Reading MQL5 Signals Track Records
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated · How we make money
On this page
MQL5 Signals makes no win rate claim of its own. It is a marketplace, and each signal shows statistics collected from the provider's live trading account. The track record is verified in that sense: demo, contest and cent accounts are not allowed. The statistics are not audited by an outside firm, and quality varies widely. You can check any signal on the platform itself. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
Track record
| Claimed win rate | No platform-wide win rate published; each signal page shows its own statistics (provider's claim) |
|---|---|
| Independently verified | Yes |
What the statistics are
MetaQuotes collects trading data directly from each provider's live account through MetaTrader. A signal page usually shows growth, balance and equity charts, drawdown, trade history, trading activity, and the number of subscribers. Because the data comes from the account, a provider cannot type in results. If falsified results are found, subscription funds are returned to buyers under the service rules.
What they can still hide
Live data is not the same as a safe strategy. Put directly, smooth growth curves can hide martingale or grid risk; compare equity with balance.
- Balance counts only closed trades.
- Equity includes open trades at current prices.
A strategy that never closes a losing trade, or keeps adding to it, can show a steadily rising balance while equity sinks underneath. When the market finally moves far enough, the account can lose most of its value in one go.
How to read a signal's record
Compare equity with balance. If the equity line regularly dips far below the balance line, losing positions are being held open. That is the most common warning sign on the marketplace.
Maximum drawdown. Look at the largest fall from peak to low, measured on equity. Ask whether you could sit through it without stopping copying at the worst moment.
Sample size and age. A few weeks of spectacular growth proves little. Look for at least a year and several hundred trades, across different market conditions.
Trade history. Scroll through losing trades. How long were they held? Were positions added as price moved against them? Are lot sizes rising after losses?
Leverage and deposit load. High margin use relative to equity means large swings.
Win rate with payoff. A very high win rate combined with rare, very large losses is the signature of grid and martingale systems.
Account type and your results
Statistics come from live accounts, which is stronger evidence than demo results. But they are the provider's account at the provider's broker. Results differ when your broker or trade server differs. Spreads, execution speed and swap rates all vary. A scalping strategy that profits on tight spreads can lose on wider ones.
Survivorship
An open marketplace shows the strategies that are still running. Many that blew up are no longer prominent. Rankings and "top" lists favor recent growth. Treat them as a starting point for checking, not as a recommendation.
Free versus paid signals
Free and paid signals are measured the same way, from live accounts. A paid signal is not more carefully checked than a free one, and the price says nothing about quality. Apply the same equity, drawdown and history tests to both.
Reviews of the site
mql5.com scores 1.2 on Trustpilot from 187 reviews. Those reviews cover the whole site, including its marketplace and services, not any one signal.
A checklist before subscribing
- Equity stays close to balance.
- Maximum drawdown is one you could accept.
- At least a year of live history.
- No signs of doubling up after losses.
- The provider's broker is similar to yours.
- Total cost, including a virtual server, makes sense at your account size. See MQL5 Signals pricing.
Related pages
Back to the full MQL5 Signals review.
Frequently asked questions
Does MQL5 Signals claim a win rate?
No. It is a marketplace, so it makes no win rate claim. Each signal shows its own statistics.
Are MQL5 Signals statistics real?
They are collected from providers' live accounts, and demo, contest and cent accounts are not allowed. They are not audited by an outside firm.
What is the most important statistic on an MQL5 signal?
The gap between equity and balance, and the maximum drawdown. A smooth balance line can hide large open losses.
Where can I check MQL5 signals?
On the public signal pages at mql5.com and inside MetaTrader.