Skip to content
Menu

Reviewing Day Trading Performance

By Chad Smith, Director of Research & Analysis · Updated

On this page
  1. Why review matters
  2. Core measures
  3. Costs
  4. Rule-following
  5. Break results down
  6. Look at execution
  7. The review schedule
  8. Make one change at a time
  9. When to stop or step back
  10. Key takeaways

In this lesson you will learn

  • Calculate win rate, average win, average loss and expectancy
  • Measure drawdown, costs and rule-following
  • Break results down by setup, market and time of day
  • Run a monthly review that leads to one clear change

This final lesson closes the loop. You have a plan, and you are trading it. Now you need to know whether it works and how to improve it. You will learn the key performance measures, how to break results down to find what is working, how to measure rule-following, and how to run a review that leads to clear, testable changes.

Why review matters

Without review, you only have impressions, and impressions are distorted by the last few trades. The confirmation bias lesson explains how recency bias and selective memory affect judgment. A structured review uses your full record instead.

Core measures

Use net results, after spread, commission and slippage.

Win rate

Win rate = winning trades ÷ total trades × 100

Average win and average loss

Total money from winning trades divided by the number of winners, and the same for losers.

Profit factor

Profit factor = gross profit ÷ gross loss

A value above 1 means profits exceeded losses over the period.

Expectancy

Expectancy is the average result per trade:

Expectancy = (win rate × average win) − (loss rate × average loss)

Worked example (illustrative numbers): 50 trades, 20 winners and 30 losers. Average win 150 US dollars, average loss 80 US dollars.

  • Win rate: 40%
  • Expectancy: (0.40 × 150) − (0.60 × 80) = 60 − 48 = +12 US dollars per trade
  • Gross profit: 20 × 150 = 3,000; gross loss: 30 × 80 = 2,400; profit factor 1.25
Example50 tradesWinners20Losers30Average win150Average loss80ResultsWin rate40%0.40 × 150+600.60 × 80−48Gross profit / loss3,000 / 2,400Profit factor1.25Expectancy+12 per trade
A 40% win rate can still be profitable: wins that are larger than losses give a positive expectancy and a profit factor above 1.

A positive expectancy over a reasonable number of trades is a good sign, but a small sample can mislead. Judge over the number of trades you set in advance, such as 50 or 100.

Results in R

Many traders express results in R, where 1R is the amount risked per trade. A win of 150 with 75 risked is +2R. Using R makes results comparable even if account size changes.

Drawdown

Maximum drawdown is the largest fall in equity from a peak to a low. It shows how painful the strategy is to trade and whether your risk limits are working. Also note the longest losing streak.

Costs

From the costs lesson, record:

  • gross result before costs
  • total costs
  • net result
  • costs as a share of gross profit

If costs take a large share of gross profit, look at trade count, trading times and account type.

Rule-following

Track two numbers each month:

  • Plan adherence: the share of trades that followed every rule.
  • Results by adherence: net result of plan-following trades versus rule-breaking trades.

Worked example (illustrative numbers): 60 trades. 48 followed the plan and made +900 US dollars. 12 broke the plan and lost −700 US dollars. The fix is clear: behavior, not strategy. The journaling lesson shows how to find the triggers behind rule breaks.

Break results down

Totals hide detail. Sort your trades by:

  • Setup: which setups make money and which do not?
  • Market: is one market dragging results down?
  • Time of day: are certain hours consistently poor?
  • Day of week: do some days produce more mistakes?
  • Direction: are long and short trades very different?
  • Trade management: did moving stops to break-even help or hurt?

Worked example (illustrative numbers): setup A produced +1,200 over 30 trades; setup B produced −300 over 25 trades. Trades in the first 15 minutes of the session lost −400 in total. Two possible changes appear: drop or rework setup B, or stop trading the first 15 minutes. Test one first.

Look at execution

Compare planned and actual prices:

  • Was slippage larger at certain times?
  • Were exits taken early, before the target or the stop-loss?
  • Did any trade lose more than 1R? If so, why?

Losses larger than 1R usually point to a stop moved, a gap, or a sizing error, and each has a different fix.

The review schedule

  • Daily: journal each trade and rate rule-following. Five to fifteen minutes.
  • Weekly: count trades, net result, adherence and rule breaks. Pick one behavior to focus on next week.
  • Monthly: full measures, breakdowns, costs and drawdown. Decide on at most one change to the plan.
  • Quarterly: larger strategy review on a bigger sample.

Make one change at a time

If you change several things at once, you cannot tell which helped. A good review ends with one clear change, written into the plan, with a date to review its effect. Examples:

  • remove a setup that has lost money over a large sample
  • add a rule to avoid a poor time of day
  • reduce the maximum trades per day
  • move to a lower-cost account type

When to stop or step back

Consider stepping back to demo, or pausing, if:

  • expectancy has been negative over a large sample, even with good rule-following
  • you hit your monthly loss limit
  • rule-following falls and does not recover

Stepping back is a normal part of the process, not a failure. Day trading is difficult, and many people find that a slower style suits them better. The stock trading course and trading psychology course offer alternatives and support.

Key takeaways

  • Review with full records, not impressions, using net results after costs.
  • Track win rate, average win and loss, expectancy, profit factor, R multiples and drawdown.
  • Measure rule-following and compare results of plan-following and rule-breaking trades.
  • Break results down by setup, market and time to find what works.
  • Make one change at a time, at planned review points, and step back when the evidence says so.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Win rate 40%, average win 150 US dollars, average loss 80 US dollars. What is the expectancy per trade?

    • A. -12 US dollars
    • B. +12 US dollars
    • C. +60 US dollars
    • D. +70 US dollars
    Show answer

    B. +12 US dollars

  2. 2. Why break results down by setup?

    • A. To find which setups add value and which lose money
    • B. To make the journal longer
    • C. Because brokers require it
    • D. It has no use
    Show answer

    A. To find which setups add value and which lose money

  3. 3. How many changes should a monthly review usually lead to?

    • A. As many as possible
    • B. One clear change, so its effect can be measured
    • C. None ever
    • D. A full new strategy every month
    Show answer

    B. One clear change, so its effect can be measured

Low-cost brokers for active trading

Put this into practice on a demo account first, with no money at risk.