Skip to content
Menu

Tickmill vs XM

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Safety and regulation
  2. Costs
  3. Accounts
  4. Platforms
  5. Funding
  6. Markets
  7. Research and support
  8. Raw accounts in practice
  9. Funding in different currencies
  10. Checking reviews before you deposit
  11. Which should you choose?

Tickmill and XM are both European-rooted MetaTrader brokers with CySEC entities and offshore arms, but they target different traders. Tickmill is a raw-pricing broker with an FCA entity, low commissions on its Raw and TradingView Raw accounts, refunds on large wire fees and fast card and e-wallet withdrawals. XM is a broad global broker with a token minimum deposit, many regional entities, real shares, courses and support around the clock, but no UK entity and an inactivity fee after a short pause. Pick Tickmill for UK regulation and low raw commissions. Pick XM for a very small start, a wide market list and beginner support. Both offer demo accounts, swap-free accounts and MetaTrader 4 and 5, so switching between them later is straightforward.

XM
4.6 / 5
Visit
Minimum deposit
USD 100
USD 5
Max leverage
1:1000 (FSCA)
1:1000 (FSC Belize)
EUR/USD average spread
1.6 pips (Classic)
1.6 pips (Standard)
Regulators
FSA, FCA, CySEC, FSCA, DFSA
CySEC, FSC Belize, FSC, FSA, BVI FSC, FSCA, DFSA, UAE CMA, CMA
Platforms
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, Proprietary platform
MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform
Funding methods
12
9
Trustpilot
2.2 / 5
Not shown
Founded
2014
2009
Headquarters
Mahe, Seychelles
Limassol, Cyprus

Safety and regulation

Winner: Tickmill. Tickmill UK Ltd holds FCA license 717270 with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000, and Tickmill Europe holds CySEC license 278/15. International clients sign with Tickmill Ltd in the Seychelles, covered by Excess of Loss insurance policy up to EUR 1,000,000. It also has FSCA and DFSA entities.

XM's EU entity holds CySEC license 120/10, with compensation up to EUR 20,000, and it has a DFSA entity. International clients sign with XM Global in Belize at up to 1:1000. XM has no UK entity.

Both state negative balance protection on their main entities. Tickmill's FCA entity and the private insurance on its offshore entity give it the edge. Tickmill is privately owned and not publicly traded. It is part of the Tickmill Group, co-founded by Ingmar Mattus. XM is privately owned by Trading Point Group; XM is a trading name of Trading Point Holdings Ltd. The group is controlled by co-founder Costas Cleanthous.

Costs

Winner: Tickmill on raw commission. Neither broker publishes an average EUR/USD spread. Tickmill's Raw account charges 6 USD per round turn; XM's Zero charges 7 USD. On spread-only accounts, Tickmill's Classic and XM's Standard both list spreads from 1.6 and 1.6 pips respectively, while XM's Ultra Low lists 0.8. Minimum spreads do not show typical costs.

XM charges USD 10 per month after 90 days without trading, deposits or withdrawals. Tickmill's inactivity terms are not published. On funding, Tickmill's terms are: None; bank fees up to USD 100 are refunded on wire deposits of USD 5,000 or more. XM charges None; XM covers payment fees, except bank wires under USD 200. Tickmill's conversion terms are None from Tickmill; payments are processed in EUR, GBP and USD and the bank or e-wallet converts other currencies at its own rate. See Tickmill fees and XM fees.

Accounts

Winner: XM. XM's minimum is 5 USD on Standard, Ultra Low and Zero, against 100 USD at Tickmill. XM also offers a Shares account for real stocks. Both offer swap-free accounts. Tickmill's professional clients can use leverage up to 1:500 at its UK and EU entities.

Platforms

Winner: Tickmill, narrowly. Tickmill offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, Proprietary platform, with a dedicated TradingView Raw account. XM offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform, with TradingView integration. Both list copy trading and VPS hosting. Tickmill adds an API and allows scalping; XM does not publish its scalping policy.

Funding

Winner: Tickmill for cards; XM for e-wallets. At Tickmill, card, Skrill, Neteller, PayPal, Trustly and Przelewy24 withdrawals are paid Within 1 working day, and bank transfers 1-3 working days. At XM, Skrill, Neteller and Google Pay are Instant, and cards and bank transfers 2-5 business days. Tickmill accepts PayPal; XM accepts M-Pesa and crypto.

Markets

Winner: XM. XM offers about 1,400 instruments, including about 1,200 share CFDs and real shares. Tickmill lists 62 forex pairs, 19 indices, about 492 share CFDs, 25 ETFs and 15 crypto CFDs; it does not publish a total.

Research and support

Winner: XM. Both publish news, an economic calendar, daily analysis and webinars. XM adds Trading Central and courses. XM answers 24/7; Tickmill offers 24/5 (chatbot 24/7; phone Monday to Friday 7:00-16:00 GMT). Tickmill scores 2.2 on Trustpilot from 1,205 reviews; XM's score is not published.

Raw accounts in practice

Tickmill is built around raw pricing: its Raw and TradingView Raw accounts pass through interbank spreads and add a fixed commission, which suits scalpers and algorithmic traders who measure costs per lot. XM's Zero account works the same way, at a slightly higher commission. The difference per lot is small, but it adds up for a trader opening many positions a day. A trader placing a few trades a week will notice it far less than the difference in support hours or account minimums.

Funding in different currencies

Tickmill processes payments in a few major currencies and charges no conversion fee itself, though payment providers may. XM covers payment fees except on small bank wires. If your bank account is in a currency neither broker uses for your account, conversion by your bank can cost more than any broker fee, so check which account currencies each offers before you deposit. Holding the account in the same currency as your bank avoids a conversion on every deposit and withdrawal.

Checking reviews before you deposit

Tickmill's strong licenses sit beside a low Trustpilot score, and XM has no Trustpilot score shown. Review scores are a rough signal: they can reflect a run of complaints about withdrawals or verification, or simply a small number of reviews. Read the most recent ones, look at whether the broker responds, and search the regulator's register for warnings. A UK or EU entity also gives you access to an official complaints route, such as the Financial Ombudsman Service in the UK or the Cyprus Financial Ombudsman, which offshore entities do not.

Which should you choose?

  • UK traders: Tickmill, since XM has no FCA entity.
  • Raw-account scalpers: Tickmill, for its lower commission.
  • Beginners starting with a small deposit: XM.
  • Share CFD traders and real-share investors: XM.
  • Traders who want support at any hour: XM.

Most retail CFD accounts lose money. Read the full Tickmill review and XM review, or see all broker comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

Is Tickmill cheaper than XM?

On raw accounts, Tickmill's commission is a little lower than XM's. Neither publishes an average EUR/USD spread, so spread-only costs cannot be ranked. XM charges an inactivity fee after a short break; Tickmill's inactivity terms are not published.

Which is better regulated?

Tickmill has an FCA entity for UK clients and XM does not. Both have CySEC entities in the EU and offshore entities elsewhere, and both have a presence in Dubai.

What is the minimum deposit?

XM's minimum is a token amount on its main accounts. Tickmill asks for a modest minimum on all accounts.

Which has better reviews?

Tickmill's Trustpilot score is low, while XM has no Trustpilot score shown, so a direct comparison is not possible. Read recent reviews before opening an account at either.

Do both offer copy trading?

Yes, both list copy trading, though neither names the services.