Skip to content
Menu

The5ers vs Topstep

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Challenge models and prices
  2. Profit targets and drawdown
  3. Trading rules
  4. Payouts and profit split
  5. Platforms
  6. Scaling
  7. Inactivity and support
  8. Reputation
  9. Forex and CFD programs
  10. Which should you choose?

The5ers and Topstep mostly serve different traders. The5ers is an Israeli firm built around forex and CFD programs that scale one account over time, with a small futures range added. Topstep is a Chicago futures-only firm with one product, the Trading Combine, on its own platform. Pick The5ers if you trade forex or CFDs, want to scale into the millions, or want a cheap futures plan with a fee refund. Pick Topstep if you day-trade US futures and want larger futures accounts, named platforms and a very long payout record. We compare the futures plans directly, then the terms that apply to both.

Max profit split
100%
90%
Platforms
MetaTrader 5
Proprietary platform
Trustpilot
4.7 / 5
3.7 / 5
Founded
2016
2012
Headquarters
Raanana, Israel
Chicago, Illinois, United States

Challenge models and prices

Winner: no clear winner on futures price. At 50,000 The5ers' Futures Day Trade costs 100 USD. Topstep's Combine costs 49 USD a month on the Standard path, plus an activation fee, or 95 a month without one. The5ers does not say whether its futures fee is one-time or monthly, so there is no price winner.

The5ers sets these terms for its 25,000 plan: Futures evaluation. Consistency rule 40% per position. Contract size 2 mini or 20 micro. No activation fee. Fee refunded on the third payout. Pro stage: 4% profit target for payout, scaling to USD 500,000. Positions must be closed 10 minutes before the market close. A refund on the third payout is something Topstep does not offer. Topstep sells larger accounts, up to 150,000 at 199 a month on the Standard path; The5ers' futures stop at 50,000.

For CFD traders only The5ers applies. Its High Stakes 2-step costs 405 for 100,000. See The5ers programs and the Topstep Trading Combine.

Profit targets and drawdown

Winner: tie. At 50,000 the two ask for the same amounts in different units. The5ers sets a 6% target and a 4% end-of-day trailing drawdown, while Topstep sets a $3,000 target and a drawdown of $2,000, set at the end of each day from the account balance high. On a 50,000 account those match.

Topstep has no daily limit by default. It is quick to complete. Minimum trading days: Can be passed in 2 days. Contract limits at 50,000 are 5 minis / 50 micros at Topstep; The5ers' contract limit for its 25,000 plan is in the terms quoted above. On the CFD side, The5ers' High Stakes splits its target across two steps with no time limit.

Trading rules

Winner: The5ers, narrowly. Both firms' day-trading futures plans close positions daily. Topstep closes them in the afternoon. Not allowed. Positions must be flat by 3:10 PM CT each weekday; trading resumes at 5:00 PM CT. Positions cannot be carried from one session to the next. The5ers' Day Trade plan requires positions to be closed ten minutes before the market close, and its Swing plan allows a small overnight position, which Topstep never does.

Consistency differs in kind. The5ers caps each position on futures. None stated for CFD programs. Futures Day Trade: 40% per position. Topstep caps the best day. Trading Combine: best day at most 55% of the profit target, otherwise the target increases. Express Funded Account Consistency path: best day within 40% of total profit.

Topstep allows copying between your own Combine and Express accounts with its built-in copier. The5ers bans copy trading. Trade coordination or copy trading with other traders or accounts is prohibited. Each active account must have a different strategy. Topstep's device rule is strict. VPNs, proxies, TOR and other location or identity masking services are prohibited. Orders must originate from the trader's personal device; a VPS or remote server may not place or relay orders. See The5ers rules and Topstep rules.

Payouts and profit split

Winner: Topstep on futures payout terms; The5ers on top CFD split. Topstep pays 90% on futures. The5ers' maximum, 100%, is reached through CFD scaling; The5ers publishes no futures split.

Topstep's minimum is USD 125; The5ers' is USD 150 after the profit split. The5ers charges a percentage fee on most methods; Topstep charges a flat fee on ACH and wires but pays US traders instantly through Aeropay. Topstep states it has paid more than USD 1.5 billion; The5ers publishes no total. See The5ers payouts and Topstep payouts.

Platforms

Winner: Topstep for futures. Topstep trades on its own platform, Proprietary platform. The5ers' CFD accounts run on MetaTrader 5, and The5ers does not name its futures platform. Topstep publishes commission, USD 1.00 round turn commission plus exchange and NFA fees (ES total USD 3.78) on minis; The5ers does not publish its commissions.

Scaling

Winner: The5ers. The5ers scales on every target. High Stakes scales on every 10% target up to USD 500,000, with the payout ratio rising from 80% to 100% plus fixed payouts. Hyper Growth doubles the account on every 10% target up to USD 4,000,000. Bootcamp scales on every 5% target. Topstep scales position size instead. The Scaling Plan applies to the Express Funded Account and sets the maximum position size from the current account balance. It does not apply to the Live Funded Account, which uses Dynamic Live Risk Expansion. Its cap is Up to USD 150,000 buying power per account.

Inactivity and support

Winner: Topstep on support. The5ers expires idle accounts after a month. Accounts with no activity for more than 30 consecutive days expire. Topstep may close an idle funded account. An Express Funded Account with more than 30 days of inactivity may be closed. Topstep's support runs 24/7; The5ers' support channels were not published.

Reputation

Winner: The5ers. The5ers is rated 4.7 from 42,008 reviews. Topstep is rated 3.7 from 15,083 reviews, low for its size, with complaints about outages and terminations. Topstep has the longer history, having launched its evaluation in 2012; The5ers was founded in 2016.

Forex and CFD programs

Winner: The5ers, as the only option. Topstep offers no forex or CFDs. The5ers' Hyper Growth doubles the account on every target, from 98 for 10,000, and its Bootcamp starts from 22. Both run on MT5 with overnight and weekend holding allowed.

Which should you choose?

  • Forex and CFD traders: The5ers. Topstep has no CFDs.
  • Futures traders who want accounts above 50,000: Topstep.
  • Futures traders on a small budget who want a fee refund: The5ers Day Trade.
  • Futures traders who want to hold small positions overnight: The5ers Swing.
  • Traders who want to scale one account over years: The5ers.
  • US traders who want instant payouts: Topstep.

Read the full The5ers review and Topstep review, or see all prop firm comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

Does The5ers offer futures like Topstep?

Yes, a small range of Day Trade and Swing plans. Topstep is a futures specialist with larger accounts and a much longer futures record.

Which futures evaluation is cheaper?

Topstep's Standard path has the lower monthly price at the 50,000 size, plus an activation fee on passing. The5ers does not state whether its futures fee is one-time or monthly, so the total cost cannot be settled.

Which is better for forex traders?

The5ers. Topstep does not offer forex or CFDs.

Can I hold futures positions overnight?

Not at Topstep, and not on The5ers' Day Trade plan. The5ers' Swing plan allows a small overnight position.

Which has the better Trustpilot score?

The5ers, by a wide margin, on a larger number of reviews.