average spread
- 0.9 pips (OctaTrader)
- 1.6 pips (Classic)
- Regulators
- MISA, CySEC, FSCA, FSC
- FSA, FCA, CySEC, FSCA, DFSA
- Platforms
- Proprietary platform, MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5
- MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, Proprietary platform
- Funding methods
- 10
- 12
- Trustpilot
- 3.7 / 5
- 2.2 / 5
- Founded
- 2011
- 2014
- Headquarters
- Mwali, Comoros
- Mahe, Seychelles
Safety and regulation
Winner: Tickmill. Tickmill UK Ltd holds FCA license 717270 with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000, and Tickmill Europe holds CySEC license 278/15. International clients sign with Tickmill Ltd in the Seychelles (SD008), covered by Excess of Loss insurance policy up to EUR 1,000,000.
Octa's EU clients sign with Octa Markets Cyprus under CySEC license 372/18. International clients mostly sign with Octa Markets LTD, registered with the Mwali authority (T2023320), the lowest of our regulator tiers. Both have FSCA entities in South Africa.
Both state negative balance protection on their entities. Tickmill is privately owned and not publicly traded. It is part of the Tickmill Group, co-founded by Ingmar Mattus. Octa is privately owned and not publicly traded. It traded as OctaFX until a rebrand to Octa.
Costs
No clear winner. Octa publishes an average EUR/USD spread of 0.9 pips, so one standard lot costs 9 USD round trip with no commission. Tickmill publishes no average spread: its Classic account lists spreads from 1.6 pips, and its Raw account charges 6 USD per round turn on top of the raw spread.
Without a Tickmill average, the two cannot be ranked. Raw accounts are usually cheaper per lot than all-in accounts for active traders, which favors Tickmill for scalpers.
Octa's accounts carry no swaps, which favors swing traders. Octa charges None for withdrawals and None for inactivity. Tickmill's withdrawal terms are: None from Tickmill; intermediary banks or e-wallets may charge; its inactivity terms are not published. See Octa fees and Tickmill fees.
Accounts
Winner: Octa for entry; Tickmill for choice. Octa's minimum is 25 USD, against 100 USD at Tickmill. Tickmill offers spread-only, raw and TradingView Raw accounts, plus professional terms with leverage up to 1:500. Octa's three accounts share one price. Both offer swap-free options.
Platforms
Winner: Tickmill. Tickmill offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, Proprietary platform, including TradingView, with VPS hosting and an API. Octa offers Proprietary platform, MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, with guaranteed stops but no VPS. Both list copy trading and allow scalping and Expert Advisors.
Funding
Tie. At Octa, Skrill and Neteller withdrawals take 1-3 hours, and crypto 1-3 hours to approve, up to 30 minutes to transfer. At Tickmill, cards, Skrill, Neteller, PayPal, Trustly and Przelewy24 are paid Within 1 working day, crypto Within 24 hours, and bank transfers 1-3 working days. Octa is faster on e-wallets; Tickmill publishes card times and accepts PayPal.
Markets
Split. Tickmill lists 62 forex pairs, about 492 share CFDs, 25 ETFs and 15 crypto CFDs. Octa lists 52 forex pairs, 10 indices and 27 crypto CFDs, about 260 in total.
Research and support
Winner: Octa. Both publish news, an economic calendar, daily analysis and webinars. Octa adds courses. Octa answers 24/7; Tickmill offers 24/5 (chatbot 24/7; phone Monday to Friday 7:00-16:00 GMT). On Trustpilot, Octa scores 3.7 from 9,986 reviews, against 2.2 from 1,205 for Tickmill.
Regulation against reputation
This pair shows that licenses and reviews do not always point the same way. Tickmill has the stronger regulatory set-up, with FCA and CySEC entities and insured offshore accounts, yet a low Trustpilot score. Octa has a lightly regulated international entity but better reviews. Licenses tell you what protection exists if something goes wrong; reviews tell you how clients feel about day-to-day service. Weigh both. A trader in the UK or EU gets formal protection only at Tickmill's or Octa's European entities; a trader elsewhere should read Tickmill's recent reviews closely and remember that Octa's Mwali entity offers no regulator to complain to.
Professional and swap-free accounts
Tickmill's professional terms suit experienced traders who qualify and want higher leverage at a regulated entity, at the cost of some retail protections. Octa's swap-free accounts suit traders who hold positions over several nights or need Islamic accounts. These features attract different people, so they rarely compete head to head.
Execution and risk tools
Tickmill's broker model is Market maker and STP, and both brokers allow scalping and Expert Advisors, which suggests neither restricts short-term strategies. Octa adds guaranteed stops, which close a trade at the exact level you set even if the price gaps, useful around weekends and major announcements. Tickmill has no guaranteed stops but offers VPS hosting, which matters to algorithmic traders whose Expert Advisors must run without interruption. If execution speed is central to your strategy, test both on demo accounts during busy market hours and compare the fills you get.
Withdrawals in practice
Both brokers say they charge nothing of their own to withdraw, and both pay e-wallets quickly. Octa pays e-wallets within hours; Tickmill pays most methods within one working day. As at any broker, a first withdrawal may take longer while identity checks are completed, and money usually returns first to the method you deposited with. Verify your account fully before you need to withdraw, and keep your deposit and withdrawal methods the same to avoid delays.
Which should you choose?
- UK traders: Tickmill, since Octa has no FCA entity.
- Scalpers who prefer raw pricing: Tickmill.
- Swing traders and those who need swap-free accounts: Octa.
- TradingView users: Tickmill.
- Traders starting with a small deposit: Octa.
Most retail CFD accounts lose money. Read the full Octa review and Tickmill review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Which is safer, Octa or Tickmill?
Tickmill, for most traders. It has FCA and CySEC entities and its offshore entity in the Seychelles carries private insurance. Octa has a CySEC entity for the EU, but its main international entity is registered in Mwali, which gives very little oversight.
Which is cheaper?
Octa publishes an average spread, giving a known all-in cost on its commission-free accounts. Tickmill publishes only minimum spreads, so its total cost is not known on the same basis, but it offers raw accounts with a low commission, which Octa does not.
Does Tickmill charge swaps?
Yes, on standard accounts, though it offers swap-free options. Octa's accounts are swap-free.
Which has better reviews?
Octa's Trustpilot score is higher than Tickmill's. Read recent reviews of both before you open an account.
Which has more markets?
Tickmill lists more share CFDs and ETFs. Octa lists more crypto CFDs. Their forex lists are similar in size.