Skip to content
Menu

Fear and Greed in Trading

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Two sides of the same problem
  2. What fear makes traders do
  3. What greed makes traders do
  4. How both emotions break the numbers
  5. Signs that an emotion is in control
  6. Rules that reduce fear and greed
  7. A short exercise
  8. Key takeaways

In this lesson you will learn

  • Recognize the actions that fear and greed produce on the platform
  • Explain how both emotions damage the balance between winners and losers
  • Use pre-set orders and fixed size to reduce emotional exits
  • Notice the physical and mental signs that an emotion is in control

The first lesson showed that emotions turn into actions on the platform. This lesson looks at the two oldest emotions in markets, fear and greed. You will see what each one makes traders do, how both damage the balance between winners and losers, and which simple rules reduce their influence.

Two sides of the same problem

Fear and greed are often described as opposites, but in trading they cause the same kind of damage. Both push you to change a trade after you entered it, based on how you feel rather than on what the plan says. Fear makes you want to escape risk. Greed makes you want more reward than the plan allows.

Neither emotion is a flaw to remove. Fear is useful when it stops you from risking money you cannot afford to lose. The problem starts when fear or greed overrides rules you set when you were calm.

What fear makes traders do

Fear shows up in several ways:

  • Not taking valid setups. After a few losses, a trader sees a signal that matches the plan and hesitates until the move has gone.
  • Closing winners too early. A trade moves into profit, then pulls back a little, and the trader closes it to protect the gain, far short of the planned take-profit.
  • Tightening the stop too soon. The stop-loss is moved to break-even before the trade has room to work, and normal price noise closes it.
  • Trading too small to matter. Size is cut so far that the trader stops caring about following the rules.

Fear is strongest after losses and when position size is too large compared with the account. If every tick feels important, size is usually the root cause.

What greed makes traders do

Greed shows up differently:

  • Increasing size after wins. A good week makes the trader feel skilled, and risk per trade creeps up without a written decision.
  • Removing the take-profit. The trade hits the target, but the trader wants more and lets it run without a plan for the exit.
  • Adding to positions without rules. Extra entries are added to a winning trade because it "feels strong."
  • Using too much leverage. Leverage makes large positions possible with a small deposit, which feeds the urge to make a lot quickly.

Greed is strongest after wins and when a trader has a money target, such as wanting to make a fixed amount by Friday.

How both emotions break the numbers

Every plan relies on a relationship between the average size of winners and the average size of losers. Fear and greed attack that relationship from both sides.

Worked example (illustrative numbers): a plan risks 100 US dollars per trade and aims for 200 US dollars on winners. The plan wins 4 trades out of 10.

  • As planned: 4 × 200 − 6 × 100 = +200 US dollars over 10 trades.
  • With fear, winners are closed at 100 instead of 200: 4 × 100 − 6 × 100 = −200 US dollars.
  • With fear on winners and hope on losers, losers grow to 150: 4 × 100 − 6 × 150 = −500 US dollars.

The entries and the win rate did not change. Only the exits changed, and a plan that was positive on paper became negative. You can test your own numbers with the risk-reward calculator.

Signs that an emotion is in control

It helps to recognize the moment before the mistake. Common signs include:

  • watching every tick of a single trade instead of the wider chart
  • a tight chest, faster breathing or restlessness
  • talking to the screen or to yourself about what the price "should" do
  • wanting to check the profit and loss figure rather than the chart
  • thinking about what you could buy with the profit, or how bad the loss would be

None of these means you must close the trade. They mean you should not make a new decision about it until you have stepped back.

Rules that reduce fear and greed

The best protection is to make decisions before the trade, when you are calm, and to make changes during the trade hard.

  1. Set the stop and target when you enter. Place both as orders on the platform, not as plans in your head.
  2. Fix the risk per trade in writing. For example, a set small percentage of the account. The position size calculator turns that into a lot size.
  3. Define the only allowed changes. For example: "I may move the stop to break-even once price has moved one times my risk in my favor. I may not move the stop further away." A trailing stop can follow this rule automatically.
  4. Step away after entry. If you cannot watch without interfering, set alerts and close the chart.
  5. Change size only at set review points. For example, review risk once a month, never in the middle of a session.

A short exercise

On your next ten demo or live trades, write down two numbers for each: the planned exit and the actual exit. If your actual winners are regularly smaller than planned, fear is cutting them. If your actual losers are larger than planned, hope or greed is stretching them. Both patterns are fixable once you can see them, and the journaling lesson shows how to track them over time.

Key takeaways

  • Fear and greed both make traders change a trade after entry for emotional reasons.
  • Fear cuts winners, delays entries and tightens stops too soon; greed raises size and removes exits.
  • Changing only the exits can turn a positive plan into a losing one.
  • Set the stop, target and size before entry, and write down the only changes you allow.
  • Large position size makes both emotions stronger, so keep risk per trade small and fixed.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which action is most typical of fear?

    • A. Adding to a winning trade without a plan
    • B. Closing a winning trade early to lock in a small gain
    • C. Doubling size after a winning week
    • D. Removing the take-profit to let a trade run forever
    Show answer

    B. Closing a winning trade early to lock in a small gain

  2. 2. Your plan aims for winners twice the size of losers, but fear makes you close winners at half the planned distance. What happens to the ratio?

    • A. It stays at 2:1
    • B. It falls to about 1:1
    • C. It rises to 4:1
    • D. It has no effect
    Show answer

    B. It falls to about 1:1

  3. 3. What is a practical defense against greed-driven size increases?

    • A. A fixed percentage risk rule written before the session
    • B. Trading only on Fridays
    • C. Using higher leverage
    • D. Turning off the stop-loss
    Show answer

    A. A fixed percentage risk rule written before the session

Where to practice this

Put this into practice on a demo account first, with no money at risk.