XM vs XTB
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
XM and XTB are both large brokers with very low minimum deposits and strong education, but they serve different regions and styles. XTB is a listed European broker whose xStation platform holds CFDs, real stocks and ETFs in one account, with a published average spread. XM is a MetaTrader broker that serves the EU from Cyprus and most other clients offshore, with local payment methods, raw-pricing and Islamic accounts and support around the clock. Pick XTB if you live in Europe and want to trade and invest. Pick XM for MetaTrader and access in emerging markets.
- Minimum deposit
- USD 5
- USD 0
- Max leverage
- 1:1000 (FSC Belize)
- 1:500 (CMF)
- EUR/USD average spread
- 1.6 pips (Standard)
- 1.06 pips (Standard)
- Regulators
- CySEC, FSC Belize, FSC, FSA, BVI FSC, FSCA, DFSA, UAE CMA, CMA
- KNF, FCA, CySEC, DFSA, UAE CMA, CMF, BAPPEBTI, FSC Belize
- Platforms
- MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Proprietary platform
- Proprietary platform
- Funding methods
- 9
- 5
- Trustpilot
- Not shown
- 3.8 / 5
- Founded
- 2009
- 2004
- Headquarters
- Limassol, Cyprus
- Warsaw, Poland
Safety and regulation
Split: XTB in Europe, XM offshore. XTB serves UK clients under FCA license FRN 522157, with FSCS cover up to GBP 85,000, and most EU clients from Poland with the KDPW investor compensation scheme up to EUR 20,100. It is listed in Warsaw and publishes audited results. XM has no UK entity and is privately owned.
Both have CySEC companies covered by the Investor Compensation Fund up to EUR 20,000, and both have DFSA companies in Dubai. XM adds FSCA and Kenyan licenses; XTB adds onshore UAE, Chile and Indonesia.
Outside those regions, both use Belize, which makes a fair comparison. XM Global offers negative balance protection, with leverage up to 1:1000. XTB International allows up to 1:500 and offers no negative balance protection, so an account can end up owing money after a gap. Neither has a compensation scheme there. Trustpilot withholds XM's rating, citing a guidelines breach; XTB is rated 3.8.
Costs
No winner on spreads. On spread-only accounts, the like-for-like test, XTB publishes a group average EUR/USD spread of 1.06 pips, an all-in cost of 10.6 USD per standard lot round trip. XM publishes only minimums, such as 0.8 pips on Ultra Low, so the two cannot be ranked.
XM also offers a raw-pricing Zero account with commission of 7 USD per lot round trip, but no published average spread; XTB has no raw account. XTB's separate advantage is investing: real stocks and ETFs are commission-free up to a monthly turnover limit. To compare forex costs, watch XM's live spreads on a demo at the times you trade and set them against XTB's published figure.
Non-trading fees: split. XM covers payment fees except small bank wires, but charges USD 10 per month after 90 days without trading, deposits or withdrawals. XTB's inactivity fee starts later, EUR 10 per month if no buy or sell transaction has been made within 365 days, but it charges Free above USD 50; USD 30 below USD 50, percentages on Skrill and Neteller deposits, and a conversion fee of 0.5%. XM publishes no conversion fee and offers more base currencies.
More detail: XM fees and XTB fees
Accounts
Split. Both are cheap to open: XTB has no minimum, 0 USD, and XM's main accounts need 5 USD. XTB's single account holds CFDs, real stocks and ETFs together.
XM offers a choice of pricing model, Islamic accounts and micro lots, plus a separate Shares account in selected regions from 10,000 USD. XTB offers swap-free status only in some countries and for limited periods. See XM account types and XTB account types.
Platforms
Winner: XM. It offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 and its own XM App, with Expert Advisors and a free VPS for XM Global clients who meet the conditions. It offers copy trading, though it does not name providers.
XTB runs only on xStation, which has sentiment data, trading statistics and investing built in, and some of the strongest app ratings in the market. But it has no MetaTrader, no VPS, no API, no copy trading and no automated trading. Manual traders who also invest may prefer it; anyone using Expert Advisors needs XM.
At XTB, check which order ticket you are using: a real share purchase and a CFD on the same share look similar but carry very different risks. A real share has no leverage or overnight funding, and the most you can lose is what you paid; a CFD can be closed out on margin and, at XTB's offshore entities, can lose more than your deposit. XM's Shares account avoids that confusion by keeping real shares in a separate account with no forex trading.
Funding
Winner: XM. XM covers payment fees on most methods and offers local options such as M-Pesa. Skrill and Neteller withdrawals take Instant, and crypto withdrawals Instant to 24 hours. Card withdrawals take 2-5 business days.
XTB processes bank withdrawals Same or next business day, which is quick, but cards, Skrill and Neteller work for deposits only, so every withdrawal goes to a bank account, and small ones carry a fee.
Markets
Winner: XTB. It lists roughly 12,200 instruments, including 71 forex pairs, 32 commodities, about 2,251 share CFDs and around 2,400 ETFs, plus real stocks in the main account. XM lists around 1,400, with 20 commodities and about 1,200 share CFDs.
XM publishes an index count of 21; XTB does not publish one. XTB publishes 54 crypto CFDs; XM gives no single count.
Research and support
Tie on research; XM on support. Both publish news, daily analysis, an economic calendar and webinars, and both offer structured courses. XM adds Trading Central; XTB adds an in-house analyst team and sentiment tools in xStation. XTB's demos are time-limited; XM does not state whether its demo expires.
XM answers 24/7, in one of the longest language lists in the market. XTB answers 24/5. Both offer live chat, email and phone.
Which should you choose?
- UK and EU traders who also invest: XTB, for its FCA entity and real stocks in one account.
- MetaTrader users and algorithmic traders: XM.
- Traders in Africa and Asia who rely on local payments: XM.
- Clients outside Europe who want negative balance protection: XM, though keep leverage low.
- Traders who need Islamic accounts: XM.
- Traders who want MetaTrader with an FCA entity and published averages: neither offers all three. Pepperstone is a third option (see how it compares with XM).
High leverage magnifies losses as fast as gains. Read the full XM review and XTB review, or see all broker comparisons.
Frequently asked questions
Is XTB cheaper than XM?
Their spreads cannot be ranked, because XM publishes only minimums while XTB publishes an average. Their non-trading fees differ. XM covers most payment fees but charges an inactivity fee quickly, while XTB's inactivity fee starts later but it charges for small withdrawals and some deposits.
Which is safer, XM or XTB?
In the UK and EU, XTB, which has an FCA entity, a Polish license with investor compensation and a stock-exchange listing. Outside Europe, XM's main offshore company offers negative balance protection and XTB's does not.
Can I use MetaTrader at XTB?
No. XTB runs only on xStation and does not support automated trading. XM offers MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 and its own app.
Can I buy real stocks at both?
Yes, in different ways. XTB holds real stocks and ETFs in its main account. XM offers a separate Shares account in selected regions, with a higher minimum deposit.
Which is better for traders in Africa and Asia?
XM, for most. It offers local payment methods such as M-Pesa, support around the clock in many languages and local licenses in South Africa and Kenya.