Skip to content
Menu

Trading Journal: What to Record and How to Review It

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Why keep a journal
  2. What to record
  3. Measuring in R
  4. Key statistics
  5. Running a weekly review
  6. Running a monthly review
  7. A worked monthly review
  8. Journaling your psychology
  9. Turning findings into rules
  10. Behavioral patterns to look for
  11. Spreadsheet or software?
  12. Journaling for different styles
  13. Common journaling mistakes
  14. Key takeaways

A trading journal is a record of every trade you take: what you traded, why, how much you risked, how it ended, and how you behaved. It is the single most useful tool for improving as a trader, because it turns memory and impressions into data you can review. This guide explains what to record, how to measure results, how to run weekly and monthly reviews, and how to turn findings into changes to your plan.

The lessons Trading journal and Psychology journal cover the risk and behavioral sides in lesson form.

Why keep a journal

Memory is unreliable. Traders remember big wins and painful losses but forget the many ordinary trades that decide results. They also remember their reasons more favorably than they were at the time. A journal fixes both problems.

A journal helps you:

  • See whether your strategy has a positive expectancy after costs.
  • Find which setups, markets or times work best and worst.
  • Measure rule compliance, separately from profit.
  • Spot behavioral patterns, such as trading more after losses.
  • Make plan changes based on evidence rather than mood.

What to record

Record the same fields for every trade. Consistency matters more than detail.

Trade data

FieldExample
Date and time (entry and exit)12 March, 09:15 to 14:40
InstrumentEUR/USD
DirectionLong
Setup nameTrend pullback
Timeframe1-hour
Entry price1.0852
Stop-loss1.0827
Take-profit1.0902
Position size0.4 lots
Risk in moneyUSD 100
Exit price and reason1.0902, target hit
Result in money+USD 200
Result in R+2.0R
Costs (spread, commission, swap)USD 6

Context

  • Higher timeframe trend and key levels.
  • Relevant news or events.
  • Session (Asian, London, New York).
  • Market condition: trending, ranging or volatile.

Screenshots

Take a screenshot at entry, showing the setup, levels, stop and target, and another at exit. Screenshots are the fastest way to review whether a trade matched your rules.

Behavior and compliance

  • Did the trade match the plan? Yes or no.
  • If not, which rule was broken and why.
  • Emotional state before and during the trade, briefly.
  • Any changes made to the trade after entry, and whether the plan allowed them.

Measuring in R

R is the amount you risked on a trade, the distance from entry to stop multiplied by position size. Expressing results in R makes trades comparable regardless of size or account balance.

  • A trade that gains twice the risk is +2R.
  • A trade stopped out at the full stop is −1R.
  • A trade closed early at half the risk is −0.5R.

Example: Over 20 trades, a trader records +2R, −1R, −1R, +1.5R, −1R, +2.5R, and so on. The total is +6R. Divided by 20 trades, the average is +0.3R per trade. If each R was USD 100, that is about USD 600 over the period before costs.

Example+2R+1R0R-1Rfull stop = −1RTotal +6R over 20 trades = +0.3R per tradeAt 100 USD per R: about 600 USD before costs
Measuring each trade in R, the amount risked, makes results comparable; any bar below −1R would mean a stop was moved, a gap or large slippage.

Measuring in R also shows whether losses are controlled. Any loss larger than −1R means a stop was moved, slippage was large, or a gap occurred, all worth investigating. The lesson Risk-reward and win rate explains how R connects to win rate and expectancy.

Key statistics

Calculate these monthly, or after a set number of trades:

  • Number of trades.
  • Win rate: winning trades ÷ total trades.
  • Average win and average loss, in R.
  • Expectancy: (win rate × average win) − (loss rate × average loss).
  • Total R and total money result.
  • Maximum drawdown: largest fall from a peak.
  • Longest losing streak.
  • Rule compliance: share of trades that followed the plan.
  • Costs as a share of total risk.

Then break them down by setup, instrument, session and day of the week. That is where the most useful findings usually appear.

Running a weekly review

A weekly review takes 30 to 60 minutes. A simple structure:

  1. Check compliance. Count trades that broke the plan. Read the notes on each.
  2. Review screenshots. For each trade, ask whether it matched the setup description exactly.
  3. Look at missed trades. Setups that met the rules but were not taken.
  4. Note one thing to keep and one thing to improve.
  5. Check the calendar for next week and plan around major events.

The weekly review is mainly about behavior. Results over one week are too few to judge a strategy.

Running a monthly review

The monthly review is about the numbers:

  1. Calculate the statistics above, overall and by setup.
  2. Compare with previous months and with backtest or demo results.
  3. Check costs: are spreads, commissions or swaps taking a large share?
  4. Look for patterns: times of day, days of the week, instruments or market conditions that perform differently.
  5. Decide on changes, if any, and write them into the trading plan.

Change only one thing at a time, so you can measure its effect.

A worked monthly review

The figures below are illustrative. At the end of the month, a day trader's journal shows 42 trades across two setups.

Overall: win rate 45%, average win +1.8R, average loss −1.0R. Expectancy is (0.45 × 1.8) − (0.55 × 1.0) = 0.81 − 0.55 = +0.26R per trade before costs. Costs average 0.08R per trade, so net expectancy is about +0.18R. Total for the month is about +7.6R. Rule compliance is 81%: 34 trades followed the plan, 8 did not.

By setup: the opening range breakout has 18 trades with a net expectancy close to zero. The trend pullback has 24 trades with a net expectancy of about +0.32R.

By compliance: the 34 compliant trades have a net expectancy of about +0.33R, or about +11.1R in total. The 8 non-compliant trades total −3.5R, mostly from trades taken after two earlier losses on the same day.

Conclusions:

  1. The trend pullback setup carries the results. Keep it unchanged.
  2. The breakout setup is flat so far. Keep trading it at half size for another month, or move it to demo for testing.
  3. Rule breaks cost about 3.5R. Add a rule: stop for the day after two losses.

One month is a small sample, so these are working conclusions, not final ones. But they turn a vague feeling, "this month was okay", into specific actions.

Journaling your psychology

Numbers show what happened. Notes on your state of mind show why. A short behavioral entry for each session is enough:

  • How did I feel before the session: rested, rushed, frustrated?
  • Did anything outside trading affect my focus?
  • Was there a moment I wanted to break a rule? Did I?
  • What did I do after a loss or a win?

Over time, these notes often explain the trades that broke the plan. A trader might find that most rule breaks happen on days with little sleep, or after checking social media during the session. Those findings lead to practical fixes, such as not trading when tired or turning off notifications. The psychology journal lesson offers a fuller template.

Turning findings into rules

Journal findings are useful only if they change behavior. Examples of findings and responses:

  • Finding: Most losses come from trades taken in the last hour of the session. Response: No new trades in the last hour.
  • Finding: Trades taken after two consecutive losses have a much worse average R. Response: Stop for the day after two losses.
  • Finding: One setup has a negative expectancy after 40 trades while another is positive. Response: Drop the first setup or test a changed version on demo.
  • Finding: Losses beyond −1R happen when stops are moved. Response: Stops placed at entry; any stop move must be in the plan.
One changeat a timeRecordevery tradeReviewweeklyFinda patternWriteone ruleTest itthen record
A journal only helps when findings change behavior: each review should produce at most one new rule, which is then tested and recorded.

Behavioral patterns to look for

  • Trading more frequently after a loss (revenge trading).
  • Taking unplanned trades on fast-moving days (FOMO).
  • Cutting winners early and letting losers run (loss aversion).
  • Increasing size after a winning streak.
  • Overtrading on days with no clear setups (overtrading).

The Trading Psychology course covers each pattern and practical fixes.

Spreadsheet or software?

Spreadsheet: free, flexible, and you control every field. Use one row per trade and separate columns for each field. Add formulas for R, win rate and expectancy. Store screenshots in a folder named by date and trade number.

Journaling software: can import trades automatically from your platform, calculate statistics and display charts. Check how it handles costs, R calculations and privacy of your trading data.

Many traders start with a spreadsheet and move to software once they know which fields they use.

Journaling for different styles

  • Scalpers take many trades, so automate data capture where possible and review samples of screenshots rather than every trade. Track spread at entry and slippage closely. See our scalping guide.
  • Day traders benefit from noting session conditions and news. See our day trading guide.
  • Swing traders take fewer trades, so record more context, including swaps and fundamental backdrop. See our swing trading guide.
  • Prop traders should record distance to the daily loss limit and maximum drawdown after each trade. See our prop trading guide.
  • Copy traders can journal provider behavior: trade sizes, drawdowns and changes in style. See our copy trading guide.

Common journaling mistakes

  • Recording only some trades, usually the good ones.
  • Recording results but not reasons and compliance.
  • Measuring only in money, not in R.
  • Never reviewing the journal.
  • Changing the plan after every review instead of waiting for enough trades.

Key takeaways

  • Record every trade with the same fields, including screenshots and compliance.
  • Measure results in R to compare trades fairly.
  • Review weekly for behavior and monthly for statistics.
  • Break results down by setup, instrument and time to find what works.
  • Turn findings into specific rule changes, one at a time.

Where to practice this

Put this into practice on a demo account first, with no money at risk.

Frequently asked questions

What is a trading journal?

A trading journal is a record of every trade you take, including the setup, entry, exit, risk, result, screenshots and notes on your thinking and behavior. It is the main tool for finding out what works and what does not.

What should I record in a trading journal?

At minimum, the date, instrument, direction, setup, entry, stop, target, position size, risk, exit, result in money and in R, costs, a screenshot, and whether you followed your plan.

Should I use a spreadsheet or journaling software?

Either works. A spreadsheet is free and flexible. Journaling software can import trades automatically and calculate statistics. The important part is recording every trade consistently and reviewing it.

How often should I review my journal?

Briefly after each session, in more depth weekly, and with full statistics monthly. Reviews should focus on rule compliance as well as results.

What does measuring in R mean?

R is the amount you risked on a trade. A trade that makes twice the risked amount is +2R, and a full loss is -1R. Measuring in R makes results comparable across different position sizes and account balances.

How many trades do I need before drawing conclusions?

The more the better, because small samples are dominated by luck. Many traders wait for several dozen trades per setup before deciding whether it works.