Overtrading: When More Trades Mean Worse Results
By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated
On this page
In this lesson you will learn
- Define overtrading in terms of trade frequency and trade quality
- Explain how extra trades raise costs and lower average trade quality
- Recognize the triggers that lead to overtrading
- Set daily trade limits and setup criteria that keep trading selective
The previous lessons covered emotions that affect a single trade. This lesson looks at a pattern across many trades: overtrading. You will learn what it is, why it happens, how it quietly raises costs and lowers trade quality, and which limits keep your trading selective.
What overtrading means
Overtrading is taking more trades than your plan supports. It has two forms:
- Too many trades: trading far more often than your strategy produces valid setups.
- Trades outside the plan: taking setups that do not meet your rules, in markets or at times you did not plan to trade.
The number of trades on its own does not define overtrading. A scalping plan may call for many trades a day. The problem is trading more than your plan calls for, or taking trades that do not match it.
Why traders overtrade
Common triggers include:
- Boredom. Markets spend a lot of time doing nothing useful. Watching charts for hours without a trade feels like wasted time.
- The urge to be busy. Many people feel that more activity means more progress. In trading, waiting is part of the work.
- Chasing a target. A trader wants to make a set amount today and keeps trading until they reach it.
- Recovering a loss. After a losing trade, the next trade feels urgent. The revenge trading lesson covers this in detail.
- Excitement after wins. Confidence rises and standards drop.
- Too many markets or screens. The more charts you watch, the more "almost setups" you see.
How overtrading damages results
Overtrading hurts in two ways at once.
Costs rise. Every trade pays a spread, often a commission, and sometimes slippage. Positions held overnight may pay a swap. These costs are paid whether the trade wins or loses.
Worked example (illustrative numbers): a trader's average cost is 8 US dollars per trade. Their plan produces about 20 trades a month, costing 160 US dollars. Overtrading adds 30 extra trades, adding 240 US dollars of costs. The extra trades must make more than 240 US dollars just to break even. You can estimate your own costs with the cost of trade calculator.
Quality falls. Your best setups are limited. When you take more trades, the extra ones are usually lower quality: weaker signals, poorer timing, worse markets. Your average result per trade falls, even if your best trades are as good as before.
Warning signs
You may be overtrading if you notice that:
- you trade more on days you feel bored or restless
- you cannot explain which rule a trade met when you look at it later
- you trade markets or sessions that are not in your plan
- your number of trades rises sharply on losing days
- you feel uneasy when you have no open positions
- your costs are a large share of your gross profit or loss
The journal is the best tool here. Count your trades per day and mark which ones met every rule. The pattern is usually clear within a few weeks.
Limits that keep trading selective
The fix is to decide in advance what a tradable setup looks like and how many trades you allow.
- Write a setup checklist. List the exact conditions that must be true before you enter. If any one is missing, there is no trade. The technical analysis course shows how to build a rule-based setup.
- Set a maximum number of trades per day. For example, a maximum of three trades in a session. When you hit the limit, you are done for the day.
- Set trading hours. Trade only in the sessions you planned, and close the platform outside them.
- Limit your watchlist. Follow a small number of markets you know well.
- Use alerts instead of watching. Set price alerts at your levels and leave the screen. You return only when the market comes to you.
- Add a waiting rule. For example, wait five minutes after spotting a setup and re-check the checklist before entering.
Grade your setups
Another useful habit is to grade each setup before you enter it. An A-grade setup meets every rule and has a clear stop and target. A B-grade setup meets the rules but has a weakness, such as nearby resistance. Anything less is not a trade. Over time, your journal will show whether B-grade setups add anything after costs. Many traders find that cutting them reduces trade count and improves the average result.
What to do with the time
If you are not trading, you still have useful work: reviewing past trades, updating your journal, backtesting, reading the economic calendar or preparing levels for the next session. Treating these as part of the job reduces the feeling that a day without trades is a wasted day.
A note on costs and trading style
Some styles are more exposed to overtrading than others. Short-term styles such as day trading and scalping involve many small trades, so costs per trade matter a great deal and discipline about trade count is essential. Longer-term styles trade less often, but traders can still overtrade by checking positions constantly and closing them early. The day trading course covers trade frequency in more detail.
Key takeaways
- Overtrading means taking more trades than your plan supports, or trades that do not meet it.
- Boredom, targets, losses and excitement are the usual triggers.
- Extra trades add costs on every trade and lower the average quality of your trades.
- A written setup checklist, a daily trade limit and set hours are the main defenses.
- A day with no trades because no setup appeared is a day you followed your plan.
Check your understanding
1. Which is the best definition of overtrading?
- A. Trading more than once a week
- B. Taking trades that do not meet your plan, or trading more than your plan allows
- C. Using a stop-loss on every trade
- D. Holding trades overnight
Show answer
B. Taking trades that do not meet your plan, or trading more than your plan allows
2. A trader pays 8 US dollars in costs per trade. How much do 30 extra trades in a month cost before any profit or loss?
- A. 80 US dollars
- B. 160 US dollars
- C. 240 US dollars
- D. 300 US dollars
Show answer
C. 240 US dollars
3. Which rule directly limits overtrading?
- A. A maximum number of trades per day
- B. Using a bigger screen
- C. Trading every session
- D. Removing take-profit orders
Show answer
A. A maximum number of trades per day
Where to practice this
Put this into practice on a demo account first, with no money at risk.
- Featured broker
Pepperstone4.7 / 5Visit
IC Markets4.9 / 5Visit
GO Markets4.8 / 5Visit