No Dealing Desk
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
A no dealing desk (NDD) broker passes client orders to external liquidity providers instead of filling them from its own book through an internal dealing desk.
Worked example
Example: you place a market order to sell 1 lot of EUR/GBP. At an NDD broker, the order is sent electronically to an outside provider, such as a bank or a non-bank market maker, that is offering the best bid at that moment.
The broker earns money in one of two ways:
- Markup: it adds a small amount to the provider's spread, as in most STP accounts.
- Commission: it passes on the raw spread and charges a fee per lot, as in most ECN accounts.
Why it matters to a trader
Under NDD, the broker's income comes from your trading activity, not from your losses. That makes its incentives closer to yours. Execution is usually market-based, so there are no requotes, and prices reflect real interbank conditions.
The trade-offs are that spreads float, and slippage can happen both for and against you. Minimum trade sizes and costs can be higher than at some dealing desk brokers on very small accounts.
Common confusions
- NDD is a family, not a single model. STP and ECN are both NDD. They differ in how orders are matched.
- Marketing labels. Some brokers use NDD in marketing while internalizing part of their order flow. The order execution policy is the reliable guide.
- NDD versus A-book. An A-book broker passes risk to the market, which is the same idea seen from the broker's risk side.
Related terms
Where to practice this
Put this into practice on a demo account first, with no money at risk.
- Featured broker
Pepperstone4.7 / 5Visit
IC Markets4.9 / 5Visit
GO Markets4.8 / 5Visit
Frequently asked questions
Is NDD the same as ECN?
ECN is one type of NDD. STP is another. Both route orders to the market rather than through an internal dealing desk.
Does NDD mean no conflict of interest?
It reduces the most direct conflict, because the broker earns from spreads or commission rather than client losses. Routing and markup choices still matter.
Are NDD spreads fixed or variable?
They are variable, because they come from liquidity providers whose prices change with market conditions.
Do NDD brokers have slippage?
Yes. Orders fill at the next available market price, so slippage can occur, especially in fast markets.