Skip to content
Menu

Confirmation Bias and Other Thinking Traps

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. What confirmation bias is
  2. How it shows up
  3. Other common thinking traps
  4. Worked example: a one-sided analysis
  5. The counter-case habit
  6. Use checklists, not impressions
  7. Judge your strategy on enough trades
  8. Look for disagreement on purpose
  9. Key takeaways

In this lesson you will learn

  • Define confirmation bias and explain how it affects analysis
  • Recognize anchoring, recency bias and overconfidence
  • Write a counter-case and an invalidation level for every trade idea
  • Use checklists to reduce the effect of bias on decisions

The earlier lessons looked at emotions such as fear, greed and FOMO. This lesson moves to thinking errors, called cognitive biases, which affect your analysis before you even place a trade. The main one is confirmation bias. You will also meet anchoring, recency bias and overconfidence, and learn simple habits that keep your analysis honest.

What confirmation bias is

Confirmation bias is the tendency to look for, notice and remember information that supports what you already believe, and to ignore or explain away information that does not.

In trading, it often starts with a view: "this market is going up." From then on, every bullish signal looks important and every bearish signal looks like noise. The trader feels they are doing careful analysis, but they are really collecting reasons to agree with themselves.

How it shows up

  • Indicator shopping. Adding indicators until one agrees with your view, then ignoring the ones that do not.
  • Timeframe shopping. Switching to a different chart timeframe until the picture matches your idea.
  • Selective news. Reading only the articles that support your position.
  • Explaining away losses. Treating every loss as bad luck or "manipulation" rather than as information.
  • Echo chambers. Following only traders and groups who share your view on a market.

Confirmation bias is most dangerous when you already have a position. Once money is on the line, the brain works even harder to protect the belief behind it.

Other common thinking traps

Several related biases often appear together.

Anchoring. Relying too much on one number you saw first. A trader who bought at 1.2000 may treat that price as meaningful long after the market has moved on. Another may expect price to "return to" an old high just because the number is familiar.

Recency bias. Giving too much weight to what happened most recently. After three winning trades, a strategy feels perfect. After three losses, it feels broken. Neither conclusion is supported by so few trades.

Overconfidence. Overrating your own skill or the accuracy of your forecasts, often after a good run. It leads to larger size and fewer checks.

Hindsight bias. Believing, after the fact, that a move was obvious. "I knew it would fall." This makes past mistakes look like near-misses and hides how uncertain the decision really was.

Worked example: a one-sided analysis

Illustrative example: a trader thinks a currency pair will rise. They note that price is above a moving average, that a support level held twice, and that a bullish candlestick formed. All three are real.

What they missed: the higher timeframe is in a downtrend, price is just below a strong resistance level, and a major economic release is due in an hour. A balanced analysis would weigh all six facts. The one-sided version only weighed the three that matched the view.

Neither version guarantees the outcome. The point is that the balanced version shows the real level of uncertainty, which affects whether to trade and what size to use.

The counter-case habit

The most effective defense is to argue against yourself on purpose. Before every trade, write down:

  1. The case for the trade: the reasons that match your setup rules.
  2. The case against: the strongest reasons the trade could fail. Look at the higher timeframe, nearby support and resistance, upcoming news and the current trend.
  3. The invalidation level: the price that would prove the idea wrong. This is usually where your stop-loss belongs.

If you cannot think of any case against, you have not looked hard enough. Every trade has a reason it could fail. If the case against is stronger than the case for, the right choice may be a smaller position or no trade at all.

Use checklists, not impressions

Biases thrive when decisions are based on overall impressions. A written checklist forces the same questions every time, whether you feel bullish or bearish. A simple version:

  • Does the setup meet every rule in my plan?
  • What does the higher timeframe show?
  • Is there major news due during the trade?
  • Where is the trade proven wrong?
  • What is the risk-reward to the first logical target?

The technical analysis course covers the chart side of these checks, and the fundamental analysis course covers the news side.

Judge your strategy on enough trades

Recency bias and overconfidence feed on small samples. Decide in advance how many trades you need before you judge a method, for example a fixed number such as 50 or 100 trades, and do not change the rules before then unless a clear error appears. Backtesting helps you see how a method behaves over a long series of trades rather than the last few.

Look for disagreement on purpose

If you follow other traders, include some who think differently. If you read analysis, read the opposite view too. The aim is not to be persuaded by every argument but to make sure you have seen the strongest argument against your trade before you risk money on it.

Key takeaways

  • Confirmation bias makes you favor information that supports your existing view.
  • Anchoring, recency bias, overconfidence and hindsight bias often appear alongside it.
  • Write a case against every trade and define the price that proves the idea wrong.
  • Checklists force the same questions every time and reduce the effect of impressions.
  • Judge a method on a planned number of trades, not on the last few results.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What is confirmation bias?

    • A. Waiting for a candle to close before entering
    • B. Seeking and favoring information that supports what you already believe
    • C. Using two indicators instead of one
    • D. Checking the economic calendar
    Show answer

    B. Seeking and favoring information that supports what you already believe

  2. 2. Which question best tests a trade idea against confirmation bias?

    • A. How much can I make?
    • B. What would prove this idea wrong?
    • C. Who else agrees with me?
    • D. How fast can I enter?
    Show answer

    B. What would prove this idea wrong?

  3. 3. A trader believes a price 'must' return to last month's high because that number sticks in their mind. Which bias is this?

    • A. Anchoring
    • B. Loss aversion
    • C. Revenge trading
    • D. Diversification
    Show answer

    A. Anchoring

Where to practice this

Put this into practice on a demo account first, with no money at risk.