Stake vs CommSec
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
Stake and CommSec are two of the most used share platforms in Australia. Stake is the low-cost app, with flat brokerage of 3 AUD on ASX trades and 3 USD on US trades and fractional US shares. CommSec is the big bank broker, owned by the Commonwealth Bank, with more markets, ASX options, margin lending, CommSec Pocket for ETFs and interest on its settlement account. Pick Stake for low-cost ASX and US investing; pick CommSec for options, margin or many international markets.
- Minimum deposit
- AUD 0
- AUD 0
- Regulators
- ASIC, SEC/FINRA
- ASIC
- Platforms
- Stake mobile app, Stake web platform
- CommSec website, CommSec app, CommSec Pocket app
- Funding methods
- 4
- 1
- Trustpilot
- 2.5 / 5
- 1.6 / 5
- Founded
- 2017
- 1995
- Headquarters
- Sydney, New South Wales, Australia
- —
Safety
Winner: CommSec, narrowly. CommSec is Commonwealth Securities Limited, licensed by ASIC under AFSL 238814. CommSec is a wholly owned, non-guaranteed subsidiary of the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX: CBA).
Stake operates under ASIC as an authorized representative: AFSL 548196 (authorized representative no. 1241398). Its US shares are held by DriveWealth, registered as CRD 165429, with SIPC cover up to USD 500,000 including USD 250,000 cash. Stake is privately held.
Costs
Winner: Stake. US shares: Stake USD 3 per trade up to USD 30,000, then 0.01%. CommSec USD 5 or 0.12%, whichever is greater (International Shares account); USD 9.95 or 0.20% on the Plus account.
ASX shares and ETFs: Stake USD 3 per US ETF trade and AUD 3 per ASX ETF trade up to 30,000, then 0.01%. CommSec ASX ETFs at share brokerage: AUD 5 up to AUD 1,000, AUD 10 to AUD 3,000, AUD 19.95 to AUD 10,000, AUD 29.95 to AUD 25,000, then 0.12%. AUD 0 on CommSec Pocket until 31 March 2027.
Currency: Stake 0.55% (55 basis points) on transfers between AUD and USD; no FX fee per trade. CommSec 0.55% per currency conversion. Stake's card deposits cost extra: Bank transfer free; debit card, Apple Pay and Google Pay 0.5%; credit card 2.5%.
Accounts and markets
Winner: CommSec. CommSec trades on 13 exchanges and offers ASX options, margin lending and SMSF accounts. Its settlement account pays interest: Commonwealth Direct Investment Account (settlement account) from 13 November 2026: 0.85% under AUD 50,000, 1.60% to AUD 249,999, 2.25% to AUD 999,999 and 2.95% from AUD 1 million; SMSF accounts 2.40% to 3.25%. Stake offers SMSF (via Stake Super administration), but no options or margin.
Platforms
Winner: tie. Stake offers Stake mobile app, Stake web platform, with fractional US shares from USD 10 (US shares only). CommSec offers CommSec website, CommSec app, CommSec Pocket app. CommSec offers phone support. Hours: Monday to Friday 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. and 7 days 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. Sydney time on separate lines; international trading support 24 hours on US trading days.
Who each suits
Stake suits Australian and New Zealand investors who buy ASX and US shares and want a low flat fee. CommSec suits Commonwealth Bank customers, options traders, margin borrowers and investors who want shares in the UK, Europe or Asia.
Which should you choose?
- Lowest ASX and US fees: Stake.
- Fractional US shares: Stake.
- Options and margin lending: CommSec.
- International markets beyond the US: CommSec.
- Commonwealth Bank customers: CommSec.
Investing involves risk, and the value of your investments can fall. Read the full Stake review and CommSec review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Is Stake or CommSec cheaper?
Stake, for most investors. It charges a flat 3 AUD per trade on ASX shares (3 USD on US shares) for trades up to 30,000 in that currency, while CommSec's standard ASX brokerage starts at 5 AUD and rises with trade size, and its US trades cost at least 5 USD.
Which has lower currency fees?
They charge the same 0.55% on currency conversion. Stake charges it when you move money between AUD and USD, not on each trade.
Can I trade options?
CommSec offers ASX exchange-traded options and margin lending. Stake offers neither.
Which offers more markets?
CommSec, with international trading on many exchanges, including the UK and Europe. Stake covers the ASX and US markets.
Are they safe?
Both are licensed by ASIC. CommSec is owned by the Commonwealth Bank. Stake's US shares are held by DriveWealth, a US broker covered by SIPC.