Skip to content
Menu

Market Maker

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Worked example
  2. Why it matters to a trader
  3. Common confusions
  4. Related terms

A market maker is a firm that quotes both a buy and a sell price for an instrument and stands ready to trade at those prices, taking the other side of its clients' orders.

ECN / STP (agency model)Clientsends orderBrokerpasses it onLiquidityprovidersbanks, ECNsearns a commission or a small markupMarket maker (dealing desk)Clientsends orderBrokertakes theother sideHedges someexposure(optional)earns the spread; can gain when clients lose
An ECN or STP broker passes your order to outside liquidity providers, while a market maker fills it from its own book and takes the other side.

Worked example

Example: a market maker broker quotes EUR/USD at 1.0850 / 1.0852. One client buys 1 lot at 1.0852. Another sells 1 lot at 1.0850. The broker has matched the two internally and earned the 2-pip spread, about 20 US dollars, with no market risk.

Now suppose only buyers come in. The broker is left short. If the price rises, the broker loses on that exposure. It may then hedge part of it with a liquidity provider or adjust its prices.

Why it matters to a trader

Market makers can offer features that are harder for other models, such as fixed spreads, small minimum trade sizes, and prices on products that have little external liquidity. Execution can be instant, because the broker fills orders itself.

The main concern is the conflict of interest. When a broker keeps client trades on its own book, a client's loss can be its profit. Regulation, a clear order execution policy and fair handling of slippage and requotes are what keep this in check.

Common confusions

  • Market maker versus dealing desk. These terms are often used to mean the same thing. A dealing desk is the team or system a market maker uses to manage its book.
  • Market makers in exchanges. On exchanges, market makers supply liquidity to everyone, not just to their own clients.
  • B-book. Keeping trades in-house is also called B-book execution.

Where to practice this

Put this into practice on a demo account first, with no money at risk.

Frequently asked questions

Do market makers trade against their clients?

They take the opposite side of client trades, so a client's loss can be the broker's gain. Regulated market makers must still treat clients fairly and manage this conflict.

Are market maker brokers safe?

Safety depends mainly on regulation, segregated funds and financial strength, not on the execution model.

Why do market makers offer fixed spreads?

Because they set their own prices, they can choose to keep the spread constant, taking on the risk of market spreads widening.

Do market makers exist outside forex?

Yes. Market makers provide quotes on stock exchanges, options markets and many other venues, earning the spread for supplying liquidity.