Vanguard vs Fidelity
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
Vanguard and Fidelity are both very large US brokers with free online stock and ETF trades, no minimum deposit and a full range of IRAs. Vanguard is built around its own index funds and ETFs and suits buy-and-hold investors who want to own them directly. Fidelity has the better platforms, fractional shares in any US stock, international trading, Level 2 data and no account fee at all. Pick Vanguard if you only want simple index investing; pick Fidelity for everything else.
- Minimum deposit
- USD 0
- USD 0
- Regulators
- SEC/FINRA
- SEC/FINRA
- Platforms
- Vanguard website, Vanguard mobile app
- Fidelity.com, Fidelity mobile app, Active Trader Pro
- Funding methods
- 2
- 1
- Trustpilot
- 1.3 / 5
- 1.3 / 5
- Founded
- 1975
- 1946
- Headquarters
- Malvern, Pennsylvania, United States
- Boston, Massachusetts, United States
Safety
Tie. Vanguard Marketing Corporation is registered with the SEC and FINRA as CRD 7452, with SIPC cover up to USD 500,000 including USD 250,000 cash. Vanguard is owned by its US-domiciled funds, which are in turn owned by their shareholders.
Fidelity Brokerage Services is registered as CRD 7784, with SIPC cover up to USD 500,000 including USD 250,000 cash. Both have run for decades: Vanguard since 1975 and Fidelity since 1946.
Costs
Winner: Fidelity, narrowly. Stock trades cost the same online. Vanguard charges more by phone. USD 0 online; USD 25 broker-assisted for accounts under USD 1 million. A securities transaction fee applies on sales. Fidelity charges nothing online, including penny stocks. USD 0 online for US equities, including OTC and penny stocks.
The differences are in account and options fees. Vanguard charges a USD 25 annual account service fee, waived with e-delivery of statements or USD 1 million in qualifying assets. Fidelity's account fee: None. Options at Vanguard cost USD 1 per contract under USD 1 million; 25 free trades a year from USD 1 million and 100 from USD 5 million, then USD 1 per contract. At Fidelity: USD 0 commission plus USD 0.65 per contract; buy-to-close orders at USD 0.65 or less are free.
Moving out also costs more at Vanguard: Free by electronic bank transfer (ACH); USD 10 per wire, waived for retirement accounts and USD 1 million in qualifying assets. USD 100 to close an account or transfer it out in full.
Accounts
Tie. Vanguard offers Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, Rollover IRA, SEP-IRA, Inherited IRA, 529 plan, UGMA/UTMA custodial. Fidelity offers Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, Rollover IRA, SEP-IRA, SIMPLE IRA, Inherited IRA, 529 plan, Custodial account, Youth Account. Both offer recurring investing and dividend reinvestment. At Vanguard, cash waits in a money market fund. Uninvested cash sits in the Vanguard Federal Money Market Fund (VMFXX) settlement fund, with a 7-day SEC yield of about 3.6%.
Platforms
Winner: Fidelity. Vanguard offers Vanguard website, Vanguard mobile app. Fractional buying is limited, from USD 1 (Vanguard ETFs only; no fractional shares in other stocks). Fidelity offers Fidelity.com, Fidelity mobile app, Active Trader Pro, fractional shares from USD 1, extended hours and Level 2 data. Fidelity also offers support 24 hours a day, 7 days a week; Vanguard's phone hours are Phone Monday to Friday, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Eastern time.
Who each suits
Vanguard suits long-term investors who mainly hold Vanguard funds and ETFs and rarely trade. Fidelity suits almost everyone else: beginners who want fractional shares, active investors who want better tools, families who want a Youth Account, and investors who want foreign shares.
Which should you choose?
- Vanguard funds held directly: Vanguard.
- Lowest ongoing fees: Fidelity, with no account fee.
- Fractional shares in any stock: Fidelity.
- Options traders: Fidelity.
- Active trading tools: Fidelity.
Investing involves risk, and the value of your investments can fall. Read the full Vanguard review and Fidelity review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Is Vanguard or Fidelity cheaper?
Both charge nothing for online US stock and ETF trades. Fidelity has no account fee at all, while Vanguard charges a small annual service fee unless you choose electronic statements. Fidelity's options fee is lower for most investors.
Which is better for index funds and ETFs?
Vanguard is the home of its own low-cost index funds and ETFs, and buying them there is simple. Fidelity sells Vanguard ETFs commission-free too, and has its own zero-fee index funds.
Which has better platforms?
Fidelity. It offers Active Trader Pro, Level 2 data and fractional shares in any US stock. Vanguard's website and app are basic and fractional buying covers Vanguard ETFs only.
Which pays more on cash?
Vanguard sweeps uninvested cash into a federal money market fund, which pays a market rate. Fidelity also uses money market sweep options; check the current rate on its site.
Can non-US residents open an account?
No. Both accept US residents only.