Skip to content
Menu

Spreads and Commissions Explained: What Trading Really Costs

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. The spread
  2. Fixed and variable spreads
  3. Why spreads widen
  4. Commissions
  5. All-in cost per trade
  6. Other costs that affect your total
  7. Spreads on indices, commodities and shares
  8. Tracking your real costs
  9. How costs affect different trading styles
  10. How brokers present spreads
  11. Markups and how brokers earn
  12. Practical ways to reduce costs
  13. Common mistakes
  14. Key takeaways

Every trade has a cost, and for most forex and CFD traders it comes in two parts: the spread and, on some accounts, a commission. The spread is the gap between the buy and sell price; the commission is a separate fee per lot. Together with swaps and slippage, they make up your cost per trade. This guide explains how each works, why spreads change, how to compare account types, and how to work out your real cost.

The lesson Bid, ask and spread covers the basics.

The spread

A broker always shows two prices. The bid is the price at which you can sell. The ask is the price at which you can buy. The ask is higher, and the difference is the spread.

1.100201.100151.100101.100051.100001.099951.09990Spread1.0 pipAsk (offer)you buy hereBidyou sell hereExample
You buy at the higher ask and sell at the lower bid, so every trade starts by paying the spread.

Example: EUR/USD is quoted 1.10000 / 1.10012. The spread is 0.00012, or 1.2 pips. If you buy and close immediately at an unchanged market, you lose 1.2 pips.

You pay the spread once per round trip, because you buy at the ask and sell at the bid. A new trade starts with a small loss equal to the spread, which the market must cover before the trade is in profit.

Converting the spread into money

The money cost depends on the position size and the pip value.

Spread cost = spread in pips × pip value per lot × lots

Example: A 1.2-pip spread on 0.5 lots of EUR/USD, where one standard lot is worth about USD 10 per pip, costs 1.2 × 10 × 0.5 = USD 6.

Use the pip value calculator for other pairs and account currencies.

Fixed and variable spreads

Variable spreads change with market conditions. They are usually tighter in busy hours and wider in quiet or volatile periods. Most brokers and most account types use them.

Fixed spreads stay the same in normal conditions. They make costs predictable but are usually wider than average variable spreads, and brokers may still widen them or requote in extreme conditions.

Why spreads widen

Spreads reflect liquidity and risk. When fewer participants are quoting, or prices are moving fast, liquidity providers widen their quotes, and brokers pass this on. Common times for wider spreads:

  • Daily rollover, often around 5 pm New York time, when many liquidity providers adjust positions.
  • Major news releases, such as central bank decisions and employment data.
  • Weekly open on Sunday evening, before liquidity returns.
  • Holidays and quiet sessions.
  • Exotic pairs and less traded instruments at all times.

This is why the minimum spread a broker advertises matters less than the typical spread during the hours you trade.

Commissions

On raw spread accounts (often called ECN, Raw, Zero or Pro accounts), the broker shows spreads close to the wholesale market and charges a separate commission. The commission is usually a fixed amount per lot.

Commissions are quoted in different ways:

  • Per side per lot: charged when you open and again when you close.
  • Per round trip per lot: covers both opening and closing.
  • Per million notional: common at some brokers; convert to per lot.
  • In different currencies: USD, EUR, GBP or AUD, depending on account base currency.

Example: A commission of USD 3.50 per side per lot equals USD 7 per round trip. On EUR/USD, where one lot is worth about USD 10 per pip, USD 7 equals 0.7 pips.

For share CFDs and real shares, commissions are often a percentage of trade value with a minimum per trade.

All-in cost per trade

To compare accounts, add the spread and the commission and express them in the same unit, usually pips per round trip.

All-in cost (pips) = typical spread (pips) + round-trip commission ÷ pip value per lot
AccountTypical spreadCommission per round tripAll-in cost
Standard (example)1.1 pipsNone1.1 pips
Raw (example)0.2 pipsUSD 7 = 0.7 pips0.9 pips

In this example, the raw account is cheaper by 0.2 pips per trade. At 100 round trips of 1 lot a month, that is 20 pips, or about USD 200. These figures are illustrative; check each broker's current pricing.

The cost of trade calculator compares accounts for your own volume.

Other costs that affect your total

Spreads and commissions are not the only costs.

  • Swap: overnight financing on positions held past the daily cut-off. For swing traders it can exceed the spread. See swap and overnight fees.
  • Slippage: the difference between the expected and actual fill price. It can be negative or positive.
  • Currency conversion: when instruments are priced in a currency other than your account currency.
  • Funding fees: deposit, withdrawal and inactivity fees. See deposits and withdrawals.
  • Guaranteed stop premiums: paid if a guaranteed stop-loss is used or triggered, depending on the broker.

Spreads on indices, commodities and shares

Spreads work the same way on other instruments, but they are quoted in points or price units rather than pips, so you need the contract size to turn them into money.

Example (index CFD): A stock index CFD is quoted 7,500.0 / 7,501.0, a spread of 1 point. If one contract is worth USD 1 per point, a 2-contract trade costs USD 2 in spread. If the contract is worth USD 10 per point, the same trade costs USD 20.

Example (gold): Gold is quoted 2,300.10 / 2,300.40, a spread of 0.30. On a 100-ounce contract, that is USD 30 per lot. On a 1-ounce CFD unit, it is USD 0.30.

Index and commodity spreads often widen outside the main cash session of the underlying market. Share CFDs and real shares may have a commission instead of, or in addition to, a spread. Always check the contract specification before comparing costs across brokers. Our CFD trading guide explains contract specifications.

Tracking your real costs

The most accurate measure of your costs is your own trading history. Many platforms show the commission per trade, and you can record the spread at entry in your journal. Over a month, add up:

  • Total spread paid (estimated from entry spreads).
  • Total commission.
  • Total swaps paid and received.
  • Any slippage on stops and market orders.

Divide by the number of trades to get your average cost per trade, and express it as a share of your average risk per trade. If costs are a large share of your risk, look at your timing, instrument choice or account type. A trading journal makes this a quick monthly check.

How costs affect different trading styles

Costs matter more the shorter your trades.

Example: Three traders each pay a 1-pip all-in cost. A scalper targets 5 pips, so costs take 20% of the target. A day trader targets 30 pips, so costs take about 3%. A swing trader targets 200 pips, so costs take 0.5%, though swaps may add more.

This is why scalpers and day traders usually prefer raw spread accounts, while swing traders pay more attention to swap rates. Costs also affect the break-even win rate of any strategy. See Risk-reward and win rate.

How brokers present spreads

Brokers publish spreads in different ways, which can make comparisons misleading.

  • Minimum spread ("from 0.0 pips"): the tightest moment, not what you will usually pay.
  • Average spread: averaged over a period; check whether it includes quiet hours and news.
  • Typical spread: the broker's estimate of normal conditions.
  • Live spread: shown on the platform at that moment.

The most reliable approach is to look at average spreads during your own trading hours, ideally from the broker's published data and your own observations on a demo or small live account. Our broker reviews show published averages where available, and the low-spread brokers list groups brokers by typical cost.

Markups and how brokers earn

Brokers earn from spreads, commissions or both. A market maker includes its revenue in a wider spread. A broker that routes orders to liquidity providers may add a small markup to the raw spread, charge a commission, or both. Neither approach is better in itself; what matters is the all-in cost. Read ECN vs market maker.

Some brokers also offer volume discounts on commissions, or rebates through partner programs. See cashback and rebates.

Practical ways to reduce costs

  1. Trade liquid instruments such as major pairs and major indices.
  2. Trade during active sessions, when spreads are tightest. See best time to trade forex.
  3. Avoid the rollover period and news releases unless your strategy requires it.
  4. Choose the right account type for your volume. See forex account types explained.
  5. Use limit orders where appropriate, to avoid paying more than planned.
  6. Trade less often if costs are eating your edge.
  7. Use an account in your deposit currency to avoid conversion fees.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing minimum spreads instead of typical spreads.
  • Forgetting to add commission when comparing raw and standard accounts.
  • Mixing per-side and round-trip commission figures.
  • Ignoring swaps on positions held for weeks.
  • Trading exotic pairs with short-term targets.

Key takeaways

  • The spread is the gap between bid and ask, paid once per round trip.
  • Raw spread accounts add a commission; compare the all-in cost in pips.
  • Spreads widen at rollover, around news, at the weekly open and on exotics.
  • Typical spreads during your trading hours matter more than minimums.
  • Short-term traders are most affected by costs; swing traders by swaps.

Compare costs across brokers with the comparison tool and our how to choose a forex broker guide.

Low-cost brokers for active trading

Put this into practice on a demo account first, with no money at risk.

Frequently asked questions

What is a spread in trading?

The spread is the difference between the bid price, where you can sell, and the ask price, where you can buy. You pay it every time you open a trade, so it is the main cost on most accounts.

Why do spreads widen?

Spreads widen when liquidity falls or volatility rises, such as around major news, at the daily rollover, during holidays and at the weekly open. Liquidity providers quote wider prices to protect themselves.

Is a commission account cheaper than a spread-only account?

Often for active traders on liquid pairs, but not always. Add the typical raw spread and the round-trip commission, convert both to pips, and compare with the spread-only account's typical spread.

What is the difference between minimum and average spread?

The minimum spread is the tightest the broker quotes at its best moments. The average or typical spread is what you are likely to pay over normal trading hours, which is more useful for comparing costs.

Are fixed spreads better than variable spreads?

Fixed spreads make costs predictable in normal conditions but are usually wider on average. Variable spreads are often tighter but can widen sharply in fast markets.

Do I pay the spread when I close a trade?

The spread is effectively paid once per round trip. You buy at the ask and sell at the bid, so the gap between them is the cost of opening and closing the position.