Tickmill vs Vantage
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
Tickmill and Vantage are both FCA-regulated raw-pricing brokers used by scalpers and algorithmic traders, with MetaTrader, TradingView, VPS hosting and copy trading. Tickmill adds a CySEC entity for the EU, private insurance on its offshore accounts, refunds on large wire deposit fees and no withdrawal fee of its own, but a weak Trustpilot score. Vantage adds an ASIC entity, its own app, a Pro ECN account with a lower commission for large balances, a cent account, spread betting in the UK, free same-day card and e-wallet payouts and much better reviews. Pick Tickmill for EU access and offshore insurance. Pick Vantage for Australia, large accounts and stronger reviews. Both offer demo accounts for testing first.
- Minimum deposit
- USD 100
- USD 50
- Max leverage
- 1:1000 (FSCA)
- 1:30 (ASIC)
- EUR/USD average spread
- 1.6 pips (Classic)
- 1.4 pips (Standard STP)
- Regulators
- FSA, FCA, CySEC, FSCA, DFSA
- FSC, VFSC, FSCA, ASIC, FCA, CIMA
- Platforms
- MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, Proprietary platform
- MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, Proprietary platform
- Funding methods
- 12
- 16
- Trustpilot
- 2.2 / 5
- 4.4 / 5
- Founded
- 2014
- 2009
- Headquarters
- Mahe, Seychelles
- Sydney, Australia
Safety and regulation
Winner: tie. Both serve UK clients under the FCA with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000: Tickmill under 717270 and Vantage under FRN 590299. Tickmill adds CySEC license 278/15 for the EU; Vantage adds ASIC license AFSL 428901 for Australia.
Offshore, Tickmill's Seychelles entity is covered by Excess of Loss insurance policy up to EUR 1,000,000, a protection Vantage's offshore entities in Vanuatu, the Cayman Islands, Mauritius and South Africa do not state. Both state negative balance protection on all their entities.
Tickmill is privately owned and not publicly traded. It is part of the Tickmill Group, co-founded by Ingmar Mattus. Vantage is privately owned and not publicly traded.Costs
No winner on standard raw accounts; Vantage for large balances. Neither publishes an average EUR/USD spread. Tickmill's Raw charges 6 USD per round turn and its TradingView Raw 7; Vantage's Raw ECN charges 6. Vantage's Pro ECN cuts commission to 3 for balances of 10,000 USD.
Spread-only accounts list minimums of 1.6 pips at Tickmill and 1.4 at Vantage, which do not show typical costs.
Non-trading fees: Tickmill's terms are None from Tickmill; intermediary banks or e-wallets may charge and None; bank fees up to USD 100 are refunded on wire deposits of USD 5,000 or more. Vantage charges None, except USD 20 for bank wire withdrawals; Neteller and Skrill charge their own fees. Vantage charges no inactivity fee; Tickmill's is not published. See Tickmill fees and Vantage fees.
Accounts
Winner: Vantage. Vantage's minimum is 50 USD, against 100 USD at Tickmill. Vantage offers four accounts, including a cent account and Pro ECN, plus UK spread betting. Tickmill offers Classic, Raw and TradingView Raw, and professional leverage up to 1:500 for clients who qualify. Both offer swap-free accounts.
Platforms
Tie. Both offer MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView and their own platforms, with VPS hosting, copy trading and scalping allowed. Tickmill adds an API; Vantage names its copy service, Vantage Copy Trading.
Funding
Winner: Vantage, narrowly. At Vantage, cards, Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal, Skrill, Neteller and regional methods are paid Up to 24 hours. At Tickmill, cards, Skrill, Neteller, PayPal, Trustly and Przelewy24 are paid Within 1 working day. Bank transfers take 1-3 working days at Tickmill, free, and 3-7 business days at Vantage for USD 20. Tickmill wins on bank transfers; Vantage on the range of methods.
Markets
Tie. Tickmill lists 62 forex pairs, 19 indices, about 492 share CFDs, 25 ETFs and 15 crypto CFDs. Vantage offers about 1,000 instruments, including 33 indices, about 800 share CFDs and 57 ETFs. Vantage has more shares and ETFs; Tickmill publishes a forex pair count Vantage does not.
Research and support
Winner: Vantage. Both publish news, an economic calendar, daily analysis and webinars. Vantage adds Trading Central and courses. Vantage offers Live chat 24/7; phone 24/5; Tickmill offers 24/5 (chatbot 24/7; phone Monday to Friday 7:00-16:00 GMT). Trustpilot strongly favors Vantage, rated 4.4 from 16,133 reviews, against 2.2 from 1,205 for Tickmill.
Offshore protection compared
For traders outside the UK, EU and Australia, both brokers use offshore entities with high leverage, and the protections differ. Tickmill's Seychelles entity carries a private insurance policy with a high limit, which can pay out if the broker fails. Vantage's offshore entities state negative balance protection and segregated funds but no insurance or compensation scheme. Insurance is a contract with its own conditions, not a statutory scheme, so read the terms, but it is still an extra layer Vantage does not state.
The review gap
Vantage's Trustpilot score is far higher than Tickmill's, from many more reviews. That does not prove one is safer, but it does suggest clients have had more positive experiences with Vantage's service. If you lean toward Tickmill for its EU entity or offshore insurance, read its most recent reviews to see whether complaints concern withdrawals, verification or something less serious, and check whether the broker responds to them.
TradingView at each broker
Both brokers connect live accounts to TradingView, but in different ways. Tickmill runs a separate TradingView Raw account, held in US dollars and traded through TradingView and Tickmill's own platform, at a slightly higher commission than its MetaTrader Raw account. Vantage offers TradingView as one of the platforms on its standard accounts. If you chart and trade in TradingView, check which account types and currencies each broker supports there, and whether your Expert Advisors or MetaTrader tools still work alongside it, before you choose.
UK traders and spread betting
UK clients at both brokers join FCA entities with the same retail leverage limits and FSCS cover. Vantage also lists spread betting, priced in pounds per point; under current UK rules, spread betting profits are generally free of capital gains tax, though your situation may differ. Tickmill does not mention spread betting, so UK clients trade CFDs. For a UK trader who expects to be profitable, that tax treatment can be worth more than any difference in commission.
Which should you choose?
- EU traders: Tickmill, through its CySEC entity.
- Australian traders: Vantage, through its ASIC entity.
- High-volume traders with large balances: Vantage's Pro ECN.
- International traders who value offshore insurance: Tickmill.
- Traders who weigh client reviews heavily: Vantage.
Most retail CFD accounts lose money. Read the full Tickmill review and Vantage review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Is Tickmill or Vantage cheaper?
Neither publishes an average EUR/USD spread. Their standard raw accounts charge the same commission, and Vantage's Pro ECN account charges less for large balances. Tickmill's TradingView Raw account charges slightly more than its MetaTrader Raw account.
Which is better regulated?
Both have FCA entities. Tickmill adds CySEC for the EU and private insurance on its offshore entity; Vantage adds ASIC for Australia. Both state negative balance protection.
Which has better reviews?
Vantage, by a wide margin on Trustpilot. Read recent reviews of both before opening an account.
Does Vantage charge to withdraw?
Only on bank wire withdrawals. Cards and e-wallets are free. Tickmill charges no withdrawal fee of its own.
Do both offer TradingView?
Yes. Tickmill has a dedicated TradingView Raw account, and Vantage offers TradingView alongside MetaTrader and its own app.