Pepperstone vs Tickmill
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
Pepperstone and Tickmill are both raw-spread brokers aimed at active MetaTrader traders and scalpers, with FCA and CySEC entities. Choose Tickmill if a lower commission per lot matters most, you want fast withdrawals across many methods including crypto, or you live in South Africa. Choose Pepperstone if you want published average spreads, so you can check what you pay, plus cTrader, an Australian license, a wider market list and support at weekends.
Each area goes to the stronger broker, and Tickmill wins on commission and funding.
- Minimum deposit
- USD 0
- USD 100
- Max leverage
- 1:400 (CMA)
- 1:1000 (FSCA)
- EUR/USD average spread
- 1.13 pips (Standard)
- 1.6 pips (Classic)
- Regulators
- ASIC, FCA, CySEC, BaFin, DFSA, UAE CMA, CMA, SCB
- FSA, FCA, CySEC, FSCA, DFSA
- Platforms
- MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, cTrader, TradingView, Proprietary platform
- MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, Proprietary platform
- Funding methods
- 11
- 12
- Trustpilot
- 4.2 / 5
- 2.2 / 5
- Founded
- 2010
- 2014
- Headquarters
- Melbourne, Australia
- Mahe, Seychelles
Safety and regulation
Winner: Pepperstone, narrowly. In the UK and EU the two are level. Tickmill UK holds FCA license 717270, with FSCS cover of up to GBP 85,000; Pepperstone Limited holds 684312, with the same cover. Both have CySEC entities for EU clients and both confirm negative balance protection on every retail entity.
Pepperstone has the wider license list: ASIC in Australia, BaFin in Germany, the DFSA and SCA in the UAE and the CMA in Kenya. Tickmill's DFSA presence is a representative office only. Tickmill does have an FSCA entity in South Africa, license FSP 49464, where Pepperstone has none.
Rest-of-world clients sign with Tickmill Ltd in the Seychelles, license SD008, or with Pepperstone in the Bahamas. Neither has a statutory compensation scheme there. Tickmill points to private insurance of up to EUR 1,000,000, which is something Pepperstone's offshore entity does not offer. Both firms are privately owned, and Tickmill has operated since 2014, against 2010 for Pepperstone.
More detail: Is Pepperstone safe? and Is Tickmill safe?
Costs
Winner: no clear winner on spreads; Tickmill on commission. Both have a raw account, so the comparison is like for like. On MetaTrader, Tickmill Raw charges 6 USD per lot round trip, against 7 USD at Pepperstone Razor. On TradingView, Tickmill charges 7 USD.
The spread is the other half of the cost, and only Pepperstone publishes an average: 0.13 pips on EUR/USD, for an all-in 8.3 USD per lot. Tickmill publishes only that its raw spreads start from 0 pips. Tickmill's lower commission is an advantage, but without an average spread there is no telling whether its total cost is lower.
On spread-only accounts, Pepperstone Standard averages 1.13 pips, while Tickmill Classic starts from 1.6 pips. A "from" figure is the best case, so Pepperstone Standard looks cheaper than Tickmill Classic. Neither broker charges an inactivity fee.
How much the commission gap matters depends on volume. For a few lots a month it is negligible; for a scalper trading many lots a day it adds up, and Tickmill's MetaTrader pricing may be worth testing on a demo against Pepperstone's.
More detail: Pepperstone fees and Tickmill fees
Accounts
Winner: Pepperstone, narrowly. Pepperstone's minimum deposit is 0 USD, against 100 USD at Tickmill. Pepperstone also offers USD, EUR, GBP, AUD, CAD, CHF, JPY, NZD, SGD, HKD as base currencies; Tickmill offers USD, EUR, GBP, ZAR, and its TradingView Raw account is USD-only.
Both offer Islamic and professional accounts. Tickmill makes swap-free available on all account types; Pepperstone offers it in some regions. Pepperstone offers spread betting for UK clients. See Pepperstone account types and Tickmill account types.
Platforms
Winner: Pepperstone. Both offer MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView and their own app, with VPS hosting, API access, scalping and hedging. Pepperstone adds cTrader.
Both offer copy trading. Pepperstone connects to CopyTrading by Pepperstone (Pelican), cTrader Copy, Signal Start, MetaTrader Signals, DupliTrade. Tickmill offers copy trading but does not name providers. Neither offers guaranteed stops.
Funding
Winner: Tickmill. Tickmill lists card, PayPal, Skrill and Neteller withdrawals Within 1 working day, and bank withdrawals in 1-3 working days. It charges nothing itself, refunds bank fees on large wire deposits, and lets you withdraw to crypto.
Pepperstone processes e-wallets Up to 1 business day and cards Up to 2 business days, charges on international bank wires and does not pay out to crypto, so a crypto depositor there needs a second withdrawal route. See Tickmill withdrawals and Pepperstone withdrawals.
Markets
Winner: Pepperstone. Pepperstone lists 90 forex pairs and 1,100 share CFDs. Tickmill lists 62 forex pairs and 492 share CFDs, plus 15 crypto CFDs. Neither offers real shares.
For most forex traders the two lists overlap on everything that matters: the majors, the main crosses, gold and the large stock indices. The gap shows up in exotic currency pairs and in single-stock CFDs, where Pepperstone covers more companies. If you trade a specific share or emerging-market currency, check that it appears on the broker's instrument list before you open an account, because neither broker's headline count tells you whether one particular market is available.
Research and support
Winner: Pepperstone. Both publish news, daily analysis, an economic calendar and webinars, and neither offers Autochartist. Pepperstone's support runs 24/7; Tickmill's runs 24/5 (chatbot 24/7; phone Monday to Friday 7:00-16:00 GMT).
User ratings differ sharply. Pepperstone scores 4.2 on Trustpilot and Tickmill 2.2. Read Tickmill's Trustpilot rating for context before you decide.
Opening an account
Winner: tie. At Tickmill, onboarding and ID verification are automated and take minutes. At Pepperstone, the online application takes under 10 minutes and verification usually takes from a few hours to one business day. See how to open a Tickmill account and how to open a Pepperstone account.
Which should you choose?
- High-volume MetaTrader scalpers: Tickmill, for the lower commission, if you accept that its average spread is unpublished.
- Traders who want a known all-in cost: Pepperstone.
- cTrader users and Australian traders: Pepperstone.
- South African traders: Tickmill, which holds an FSCA license.
- Traders who want crypto withdrawals: Tickmill.
- Newer traders: Pepperstone, for its lower minimum deposit, weekend support and stronger user ratings.
Raw-spread accounts at both brokers are leveraged CFD products, and losses can exceed what you plan for when markets move fast. Test either broker on a demo account before committing real money.
Read the full Pepperstone review and Tickmill review, see Tickmill's minimum deposit, or browse all comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Is Tickmill cheaper than Pepperstone?
Tickmill charges a lower commission per lot on its MetaTrader raw account. But Tickmill publishes no average spreads, so the full cost per trade cannot be compared. Pepperstone publishes its averages.
Is Tickmill regulated like Pepperstone?
Both have FCA and CySEC entities with negative balance protection. Pepperstone adds ASIC, BaFin and other licenses. Tickmill has an FSCA license in South Africa. Both serve rest-of-world clients offshore.
Why is Tickmill's Trustpilot score low?
Tickmill's Trustpilot score is well below Pepperstone's. Review scores reflect the experiences of people who chose to post, so read recent reviews to see which issues come up.
Does Tickmill offer cTrader?
No. Tickmill offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView and its own Tickmill Trader app. Pepperstone offers those platforms plus cTrader.
Which processes withdrawals faster?
Both process card and e-wallet withdrawals quickly. Tickmill lists most of its methods within one working day and lets you withdraw to crypto, which Pepperstone does not.