Skip to content
Menu

B-Book

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Worked example
  2. Why it matters to a trader
  3. Common confusions
  4. Related terms

A B-book broker keeps client trades on its own books and acts as the counterparty, rather than passing the risk to outside liquidity providers.

ClientordersBrokerdecides whereeach order goesA-booksent to marketearns commissionor markupB-bookkept in-housebroker gains whenclient losesMany brokers run a hybrid of both books.
On the A-book a broker passes the trade to the market and earns a fee; on the B-book it keeps the trade and profits when the client loses.

Worked example

Example: a client sells 1 lot of EUR/USD. The broker does not send the trade anywhere. It simply records that it is now long 1 lot against the client.

  • If EUR/USD falls 30 pips and the client closes at a profit of 300 US dollars, the broker pays that 300 dollars from its own funds.
  • If EUR/USD rises 30 pips and the client closes at a loss, the broker keeps the 300 dollars.

With many clients on both sides, much of the exposure cancels out. The broker then hedges what remains if it is too large.

Why it matters to a trader

B-book execution is the model behind most market maker and dealing desk brokers. It allows features such as fixed spreads, small trade sizes and quick fills.

The central issue is the conflict of interest: the broker benefits when clients lose. That does not mean a B-book broker treats clients unfairly, but it makes regulation, transparent pricing and fair slippage handling more important. Check whether a broker is licensed by a strong regulator before trusting any model.

Common confusions

  • B-book versus scam. Bucket shops that refuse withdrawals are fraud, not a business model. A regulated B-book broker must pay winning clients.
  • Hybrid books. Most brokers run both books and move flow between them. See A-book.
  • Prop firms. Many prop firms run simulated accounts, which is a different arrangement from a broker's B-book.

Where to practice this

Put this into practice on a demo account first, with no money at risk.

Frequently asked questions

Is B-booking legal?

Yes. Regulated brokers can act as principal to client trades, provided they manage conflicts of interest and follow best execution rules.

Does a B-book broker want me to lose?

It profits when clients lose overall, which is a conflict of interest. Regulation requires fair pricing and execution regardless.

Why do brokers use a B-book?

It lets them earn the spread and the net client result, offer stable pricing, and avoid paying external providers for every small trade.

What happens if many B-book clients win?

The broker loses money. Brokers manage this by netting opposite trades, hedging large exposures and moving consistently profitable clients to the A-book.